I also agree with Indu's points.
I feel like the mailing list is more for hackers. Typical MXNet users
are machine learning scientists and not necessarily like discussing
problems in a hacker's way.
Since we already have a discussion forum, why should we create a new
one and get users confused
Agree with Indu's points: email list usability and features seems inferior
compared to the discussion forum, so I would suggest to keep things simple
and stick with the forum.
Hagay
On Sat, Jun 16, 2018, 06:37 Timur Shenkao wrote:
> user mail list
>
> Pros:
> - Apache user mail list is indexed
Oh Pedro... lol funny stuff.
On Sat, Jun 16, 2018 at 10:20 AM Sebastian wrote:
> On 16.06.2018 10:57, Pedro Larroy wrote:
> > Hi Sebastian.
> >
> > Thank you for your comment. That's why I said "I would propose", because
> I
> > don't know if it's possible as my experience with Apache is
On 16.06.2018 10:57, Pedro Larroy wrote:
Hi Sebastian.
Thank you for your comment. That's why I said "I would propose", because I
don't know if it's possible as my experience with Apache is limited to the
MXNet project.
How do you interpret this part?: "Since the appointed Project Management
Whoa, who said that? I can’t find it on this thread.
On Sat, Jun 16, 2018 at 8:37 AM Sebastian wrote:
> > I would propose the two following action points:
> >
> > * Resetting the list of committers to people that have contributed in
> the
> > previous terms in the latest 6 months
> > *
Hi Sebastian.
Thank you for your comment. That's why I said "I would propose", because I
don't know if it's possible as my experience with Apache is limited to the
MXNet project.
How do you interpret this part?: "Since the appointed Project Management
Committees have the power to create their
I would propose the two following action points:
* Resetting the list of committers to people that have contributed in the
previous terms in the latest 6 months
* Suspend veto rights temporarily and use simple majority for decisions
that need a vote so we realign the project with the
Great points and feedback.
I think everyone here wants the best for the project. We should definitely
not shoot down pioneering contributions and be more inclusive with people
that are actively contributing to the community with not just code. This
should include code, documentation, website
user mail list
Pros:
- Apache user mail list is indexed and kept forever in mailing lists. Very
convenient.
- Apache user mail list is indexed by search engines actively and info
appears in search results pretty soon.
- You just get e-mails and when you have spare time read & answer them.
Cons:
Very good points Indu. I also think that the discussion forum is definitely
of big value and that we should keep it. But I also don't think it would
hurt anybody is we open up a new channel of communication, considering that
managing an email list doesn't cause any additional overhead.
Indhu
I prefer the discuss forum over email for following reasons:
1. It is easier for newcomers. People can login using Facebook, Twitter or
GitHub Id
2. The format is much more readable for people who search for something in
a search engine and land on the page.
3. Markdown support makes it easier
Thanks for your opinion, Tianqi. I still would love to listen others'
opinion on the topic to really assert anything.
On Fri, Jun 15, 2018, 21:41 Tianqi Chen wrote:
> Then who should represent the users who are using the forums but not the
> mail-list? I personally think it is a bit abuse use
12 matches
Mail list logo
