Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread Martin Dobbins
John, No, the video isn't relevant to the original question, the attitude expressed in the video may be. "I figured it out, it took me 5 seconds, 5 months, and after I did I wondered why it took so long because it was so easy" . I think I know why he does that 🙂 Some folks like figuring thing

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread John Dammeyer
Thanks Martin, His question and the subsequent discussion on the MACH group has morphed in now discussions on whether to use closed loop steppers and ethercat. Not sure why everyone is so fond of leadshine closed loop steppers but what do I know. I like my AC servos. A decade or more ago it

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread Chris Albertson
On Tue, Feb 22, 2022 at 9:14 AM John Dammeyer wrote: > Thanks Martin, > His question and the subsequent discussion on the MACH group has morphed > in now discussions on whether to use closed loop steppers and ethercat. > Not sure why everyone is so fond of leadshine closed loop steppers but > wh

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread Martin Dobbins
Hi John, I am a member of the Mach group from Yahoo times, I don't have the rights to post (don't want them either) but sometimes​ the discussions are interesting. I do know the original poster has a robot but didn't want to use it because it is too expensive for the task. With that in mind m

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread Martin Dobbins
Short version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUUOttmUVq4 I think it's a work in progress. From: Martin Dobbins Hi John, I am a member of the Mach group from Yahoo times, I don't have the rights to post (don't want them either) but sometimes​ the discussions

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread andy pugh
On Tue, 22 Feb 2022 at 18:01, Chris Albertson wrote: > That is the big advantage of open source. But the problem is running it on > an antique computer using a modified OS I have rarely run LinuxCNC on an antique computer. Most of my installations have been on brand-new hardware. Although the

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread John Dammeyer
I wish I had the space to play with one of those... > -Original Message- > From: Martin Dobbins [mailto:tu...@hotmail.com] > Sent: February-22-22 10:06 AM > To: Enhanced Machine Controller (EMC) > Subject: Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record > > Hi John, > > I am a member of

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread John Figie
Interesting video and an impressive amount of work done. I have some comments: I think it would be nice if all of the LinuxCNC I/O could be connected using standard ethernet and IEEE1588 for time synchronization. This means that a servo drive needs to be developed that has an ethernet connection t

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread gene heskett
On Tuesday, February 22, 2022 12:58:05 PM EST Chris Albertson wrote: > On Tue, Feb 22, 2022 at 9:14 AM John Dammeyer > > wrote: > > Thanks Martin, > > His question and the subsequent discussion on the MACH group has > > morphed in now discussions on whether to use closed loop steppers > > and eth

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread Ralph Stirling
I think you have just described Ethercat. There are open source Ethercat master and slave implementations (soem and soes). The slave requires a Microchip interface device (LAN9252). I would like ethercat interface to steppers of various sizes, and may work on that this summer. -- Ralph On F

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread John Figie
Actually What I described is not exactly Ethercat but more similar to Ethernet/IP with CIP Motion. Ethercat is not standard Ethernet and that is why the slave requres the mictochip interface device. But if open source master and slave implementations are available maybe that would be a good possibi

Re: [Emc-users] FW: [MachCNC] Mach4 teach/record

2022-02-22 Thread Ralph Stirling
I do wish that Ethercat was truly open source from the ground up. Beckhoff holds all the copyrights, and has an annoying association that holds all the docs. Membership is free, but a hassle. I am jumping through the hoops to join, but haven't finished yet. A real open source vhdl module for FPG

[Emc-users] broken build script

2022-02-22 Thread gene heskett
Greetings all; I've a cascade of scripts that build LinuxCNC on my rpi4, or did, but something has changed, and my make-debs, now bails out quickly. I have a script that builds to the end of runtests, works fine, then the next one makes the debs, but its stopped working with this error chain: ==