Re: Fwd: Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-18 Thread Josh Rosen
Slightly off-topic, but or helping to clear the PR review backlog, I have a proposal to add some “PR lifecycle” tools to spark-prs.appspot.com to make it easier to track which PRs are blocked on reviewers vs. authors:  https://github.com/databricks/spark-pr-dashboard/pull/39 On December 18, 201

Fwd: Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-18 Thread Sean Owen
In practice, most issues with no activity for, say, 6+ months are dead. There's down-side in believing they will eventually get done by somebody, since they almost always don't. Most is clutter, but if there are important bugs among them, then the fact they're idling is a different problem: too mu

Re: Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-18 Thread Josh Rosen
I don’t think that it makes sense to just close inactive JIRA issue without any human review.  There are many legitimate feature requests / bug reports that might be inactive for a long time because they’re low priorities to fix or because nobody has had time to deal with them yet. On December

Re: Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-15 Thread Nicholas Chammas
OK, that's good. Another approach we can take to controlling the number of stale JIRA issues is writing a bot that simply closes issues after N days of inactivity and prompts people to reopen the issue if it's still valid. I believe Sean Owen proposed that at one point (?). I wonder if that might

Re: Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-15 Thread Andrew Ash
Nick, Putting the N most stale issues into a report like your latest one does seem like a good way to tackle the wall of text effect that I'm worried about. On Sun, Dec 14, 2014 at 12:28 PM, Nicholas Chammas < nicholas.cham...@gmail.com> wrote: > Taking after Andrew’s suggestion, perhaps the rep

Re: Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-14 Thread Nicholas Chammas
Taking after Andrew’s suggestion, perhaps the report can just focus on Stale issues (no updates in > 90 days), since those are probably the easiest to act on. For example: Stale Issues

Re: Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-14 Thread Nicholas Chammas
I formatted this report using Markdown; I'm open to changing the structure or formatting or reducing the amount of information to make the report more easily consumable. Regarding just sending links or whether this would just be mailing list noise, those are a good questions. I've sent out links

Re: Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-13 Thread Andrew Ash
The goal of increasing visibility on open issues is a good one. How is this different from just a link to Jira though? Some might say this adds noise to the mailing list and doesn't contain any information not already available in Jira. The idea seems good but the formatting leaves a little to b

Spark JIRA Report

2014-12-13 Thread Nicholas Chammas
What do y’all think of a report like this emailed out to the dev list on a monthly basis? The goal would be to increase visibility into our open issues and encourage developers to tend to our issue tracker more frequently. Nick There are 1,236 unresolved issues