Re: [cobirds] South Platte Reservoir and ABA guidelines

2019-02-03 Thread Karen Strong
I’m a relatively new birder, but am I wrong in stating that the very first time I see a bird of a particular species (assuming I properly identify it), that that sighting counts as a “life bird” for me, no matter where the bird is and/or where I am when I see it? Having said that, I completel

[cobirds] Colorado Rare Bird Alert for Sunday, February 3

2019-02-03 Thread Joe Roller
Date: February 3, 2019 Compiler: Joe Roller, jroller9 AT gmail.com Phone: (303) 204-0828 E-mail: RBA AT cobirds.org This is the Colorado Rare Bird Alert for Sunday, February 3, sponsored by Denver Field Ornithologists. Observers have been diligent in reporting sightings and updates on Co

[cobirds] Black Scoter flock at Pueblo Res

2019-02-03 Thread Brandon
There is a flock of about 20 Black Scoters, including adult males at Pueblo Reservoir, swimmimg off South Shore Marina tires currently! Never seen this many in Colorado before. First year Glaucous-winged Gull continues and the adult Great Black-backed Gull are both sitting on south shore marina t

Re: [cobirds] South Platte Reservoir and ABA guidelines

2019-02-03 Thread Chip Clouse
You are correct, Karen. A Life Bird is a life bird, geography aside. People start categorizing the geography of the sighting (local patch, county, state, country, area (ABA-area, etc.) if they care to do so. If use eBird, it will categorize for you if you care to look at the breakdown. To Mark's

[cobirds] Gyrfalcon

2019-02-03 Thread robert beauchamp
Gerfalcon currently on power pole at Trilby and Taft, near landfill. 8:30 a.m. Robert Beauchamp Fort Collins -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Colorado Birds" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to c

[cobirds] Canada Jays - Cub Creek Trailhead

2019-02-03 Thread Karen Strong
When I left the Cub Creek Trailhead at 8:55 this morning, the two Canada Jays were in the stand of trees just to the left of the trailhead sign, flying between trees & hopping around on branches, occasionally calling. They first appeared at about 8:20. -- You received this message because y

[cobirds] Larimer Gyrfalcon Continues

2019-02-03 Thread 'Joshua Smith' via Colorado Birds
Gyrfalcon continues as of 9:30 am. Perched on a power trip pole just north of the Larimer County Landfill on Taft Hill Rd. Nice pull-off for parking. - Joshua Smith (Fort Collins) Sent from my iPhone -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Colorado Bir

[cobirds] Trilby Rd 2/3 (Larimer)

2019-02-03 Thread snowy.owlets
Hi Everyone,  As of 10:30am 2/3, a Glaucous Gull is at the Larimer Landfill. Several of us had the Gyrfalcon on a pole along Taft Hill Road, but it flew southeast around 9:45. There is more traffic than usual along Trilby Rd this morning. There is an auction going on.  Mark Miller Longmont, CO 

[cobirds] Re: Black Scoter flock at Pueblo Res

2019-02-03 Thread Brandon
The flock of 22 Black Scoters didn't stay long at South Shore Marina at Pueblo Reservoir. Not sure where they went, I had to leave to meet people at the Nature Center. A couple other birders were also able to see the first year Glaucous-winged Gull, before it flew off, mid-morning, at the South S

[cobirds] How to find your true Colorado bird list total

2019-02-03 Thread Joe Roller
Mark Chavez's comments were spot on! Your eBird list is usually an overcount, as it includes birds that are not on the official Colorado list, as carefully maintained by the CFO's Colorado Bird Record Committee, the CBRC. Here is one way to figure out your true, valid CO list, the only way to com

[cobirds] Raven gathering, Dillon, Summit Cty

2019-02-03 Thread Skot Latona
We observed quite an impressive gathering of ravens in Dillon this weekend. 40 - 50 ravens had marked up an entire snowy hill near the north east arm of the lake . . . They were snow-bathing, jumping, rolling, sledding, and copulating. There are lots of cute videos of a couple ravens rolling d

[cobirds] RE: How to find your true Colorado bird list total

2019-02-03 Thread Andrew Bankert
I just wanted to add a quick note that is really minor about listing. If you do report your totals to the ABA you can count anything on the ABA checklist in your state totals even if that species hasn't been accepted by the state records committee. That means for ABA, you can count Pink-footed and

Re: [cobirds] RE: How to find your true Colorado bird list total

2019-02-03 Thread Joe Roller
Andy, This is NOT my understanding. You can count those geese on the ABA checklist ONLY if you have seen them in the states out east where they have been accepted by the state bird record committees. Ditto with Mute Swan and Budgerigar. They are established and countable in some states, but you hav

Re: [cobirds] RE: How to find your true Colorado bird list total

2019-02-03 Thread Andrew Bankert
I could not find any mention of state records committees in the ABA Recording Rules. Has anyone seen anything saying that records committees have any say in ABA list totals? Here are the rules I was referring to in my first email: For vagrants it seems pretty clear to me that personal judgement

[cobirds] Speaking of lists....rules for yardbirds?

2019-02-03 Thread Thomas Heinrich
The discussion regarding listing rules got me wondering about which rules we choose to follow for yardbirds. How many of us use the ABA model as opposed to the Big Sit model, or some other perhaps? What do you count? If you happen to be returning from a walk around the neighborhood, see a No