Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-27 Thread Jacques Le Roux
De : "Jacques Le Roux" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > De : "David E Jones" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > The release4.0 branch needs testing, and that is the point of this > > thread. Of course there are bugs or issues, finding them and the > > nature of them is the point of doing this. You're right that these >

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread Jonathon -- Improov
Hmm. I didn't think about this, that we shouldn't release for sake of getting attention. It's true that it is irritating to end-users if we release something not functional. OFBiz 4.0 is functional. I haven't found any show-stopping bugs. The reason for the release, IHMO, isn't to get attention

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread Jonathon -- Improov
Call me reckless, but I don't think that bug should block binary release. As mentioned before, obsolete a bad release if we need to. I'll be testing the framework a lot over the coming month, so we might see another binary release if I happen to dig up enough critical bugs. As the release branc

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread Jacques Le Roux
De : "David E Jones" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > The release4.0 branch needs testing, and that is the point of this > thread. Of course there are bugs or issues, finding them and the > nature of them is the point of doing this. You're right that these > exist and need attention. Whether they should block

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106(in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread Jacques Le Roux
Thanks Shi, This is really the kind of feedbacks we need... Jacques De : "Shi Yusen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > We have 2 programmers developing components on 4.0 branch for 4 months > and never heard any bugs found until now. The specialpurpose, eCommerce, > content, manufacturing are the components

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread Shi Yusen
I'd suggest to move all the i18n files outside the framework except the defaults, only well qualified programmers can touch the code. Shi Yusen/Beijing Langhua Ltd. 在 2007-11-26一的 13:22 -0700,David E Jones写道: > The release4.0 branch needs testing, and that is the point of this > thread. Of cou

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread Shi Yusen
We have 2 programmers developing components on 4.0 branch for 4 months and never heard any bugs found until now. The specialpurpose, eCommerce, content, manufacturing are the components we didn't touch. BTW, we have started to integrate jbpm with the 4.0 branch. Regards, Shi Yusen/Beijing Langh

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread David E Jones
But +1 for what reason? We will NOT release this just to get attention. We will release it when there is at least a small consensus that it is ready. -David On Nov 26, 2007, at 1:19 PM, BJ Freeman wrote: +1 beta probably the only way it will ever get any attention. David E Jones sent t

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread David E Jones
The release4.0 branch needs testing, and that is the point of this thread. Of course there are bugs or issues, finding them and the nature of them is the point of doing this. You're right that these exist and need attention. Whether they should block a binary release is another question a

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread BJ Freeman
+1 beta probably the only way it will ever get any attention. David E Jones sent the following on 11/26/2007 11:44 AM: > > On Nov 26, 2007, at 9:19 AM, Jacques Le Roux wrote: > >> BTW I think the time is coming to answer questions like in >> http://docs.ofbiz.org/display/OFBADMIN/Demo+and+Test+

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread BJ Freeman
as per the bug found today on Re: HtmlWidget missing a MapStack pop? there are bugs and ver 40 needs a good test. per the commit on this bug Ver 4.0 was not updated. :( Jacopo Cappellato sent the following on 11/26/2007 11:52 AM: > Frankly speaking, my interest for the release branch is low, I'v

Re: When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread Jacopo Cappellato
Frankly speaking, my interest for the release branch is low, I've not tested it too much and I usually suggest to clients to build their fortune on the trunk. That said it would be great to release it, if there is consensus from the community. Jacopo David E Jones wrote: On Nov 26, 2007, at

When to do a binary release? (was Re: release4.0: OFBIZ-1106 (in or out?))

2007-11-26 Thread David E Jones
On Nov 26, 2007, at 9:19 AM, Jacques Le Roux wrote: BTW I think the time is coming to answer questions like in http://docs.ofbiz.org/display/OFBADMIN/Demo+and+Test+Setup+Guide?focusedCommentId=2604#comment-2604 What to you think, you developpers ? I think first things first... The first que