Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-04 Thread Bruno Aranda
Development Subject: Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject Okay, since Flash is ubiquitous and freely available, I did not expect issues regarding support of Flash [only of Flex which has been open sourced through MPL]. As mentioned by Grant in the below post, Apache has projects

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-04 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
for the JSF Central newsletter! http://oi.vresp.com/?fid=ac048d0e17 * -Original Message- From: Jihoon Kim [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, June 03, 2008 1:00 PM To: MyFaces Development Subject: Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject Okay, since Flash

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
I'm still voting -1 on having a flash-based project within MyFaces unless someone can show that this code works with a non-proprietory Flash player. I doubt that. I'd be happy to see this project succeed, but not here at Apache. This foundation exists to promote open source software, not

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Jihoon Kim schrieb: I was hoping to start a vote of creation of MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject to hold bridging of various Web 2.0 and new technology to JSF. Even if you have voted in a previous post, please vote here as well to get an accurate count and an accurate viewpoint. The initial

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread Gerhard Petracek
hello, as i know the names changed - see [1]: - we vote on a new subproject for libs like flexfaces. myfaces-alchemy |_ myfaces-flexfaces |_ ... (e.g. the javascript project werner is working on) that's the reason why i said: i prefer to have the mentioned discussion before such a vote.

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread Grant Smith
I'm voting +1 for this subproject. I don't see the current Adobe Flash dependency as a roadblock, and I don't think other contributers here should either. Adobe have recently made significant leaps into open sourcing their products and I feel it to be a matter of time before supporting

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread Hazem Saleh
+1 for having FlexFaces as a subproject. Having this project under MyFaces IMO will be a very good addition to the project. On Tue, Jun 3, 2008 at 6:30 PM, Grant Smith [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm voting +1 for this subproject. I don't see the current Adobe Flash dependency as a roadblock, and

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread Werner Punz
+1 for that I wanted to host my project I am working on under the Tomahawk umbrella since I rely on tomahawk code but since maven can resolve the dependencies I am fine with being in a dedicated web 2.0 subproject as well. Werner Gerhard Petracek schrieb: hello, as i know the names changed -

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread Jihoon Kim
I do understand and thought the following structure = myfaces-alchemy |_ myfaces-flexfaces |_ ... (e.g. the javascript project werner is working on) was okay since I didn't see any follow up posting within

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread Jihoon Kim
Okay, since Flash is ubiquitous and freely available, I did not expect issues regarding support of Flash [only of Flex which has been open sourced through MPL]. As mentioned by Grant in the below post, Apache has projects that supports PDF and Excel [which too are ubiquitous with the second one

RE: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-03 Thread Kito D. Mann
Development Subject: Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject Okay, since Flash is ubiquitous and freely available, I did not expect issues regarding support of Flash [only of Flex which has been open sourced through MPL]. As mentioned by Grant in the below post, Apache has projects

[VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-02 Thread Jihoon Kim
I was hoping to start a vote of creation of MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject to hold bridging of various Web 2.0 and new technology to JSF. Even if you have voted in a previous post, please vote here as well to get an accurate count and an accurate viewpoint. The initial batch of code that

Re: [VOTE] To have MyFaces Alchemy as a subproject

2008-06-02 Thread Gerhard Petracek
hello, my previous comment concerning alchemy: it was my suggestion - +0.9 reason: maybe a restructuring of component libs as a whole is essential? at the moment: -0.5 (because there are some issues i haven't thought about so far) i think we should discuss it within an alchemy proposal. i'm