Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-03 Thread Edward Sohn
Thanks to all for the responses to my VPN connections. I have pretty much verified it will work in an "active/failover" setting... Now, I have an issue where I need to convince my customer that it's better to subinterface a fast ethernet port into two separate VLANs rather than add secondary IP a

Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-03 Thread Darren S. Crawford
Secondarys will really hurt you in a DHCP environment. The workstations on the secondary subnet will get their DHCP request forwarded with a source segment of the initial IP address on the interface. This was good ammo for me when I was in the same boat. HTH Darren At 10:52 PM 12/3/2002 +,

Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-03 Thread p b
Actually using secondaries and DHCP should be a non issue with any reasonable DHCP server platform. As you mention, in many versions of IOS the interface's primary IP address is used as the DHCP giaddr. If an interface has multiple secondaries, one just needs to configure the DHCP server to be a

Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-03 Thread Priscilla Oppenheimer
p b wrote: > > > Actually using secondaries and DHCP should be a non issue with > any reasonable DHCP server platform. As you mention, in many > versions of IOS the interface's primary IP address is used > as the DHCP giaddr. If an interface has multiple secondaries, > one just needs to config

RE: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-03 Thread Roberts, Larry
touch the reasonable DHCP server platform statement. That sounds like an MS bashing in the waiting :) -Original Message- From: p b [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Tuesday, December 03, 2002 7:22 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498] Actually using secon

Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-04 Thread p b
Priscilla Oppenheimer wrote: > > p b wrote: > > Actually using secondaries and DHCP should be a non issue with > > any reasonable DHCP server platform. As you mention, in many > > versions of IOS the interface's primary IP address is used > > as the DHCP giaddr. If an interface has multiple sec

Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-04 Thread p b
Argh. Tab and return doesn't work well in when posting through the web page Let me revise the last part of my message: If the interface (or sub-interface) looks like: int ethernet 4/0.42 ip address 10.0.1.1 255.255.255.0 ip address 10.0.2.1 255.255.255.0 sec ip address 10.0.3.1 25

Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-04 Thread Priscilla Oppenheimer
Thanks for all the info p b. It's very helpful. Regarding the first situation, where the DHCP server is on another segment and we're using a helper address to get the requests over to the server: We have established that if you use secondaries, the router puts its primary address into the giaddr

RE: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-04 Thread Roberts, Larry
r 04, 2002 3:11 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498] Thanks for all the info p b. It's very helpful. Regarding the first situation, where the DHCP server is on another segment and we're using a helper address to get the requests over to the server: We h

RE: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-04 Thread Roberts, Larry
r 04, 2002 3:11 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498] Thanks for all the info p b. It's very helpful. Regarding the first situation, where the DHCP server is on another segment and we're using a helper address to get the requests over to the server: We h

Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-04 Thread p b
Ah, ok. I think I see some of the confusion. Recall that one can configure sub-interfaces with secondaries: int ethernet 4/0.10 ip address 1.2.3.1 255.255.255.0 ip address 2.3.4.1 255.255.255.0 secondary ip helper-address 99.88.77.66 int ethernet 4/0.20 ip address 3.4.5.1 255.255.255.0 ip

RE: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498]

2002-12-04 Thread Andrew Larkins
December 2002 22:11 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Secondary IP Addresses [7:58498] Thanks for all the info p b. It's very helpful. Regarding the first situation, where the DHCP server is on another segment and we're using a helper address to get the requests over to the server