Re: Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-07-18 Thread Phil Zoio
Joe, Yes, I seem to pick up this issue every two weeks, and coming back to it again. After reading your answers again and delving into the source code, I think I understand the mechanism pretty well. The problem for me is that Commons Chain does not seem to have an override capability. A

Re: Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-06-30 Thread Phil Zoio
Joe, Could Struts 1.3 set up to have a separate chain per module? Suppose you wanted to partition your app so that certain parts use one chain configuration and other parts use another. In 1.2 you'd use separate subclasses of RequestProcessor. With Struts 1.3, ideally you should be able to

Re: Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-06-30 Thread Ted Husted
That's exactly what Struts 2 does with interceptors, and S2 takes it a step farther by allowing each action to have its own sequence, if you like. An important question is whether we want to stick with Chain in the Struts 1.x series or consider moving to Interceptors for Struts 1.4. I didn't

Re: Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-06-30 Thread Joe Germuska
At 9:07 AM +0100 6/30/06, Phil Zoio wrote: Joe, Could Struts 1.3 set up to have a separate chain per module? Phil: I thought we discussed this two weeks ago. In short, the answer is yes. Looking back at what I wrote, perhaps I gave too much detail at the wrong time. Here is the core of

Re: Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-06-14 Thread Phil Zoio
I can't comment on how people are actually using it, but changing the request processor workflow on a per module basis is quite easy with Struts 1.2. Assuming that this is something which some people are doing, then it would seem to make sense to support this for Struts 1.3 as well, at least

Re: Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-06-14 Thread Joe Germuska
At 9:09 PM +0100 6/14/06, Phil Zoio wrote: I can't comment on how people are actually using it, but changing the request processor workflow on a per module basis is quite easy with Struts 1.2. Assuming that this is something which some people are doing, then it would seem to make sense to

Re: Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-06-14 Thread Phil Zoio
Joe Germuska wrote: At 9:09 PM +0100 6/14/06, Phil Zoio wrote: I can't comment on how people are actually using it, but changing the request processor workflow on a per module basis is quite easy with Struts 1.2. Assuming that this is something which some people are doing, then it would

Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-06-13 Thread Phil Zoio
Is it possible to have multiple chain configurations for the same Struts 1.3 app. For example, can you configure one module to use tiles and another to not do so? Regards, Phil Zoio - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Struts 1.3.x: Using multiple chain configurations

2006-06-13 Thread Joe Germuska
At 9:23 PM +0100 6/13/06, Phil Zoio wrote: Is it possible to have multiple chain configurations for the same Struts 1.3 app. For example, can you configure one module to use tiles and another to not do so? It is technically possible to change which command is looked up in the catalogs and