Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2017-02-17 Thread Ariel Feinerman
I am glad to know that a lot of people still like multiple windowed UI and remember Xcode 3 with warm like me. Of course, it is more suitable for using multiple screens: one window for each screen, or in the case of CAD -- one screen for model designing window and one for everything else. However,

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-13 Thread Dave
> On 11 Jan 2016, at 23:10, Charles Srstka wrote: > > My favorite thing in Xcode is the way that Interface Builder stuffs the > entire object library into that tiny little space in the lower-right corner > of the screen. Way back in Xcode 3 (or whenever it was that IB was a separate > app), t

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-13 Thread Dave
> On 11 Jan 2016, at 21:06, Lee Ann Rucker wrote: > > >> On Jan 11, 2016, at 7:35 AM, Jim Lee wrote: >> >> We have an application, TopXNotes that allows multiple “documents” (notes) >> to be opened in adjacent views (panes). The notes can be edited >> individually. One can cut/paste/copy fr

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-13 Thread Dave
> On 11 Jan 2016, at 16:15, Alex Zavatone wrote: > > Way back in the mid '90s, there was some double click tool that simply felt > like the holy grail to me. > > You double clicked or option clicked on the title of a window and it would > turn that window into the "floating windoid" title bar

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-12 Thread Dave
> On 12 Jan 2016, at 03:56, Greg Weston wrote: > >> (I also don’t want to restart Xcode wars, but I do actually believe that the >> unified window style that arrived in Xcode 4 was an actual decision about >> which worked best, made by clever people who actually thought about it. It >> wasn’t

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Greg Weston
> (I also don’t want to restart Xcode wars, but I do actually believe that the > unified window style that arrived in Xcode 4 was an actual decision about > which worked best, made by clever people who actually thought about it. It > wasn’t — I believe — merely clueless. I also want to point out

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Charles Srstka
My favorite thing in Xcode is the way that Interface Builder stuffs the entire object library into that tiny little space in the lower-right corner of the screen. Way back in Xcode 3 (or whenever it was that IB was a separate app), the floating palette that they had for the object library let yo

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Marco S Hyman
> My reasoning is that if you make it inflexible, you risk getting (say) 50% > lovers and 50% haters. If you make it flexible, you risk getting 40% lovers > and 40% haters, and 20% people who are annoyed because it’s too flexible or > too complicated. That’s a net loss in satisfaction. I think

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Matt Reagan
> If you make it flexible, you risk getting 40% lovers and 40% haters, and 20% > people who are annoyed because it’s too flexible or too complicated. That’s a > net loss in satisfaction. How about: 40% lovers, 40% haters, and 20% people who *are initially frustrated by the complexity, and then

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Quincey Morris
On Jan 11, 2016, at 13:06 , Lee Ann Rucker wrote: > > no system is going to make everyone happy, so go for the most flexible one if > you can I’d like to advocate the opposite point of view: no system is going to make everyone happy, so go for the the one that works best. (Yes, I understand w

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Lee Ann Rucker
> On Jan 11, 2016, at 7:35 AM, Jim Lee wrote: > > We have an application, TopXNotes that allows multiple “documents” (notes) to > be opened in adjacent views (panes). The notes can be edited individually. > One can cut/paste/copy from any text document to/from a seperate text app, or > from p

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Carl Hoefs
FWIW, I find it odd that so many apps these days seem to be following Xcode's "lead", if you want to call it that. I still miss Xcode 3.2.6 because I could configure it for the way *I* was most productive. Now you gotta use that ginormous "plate" window. It shows you what it wants to show you wh

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Gary L. Wade
I've seen an advantage to having "attached palettes" like Xcode's Utilities pane. When set up like this, I can see unique attributes per window and compare two separate documents. When there's only one shared all over the place, it might be harder at times to get context at a glance. An example

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Rick Mann
I'm pleased to see so many in favor of multiple windows. It seems the arguments in favor of a single monolithic window hinge smaller screens. But I find that monolithic windows require larger screens (and can't share screens). The thing about separate windows is they can overlap and still be use

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Alex Zavatone
Way back in the mid '90s, there was some double click tool that simply felt like the holy grail to me. You double clicked or option clicked on the title of a window and it would turn that window into the "floating windoid" title bar only. We took this model and made it so that when you collaps

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Alex Zavatone
On Jan 11, 2016, at 2:17 AM, Britt Durbrow wrote: > My preference would be multiple windows (one primary document window and > several utility panel windows) that can be snapped into place against each > other. This gives the freedom to use multiple monitors while also having the > screen-real

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Jim Lee
We have an application, TopXNotes that allows multiple “documents” (notes) to be opened in adjacent views (panes). The notes can be edited individually. One can cut/paste/copy from any text document to/from a seperate text app, or from pane to pane. Just one example of something different that I

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Dave
> On 9 Jan 2016, at 22:19, Rick Mann wrote: > > In complex apps (e.g. CAD apps, IDEs) a given document has many auxiliary > windows. The trend in UI at Apple has been to consolidate these into panes in > a single window. I've always preferred separate windows (e.g. separate > toolbar window).

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-11 Thread Charles Jenkins
Interesting that so many others like the multiwindow approach. I’ve always thought that a horrible design, because you constantly have to fool with them to get them out of the way as you work on a document. I like the approach taken by Photoshop, where you can dock them them together in the layo

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-10 Thread Britt Durbrow
My preference would be multiple windows (one primary document window and several utility panel windows) that can be snapped into place against each other. This gives the freedom to use multiple monitors while also having the screen-real-estate efficiency that a single-window approach would. (FWI

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-10 Thread Bill Cheeseman
> On Jan 10, 2016, at 8:41 AM, Alex Zavatone wrote: > > On Jan 9, 2016, at 5:19 PM, Rick Mann wrote: > >> In complex apps (e.g. CAD apps, IDEs) a given document has many auxiliary >> windows. The trend in UI at Apple has been to consolidate these into panes >> in a single window. I've always

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-10 Thread Alex Zavatone
On Jan 9, 2016, at 5:19 PM, Rick Mann wrote: > In complex apps (e.g. CAD apps, IDEs) a given document has many auxiliary > windows. The trend in UI at Apple has been to consolidate these into panes in > a single window. I've always preferred separate windows (e.g. separate > toolbar window).

Re: Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-09 Thread Jerry Krinock
> On 2016 Jan 09, at 14:19, Rick Mann wrote: > > Thoughts? You could argue this both ways until the cows come home, but here is one thought: I think the recent move toward one big window, like the move toward full-screen apps, has been advanced by the increased prevalance of laptops, with th

Panes vs. Separate Windows

2016-01-09 Thread Rick Mann
In complex apps (e.g. CAD apps, IDEs) a given document has many auxiliary windows. The trend in UI at Apple has been to consolidate these into panes in a single window. I've always preferred separate windows (e.g. separate toolbar window). One more concrete example is in a CAD program: the obje