[slim] Bug when using Replaygain

2007-06-19 Thread cliveb
A few days ago in another thread I reported the results of an experiment which demonstrated that when using Replaygain, the Squeezebox can introduce clipping if the RG value is positive. (Here's a link to that report: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showpost.php?p=208322postcount=22) I have now

Re: [slim] Bug when using Replaygain

2007-06-19 Thread Mark Lanctot
There are reasons why this might not be as high a priority here as you would like. Don't shoot the messenger here, I'm just thinking out loud: - RG values are overwhelmingly negative, mostly -7 to -10 dB. They are very, very rarely positive, I'd say less than 5% of any CDs short of classical

Re: [slim] Bug when using Replaygain

2007-06-19 Thread MelonMonkey
I can assure you that in my collection which sits at just over 20k tracks right now, there were numerous tracks with positive RG when calculating for a target of 89db. The overwhelming majority required negative RG, but there were still a significant number of positives. This process was for

Re: [slim] Bug when using Replaygain

2007-06-19 Thread cliveb
Mark Lanctot;209773 Wrote: - RG values are overwhelmingly negative, mostly -7 to -10 dB. They are very, very rarely positive, I'd say less than 5% of any CDs short of classical you could buy today. Agreed. But as you say, classical CDs often have positive RG values. Since my collection

Re: [slim] Bug when using Replaygain

2007-06-19 Thread cliveb
MelonMonkey;209790 Wrote: I can assure you that in my collection which sits at just over 20k tracks right now, there were numerous tracks with positive RG when calculating for a target of 89db. The overwhelming majority required negative RG, but there were still a significant number of