Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Jeremy Boynes
Aaron Mulder wrote: I'd like to be able to add entries to config.list when the server is not running and I'm doing a deployment. The problem is, the configuration list GBean isn't running -- it's not in the minimal set started by the deployer. And even if it was, it would install a shutdown

Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Dain Sundstrom
On Nov 4, 2004, at 11:18 AM, Jeremy Boynes wrote: Aaron Mulder wrote: I'd like to be able to add entries to config.list when the server is not running and I'm doing a deployment. The problem is, the configuration list GBean isn't running -- it's not in the minimal set started by the deployer.

Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Aaron Mulder
I'm working on the new deployer not the old one. As per the proposed deployer syntax message, this one actually offers a JSR-88 start method while the server is not running, which equates to updating the config list to include the module. I'd rather not start the server to do that...

Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Jeremy Boynes
Aaron Mulder wrote: I'm working on the new deployer not the old one. As per the proposed deployer syntax message, this one actually offers a JSR-88 start method while the server is not running, which equates to updating the config list to include the module. I'd rather not start the server to

Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Aaron Mulder
On Thu, 4 Nov 2004, Jeremy Boynes wrote: Pardon me for being dumb but how can you start a module if the server is down? I think we may be trying to hard to kludge 88-style operations into a mode that 88 was not intended to support. If you deploy to a server that's not running,

Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Jeremy Boynes
Aaron Mulder wrote: If you deploy to a server that's not running, then the module will be started next time the server starts. If you distribute to a server that's not running, then the module will not be started next time the server starts. You mean, you hope that it starts - you would have

Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Aaron Mulder
What I am proposing is the equivalent of using the current deploy tool, and then adding the module's configId to the server command line next time you start it -- which is what you can do today. I don't see how that makes the situation worse. You seem to be sugesting that the

Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Jeremy Boynes
Aaron Mulder wrote: What I am proposing is the equivalent of using the current deploy tool, and then adding the module's configId to the server command line next time you start it -- which is what you can do today. I don't see how that makes the situation worse. No, you were proposing having

Re: How to updated config.list during offline deployment

2004-11-04 Thread Aaron Mulder
On Thu, 4 Nov 2004, Jeremy Boynes wrote: No, you were proposing having the deployment tool hack the internal file used by a specific GBean. I object to that as it relies on implementation detail. Hmm. Obviously we're not on the same page here. So you would be totally