Re: [DNSOP] Meeting feedbacks/summary on draft-bretelle-dnsop-recursive-iprange-location

2020-11-23 Thread Manu Bretelle
Thanks both, So, I seem to gather that the main problem is to put forward Geolocation as a way to return pseudo-targeted answers to end-users by using the resolver IP as a proxy for it. This was more meant to be a use-case as to how geo location has been used, but It is by no means my intent to pu

Re: [DNSOP] Meeting feedbacks/summary on draft-bretelle-dnsop-recursive-iprange-location

2020-11-23 Thread Vittorio Bertola
> Il 20/11/2020 18:49 Brian Dickson ha > scritto: > > But let's not get distracted by that in the short term, where direct use > of resolver geo has real value. > Also, legal/jurisdiction issues depend on geography and not on network topology. As data localization and privacy protect

Re: [DNSOP] Meeting feedbacks/summary on draft-bretelle-dnsop-recursive-iprange-location

2020-11-20 Thread Brian Dickson
On Thu, Nov 19, 2020 at 9:35 AM Ben Schwartz wrote: > > I do not support the geolocation function. I think the right solution > here is ECS. Even bad IP-geolocation from ECS will be better than using > the recursive resolver's country-code; at least it will be estimating the > location of the r

Re: [DNSOP] Meeting feedbacks/summary on draft-bretelle-dnsop-recursive-iprange-location

2020-11-19 Thread Ben Schwartz
I support the resolver IP range discovery function. I don't think it will be hard to come up with a reasonable format for that. An APL record with standard address families would seem fine. A URI record pointed at a JSON blob or a flat text file would be fine too. I do not support the geolocati

[DNSOP] Meeting feedbacks/summary on draft-bretelle-dnsop-recursive-iprange-location

2020-11-18 Thread Manu Bretelle
Hey all, Thanks a lot for providing feedback on the resolver IP ranges and location distribution draft [0] during the dnsop meeting. I gathered the feedbacks below as follow-ups, but, based on some of the comments made at the "mic" or over Jabber, I would also to provide some clarifications as to