Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-25 Thread Franc Tireur
PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist -Caveat Lector- > As to illegal - I'm not so sure. It was British land to give. > Other land was lost and gained in war. Are you going to disclaim all lands > won by conquest? That&#x

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-25 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- > As to illegal - I'm not so sure. It was British land to give. > Other land was lost and gained in war. Are you going to disclaim all lands > won by conquest? That's ok with me, as long as we do it across the board. I > won't really miss Texas, and if they become Mexicans they can

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-24 Thread thew
-Caveat Lector- on 12/24/02 10:02 PM, flw at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > -Caveat Lector- > >> Morals? Both sides have committed evil atrocious acts. Again I state ( I >> know it's hard for this one to get through)- there is no moral high > ground >> to be had from any side here. > > You are being

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-24 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- > Morals? Both sides have committed evil atrocious acts. Again I state ( I > know it's hard for this one to get through)- there is no moral high ground > to be had from any side here. You are being coy and equivicating.By equating the acts of the oppressor with the oppressed - the

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-23 Thread thew
-Caveat Lector- on 12/23/02 10:19 PM, flw at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Your rationalization was obvious from the fact that you thought it > somehow unfair of me not to also quote other incidents where > Israelis were victimized. Unfair? I think the word I used was brilliant, actually. >As

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-23 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- > My point remains the same - every time you choose to show only part of > something, you are displaying an opinion. The facts stated in the quote were the facts that I sought report. The whole article reported other incidents and events. The other incidents or events do not chang

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-23 Thread thew
-Caveat Lector- I see the difference. You presented an edited form of an article. The editing took the form of quoting the part that backs up your belief, while editing out all the parts that go against your belief system. My point remains the same - every time you choose to show only part of so

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-23 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- > Sorry - wrong: > > Inflected forms: ed·it·ed , ed·it·ing , ed·its > 1 a. To prepare (written material) for publication or presentation, as by > correcting, revising, or adapting. b. To prepare an edition of for > publication: edit a collection of short stories. c. To modify or a

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-22 Thread thew
-Caveat Lector- on 12/22/02 11:58 AM, flw at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > -Caveat Lector- > >> Brilliant editing. As I used to tell my students - every edit is an > opinion. > > I did not 'edit' the article. It would be 'editing' if I presented the > entire > article with additions or omissions and

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-22 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- > Brilliant editing. As I used to tell my students - every edit is an opinion. I did not 'edit' the article. It would be 'editing' if I presented the entire article with additions or omissions and offered it purportedly as the original. I did offer an excerpt and cited the origina

Re: [CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-21 Thread thew
-Caveat Lector- Brilliant editing. As I used to tell my students - every edit is an opinion. Here are some snippets of the same article FLW accidentally left out: A 40-year-old rabbi and father of six was shot and killed by a Palestinian gunman in a roadside ambush this morning as he drove to a

[CTRL] Israelis Execute 11 year old Palestinian Girl Terrorist

2002-12-21 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- By Molly Moore Washington Post Foreign Service Saturday, December 21, 2002; Page A14 Palestinian: 'The World Has Lost Sensitivity' "...An 11-year-old Palestinian girl was shot in the chest and killed Thursday afternoon as she leaned out her bedroom window in the Rafah refugee cam