Re: OSGi version for Geronimo packages

2010-05-07 Thread Jarek Gawor
So do we have consensus for option #1 then? I think there are at least few modules we would have to update to make sure the package versions are not exported. Jarek On Thu, May 6, 2010 at 11:42 AM, David Jencks wrote: > At the moment, having thought about versions for the txmanager and jaspi >

Re: OSGi version for Geronimo packages

2010-05-06 Thread David Jencks
At the moment, having thought about versions for the txmanager and jaspi releases, I would like (1). I'm not very comfortable including versions until there is good tool support for knowing when they change.I certainly cannot pick a correct next package version given 2 code bases and an ini

Re: OSGi version for Geronimo packages

2010-05-06 Thread Joe Bohn
I was actually leaning toward #2 or even #1. The benefit of #2 is that the final version is what you would normally expect and is consistent with other projects. I can certainly see the value in #3 - especially if we release multiple milestones. It makes it much easier to understand the v

Re: OSGi version for Geronimo packages

2010-05-06 Thread Lin Sun
Right, that is why the final release needs to be called 3.0.0.final or 3.0.0.release and cannot be called 3.0.0! 3.0.0.final > 3.0.0.M1 3.0.0.release > 3.0.0.m1 Lin On Thu, May 6, 2010 at 9:42 AM, Guillaume Nodet wrote: > Keep in mind that in osgi, 3.0.0.m1 > 3.0.0 !!! > On Thu, May 6, 2010 at

Re: OSGi version for Geronimo packages

2010-05-06 Thread Guillaume Nodet
Keep in mind that in osgi, 3.0.0.m1 > 3.0.0 !!! On Thu, May 6, 2010 at 15:24, Lin Sun wrote: > Hi > > I think no. 3 is cool. some other qualifiers that I can think of are > > 3.0.0.m1, 3.0.0.m2, 3.0.0.release > > > Lin > > On Thu, May 6, 2010 at 12:21 AM, Jarek Gawor wrote: > > Hi, > > > > Be

Re: OSGi version for Geronimo packages

2010-05-06 Thread Lin Sun
Hi I think no. 3 is cool. some other qualifiers that I can think of are 3.0.0.m1, 3.0.0.m2, 3.0.0.release Lin On Thu, May 6, 2010 at 12:21 AM, Jarek Gawor wrote: > Hi, > > Before the milestone release we might have to figure out what osgi > version (if any) the Geronimo packages should be e

OSGi version for Geronimo packages

2010-05-05 Thread Jarek Gawor
Hi, Before the milestone release we might have to figure out what osgi version (if any) the Geronimo packages should be exported at. I can think of a few possibilities: 1) No version exported for milestone releases. In the final release everything would be exported with "3.0.0" version. 2) Use v