Re: [CGUYS] HDDs and vibrators was: Slow Dell startup

2009-08-22 Thread TPiwowar
On Aug 22, 2009, at 2:12 PM, Tony B wrote: No, you will have a hard time convincing me a fan of any type could vibrate enough to cause an r/w error on a drive. But be aware - cosmic rays *can* cause errors. Not as many as 'normal' causes, but surely it happens. Anyway, that's what chkdsk is

Re: [CGUYS] HDDs and vibrators was: Slow Dell startup

2009-08-22 Thread Tony B
Then it's just another case of people neglecting to change the subject line. No, you will have a hard time convincing me a fan of any type could vibrate enough to cause an r/w error on a drive. But be aware - cosmic rays *can* cause errors. Not as many as 'normal' causes, but surely it happens. An

Re: [CGUYS] HDDs and vibrators was: Slow Dell startup

2009-08-22 Thread Fred Holmes
At 10:35 AM 8/22/2009, Tony B wrote: >Certainly neither of you is suggesting his slow boot has to do with his >drive being vibrated by a fan Not directly, but fan vibration could cause an imperfect write leading to later slow reads. If the reads are part of the boot process, then the boot pr

Re: [CGUYS] HDDs and vibrators was: Slow Dell startup

2009-08-22 Thread Chris Dunford
> Certainly neither of you is suggesting his slow boot has to do with his > drive being vibrated by a fan No, they're two different issues. I have the slow-booting PC. Someone else has a system where the HDD seems to be affected by vibration from the fan. ***

Re: [CGUYS] HDDs and vibrators was: Slow Dell startup

2009-08-22 Thread mike
We should be clear, they were talking about HD's being affected by vibration...NOT vibrators. Unless you are visiting the adult boutique and putting some purple monsters inside your computer case? On Sat, Aug 22, 2009 at 7:35 AM, Tony B wrote: > > > But maybe I shouldn't have said anything, and

[CGUYS] HDDs and vibrators was: Slow Dell startup

2009-08-22 Thread Tony B
I haven't been following this thread, but after seeing this post this morning I had to go back and look. And I just have to ask: How the heck did you guys get off in some apparently completely different direction here? Certainly neither of you is suggesting his slow boot has to do with his drive b