[coreboot] Re: First commercially available coreboot for Intel Xeon-SP

2021-11-08 Thread Paul Menzel
Dear Jonathan, Am 05.11.21 um 20:05 schrieb Jonathan Zhang: We now have the first commercially available coreboot solution for servers based on Intel Xeon-SP processor (specifically CooperLake Scalable Processor). These are great news. (As always a nit: Cooper Lake-SP ;-)) WW OCP DeltaLake

[coreboot] Re: Providing an Interface to load PSE FW for Intel Elkhart Lake Platform

2021-11-08 Thread David Hendricks
Hi Nico, One thing that's unclear to me is if there are lingering technical reasons for holding the patch back, aside from a Kconfig variable that Michael recently requested. Werner asked that question as well but the answer(s), if any, seem to have been lost in the philosophical aspects. If the p

[coreboot] Re: First commercially available coreboot for Intel Xeon-SP

2021-11-08 Thread David Hendricks
This is awesome! Thanks for sharing, and keep up the great work! On Fri, Nov 5, 2021 at 12:06 PM Jonathan Zhang wrote: > Hi, > > We now have the first commercially available coreboot solution for > servers based on Intel Xeon-SP processor (specifically CooperLake > Scalable Processor). > > WW OC

[coreboot] Re: Another year, another blob?

2021-11-08 Thread Nico Huber
On 08.11.21 19:38, Martin Roth wrote: > > Nov 7, 2021, 04:29 by nic...@gmx.de: > >> On 07.11.21 00:15, Martin Roth wrote: >> >>> >>> Nov 6, 2021, 05:49 by nic...@gmx.de: >>> It also seems that you underestimate the individuals in the community. >>> I don't understand your statement

[coreboot] Re: Another year, another blob?

2021-11-08 Thread Nico Huber
On 08.11.21 19:57, Patrick Georgi wrote: > Am So., 7. Nov. 2021 um 12:29 Uhr schrieb Nico Huber : > >> There's also a general reluctance to expect to support a project with >> free software that has shown that it doesn't take the GPL seriously. >> > > General reluctance by whom? I just don't see th

[coreboot] Re: Weird thoughts about blobs (was Re: Re: Another year, another blob?)

2021-11-08 Thread Paul Menzel
Dear Martin, Am 08.11.21 um 19:38 schrieb Martin Roth: Nov 7, 2021, 04:13 by nic...@gmx.de: On 07.11.21 00:11, Martin Roth wrote: CB:55367 was pushed on June 9th. It's 5 months later. Intel hasn't been able to get it merged yet. Sure, we're not outright saying they can't get it in, but

[coreboot] Re: Another year, another blob?

2021-11-08 Thread Paul Menzel
Dear Martin, Am 05.11.21 um 18:15 schrieb Martin Roth: Nov 4, 2021, 05:24 by pmen...@molgen.mpg.de: On 20.10.21 14:24, Nico Huber wrote: My proposal: How about we set up some guidelines how to proceed when adding support for a new platform that requires any blobs? My vague idea is as follow

[coreboot] Re: Another year, another blob?

2021-11-08 Thread Patrick Georgi via coreboot
Am So., 7. Nov. 2021 um 12:29 Uhr schrieb Nico Huber : > There's also a general reluctance to expect to support a project with > free software that has shown that it doesn't take the GPL seriously. > General reluctance by whom? I just don't see that, instead I see tons of activity by a very diver

[coreboot] Re: Installing coreboot with SeaBIOS

2021-11-08 Thread bernd...@web.de
Thank you. I was looking on the german Wikipedia https://de.wikipedia.org.Regards,Bernd Originalnachricht Betreff: [coreboot] Re: Installing coreboot with SeaBIOSVon: Nico Huber An: bernd...@web.deCc: coreboot@coreboot.orgOn 08.11.21 19:15, bernd...@web.de wrote:> Hi. Is the SeaBIOS

[coreboot] Re: Weird thoughts about blobs (was Re: Re: Another year, another blob?)

2021-11-08 Thread Martin Roth via coreboot
Nov 7, 2021, 04:13 by nic...@gmx.de: > On 07.11.21 00:11, Martin Roth wrote: > >> CB:55367 was pushed on June 9th.  It's 5 months later.  Intel hasn't been >> able to get it merged yet.  Sure, we're not outright saying they can't get >> it in, but in effect, that's what's happening. >> > Yes, 5

[coreboot] Re: Another year, another blob?

2021-11-08 Thread Martin Roth via coreboot
Nov 7, 2021, 04:29 by nic...@gmx.de: > On 07.11.21 00:15, Martin Roth wrote: > >> >> Nov 6, 2021, 05:49 by nic...@gmx.de: >> >>> It also seems that you underestimate the individuals in the >>> community. >>> >> I don't understand your statement that patrick is underestimating the >> individuals

[coreboot] Re: Installing coreboot with SeaBIOS

2021-11-08 Thread Nico Huber
On 08.11.21 19:15, bernd...@web.de wrote: > Hi. Is the SeaBIOS payload open source, actually? Yes. > I have looked for SeaBIOS on > Wikipedia but it has no entry of its own. Please look closer [1]. Nico [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SeaBIOS ___ c

[coreboot] Re: Installing coreboot with SeaBIOS

2021-11-08 Thread bernd...@web.de
Hi. Is the SeaBIOS payload open source, actually? I have looked for SeaBIOS on Wikipedia but it has no entry of its own. On Wikipedia's coreboot website SeaBIOS is mentioned, though but there's no statement whether or not it's open source.Regards,Bernd___

[coreboot] Re: Installing coreboot with SeaBIOS

2021-11-08 Thread Nicholas
It's fine that there are more than 2 lines. In general, there would only be two lines if you configure coreboot exactly the same as in the tutorial (and even then there probably will be more than 2 lines, as was explained previously on another thread). Anything you do differently from the tutori

[coreboot] Re: Another year, another blob?

2021-11-08 Thread Nico Huber
Hi Werner, On 08.11.21 12:24, Zeh, Werner wrote: > I fully can understand your point of view in this discussion. Unfortunately, > we do live in a real world with real companies that are business-driven. > With this sidenote in context the world changes dramatically in this regard. > > Your reque

[coreboot] Re: How to enable SERIRQ reliably?

2021-11-08 Thread Lance Zhao
Thanks for let us know the result. But the explanation will be the warm reboot path will modify the GPIO setting? Or the GPIO setting is floating at the moment? Lance Zhiwen Zheng 于2021年11月8日周一 下午7:31写道: > Add gpio.c from > https://u8209486.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=5-2BjrOL6Sde2a9aQLMiEgaLz

[coreboot] Re: How to enable SERIRQ reliably?

2021-11-08 Thread Zhiwen Zheng
Add gpio.c from https://u8209486.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=5-2BjrOL6Sde2a9aQLMiEgaLzceDV6ek3hr5PekV6loyqk65QWgl6iFUXTzf0xmiYdaz1dP39rwh5BPgTpUyb-2Bsg-3D-3DxXBW_L-2FDzr14mnrsJO5b1wX1hp9b1MAQygl7x-2B74RAaH2cn2wBxw68JrPs9IxSJmJXQAva-2BUY65aZPvVauIf67M-2FgY9v12g9aQMGCk5eA9Kfw56r9XM2u-2FaXeM-2BCATfg

[coreboot] Re: Another year, another blob?

2021-11-08 Thread Zeh, Werner
Hi Nico. I fully can understand your point of view in this discussion. Unfortunately, we do live in a real world with real companies that are business-driven. With this sidenote in context the world changes dramatically in this regard. Your request for an early discussion whether this or that de

[coreboot] Re: Installing coreboot with SeaBIOS

2021-11-08 Thread bernd...@web.de
Hi. I'm with "Check your configuration (optional step):".I did$ make savedefconfig$ cat defconfigThe instructions say:"There should only be two lines (or 3 if you’re using the system toolchain):CONFIG_PAYLOAD_ELF=yCONFIG_PAYLOAD_FILE="payloads/coreinfo/build/coreinfo.elf""I wasn't using the system

[coreboot] Re: How to enable SERIRQ reliably?

2021-11-08 Thread Zhiwen Zheng
On Mon, 8 Nov 2021 13:18:07 +0530 "Naresh G. Solanki" wrote: > Since the hang happens in Linux, can you in some way get Linux kernel log > to understand the cause like soft lockup or panic message. > No. > Also are you saying irrespective of serirq enable/disable, hang is seen? > > UART works p

[coreboot] Re: How to enable SERIRQ reliably?

2021-11-08 Thread Zhiwen Zheng
I just looked at the patch, it does not reenable continuous mode in ramstage. So what I do is basically the same with that patch, but that doesn't work after a warm reset for me. I am wondering whether the gpio configuration of the soc is related to this issue, I don't have access to the BWG do