[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-15 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #30 on issue 5278 by p...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 Re #29: The debate over whether options cost users as well as developers is out of place in this bug. It's worthy of discussion, but over on the

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-15 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #29 on issue 5278 by dhhwai: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 @Pam, I totally agree and understand that options entail costs for development, testing, and maintenance. However, strictly from a user's point of view, I

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-15 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #28 on issue 5278 by nickb...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 I agree with Peter, i.e. always restore tabs to the window they were in. If that window was closed, open a new window. Ideally, restoring mul

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-15 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #27 on issue 5278 by pkast...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 Certainly your current plan is an improvement on what we have now and I'm all for that. The main time the "window has since been closed" iss

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-15 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #26 on issue 5278 by p...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 Re #25: Those two pieces are both pretty uncontroversial. The pending question is what to do when the window a tab was in has since been closed.

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-15 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #25 on issue 5278 by pkast...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 I encouraged Glen to post directly, but I believe his opinion yesterday was generally like mine, with the critical bits in his view being tha

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-15 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #24 on issue 5278 by dhhwai: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 Again, the simple and direct solution to all this is to provide *CONFIGURABLE OPTIONS* that can be set from the UI. Then everyone can choose the options th

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-15 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #23 on issue 5278 by s...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 Here's my thoughts. I freely admit Peter and myself differ on how this should be implemented. You might talk with Glen for his perspective. > Q:

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-14 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #22 on issue 5278 by pkast...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 FWIW, keeping track of which window a closed tab was in is not too hard; we do this already for the session restore stuff. Which means the a

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-14 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #21 on issue 5278 by p...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 Unfortunately, comment #4 is not a complete spec. Here's one possibility: Q: What do we do? A: However we're reopening a tab (NTP, keyboard, menu

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-14 Thread codesite-noreply
Comment #20 on issue 5278 by pkast...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 Re: comment 18: I think that's OK. This is really an "app-level" command more than a tabstrip-level one. We're only just now adding that to

[chromium-bugs] Issue 5278 in chromium: Reopen closed tab in its original position

2009-04-14 Thread codesite-noreply
Updates: Cc: pkast...@chromium.org g...@chromium.org Comment #19 on issue 5278 by s...@chromium.org: Reopen closed tab in its original position http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=5278 I like this. To do otherwise means a new window will suddenly appear, which feels to