Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-10 Thread WebbedIT
I find you insistence that in no normal circumstances could massl have a point (which is how I understand your replies to this thread) - a bit weird. Firstly, I certainly did not intend to say massl could not have a point under any circumstance. So apologies if I came across as dismissive in

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-09 Thread AD7six
On May 7, 3:46 pm, WebbedIT p...@webbedit.co.uk wrote: I guess you've never heard of black hat seo techniques. Yip, certainly have Report them for what - most of the time we're talking about typos A typo wouldn't lead to this issue, a typo would lead to your domain or main parameters

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-07 Thread WebbedIT
@AD7six: I'm not sure why that was necessary as I implied in my reply that the only way Google would find incorrect links to index was if someone maliciously posted erroneous links, but that would have to be a very rare situation to be in and you could easily find out which site they had come from

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-07 Thread AD7six
On May 7, 10:32 am, WebbedIT p...@webbedit.co.uk wrote: @AD7six: I'm not sure why that was necessary as I implied in my reply that the only way Google would find incorrect links to index was if someone maliciously posted erroneous links, but that would have to be a very rare situation to be

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-07 Thread WebbedIT
I guess you've never heard of black hat seo techniques. Yip, certainly have Report them for what - most of the time we're talking about typos A typo wouldn't lead to this issue, a typo would lead to your domain or main parameters being wrong which would result in CakePHP kicking out some sort

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-07 Thread WebbedIT
I also don't want to discuss about whether it's an issue or not @massl: Only just caught the above line in your 2nd post, so sorry to take the topic in that direction, but I think it is a useful thread for others to read as any site could fall foul of such malicious attacks, although in my

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-06 Thread WebbedIT
I do no see how this is a problem as neither you or a search engine would add extra unneeded parameters to a link, and if the hard coded links do not exist in your pages then Google cannot index them Also anyone linking to your pages is just going to copy/paste an URL, they're not going to add in

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-06 Thread AD7six
On May 6, 8:47 am, WebbedIT p...@webbedit.co.uk wrote: I do no see how this is a problem as neither you or a search engine would add extra unneeded parameters to a link, and if the hard coded links do not exist in your pages then Google cannot index them Also anyone linking to your pages is

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-06 Thread AD7six
On May 5, 2:19 pm, massl vermas...@gmail.com wrote: On 5 Mai, 14:01, John Andersen j.andersen...@gmail.com wrote: I just wonder, when the search engine goes through your site, then your site does not make the duplicate URLs (I assume), so the issue should not arise! If I am wrong,

passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-05 Thread massl
Hi, I currently have a SEO problem with CakePHP. For example you have an users-controller with an action register that is called by example.com/users/register. You can now add more arguments to the URL e.g. example.com/users/register/my/duplicate/ content. That's very bad for SEO because you

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-05 Thread John Andersen
I just wonder, when the search engine goes through your site, then your site does not make the duplicate URLs (I assume), so the issue should not arise! If I am wrong, please clarify :) Enjoy, John On May 5, 2:33 pm, massl vermas...@gmail.com wrote: Hi, I currently have a SEO problem with

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-05 Thread massl
On 5 Mai, 14:01, John Andersen j.andersen...@gmail.com wrote: I just wonder, when the search engine goes through your site, then your site does not make the duplicate URLs (I assume), so the issue should not arise! If I am wrong, please clarify :) Yes sure, it's not a ultimative huge

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-05 Thread Lucca Mordente
What about insert a canonical meta tag inside pages that are prone to have duplicated urls? The canonical meta tells the search engine that the right url for a page is that url you put as canonical This way, even if each duplicated page has the same url, you will not have indexing problems

Re: passing more parameters leads to duplicate content

2010-05-05 Thread Miles J
But how are they duplicates? /users/profile/1/ /users/profile/2/ /blog/read/some-slug/123/ /blog/read/slug/12356/ /image/view/15 None of those are duplicates. Why would you pass arguments that ultimately don't decide how the action renders? On May 5, 8:17 am, Lucca Mordente