Re: [Finale] OT: 4'33: can anyone confirm that it isn't [only] music?

2002-12-28 Thread Andrew Stiller
When I played 4'33 last year, I did an internet search on the piece and found all sorts of stuff. There's an interesting article by Larry J. Solomon at http://www.azstarnet.com/~solo/4min33se.htm Here's a short quote from it: Liberties are sometimes taken with the music, from performing it as

Re: [Finale] OT: 4'33: can anyone confirm that it isn't [only]music?

2002-12-27 Thread rolin mains
on 12/26/02 9:17 PM, Harold Owen at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I can see it now - the dancers come out and stand there for 4' 33. as i understand it, cage conceived of that piece based on a study that measured the average attention span to be...you guessed it...4 minutes and 33 seconds. the

Re: [Finale] OT: 4'33: can anyone confirm that it isn't [only] music?

2002-12-27 Thread Christopher BJ Smith
At 10:29 AM -0600 12/27/02, rolin mains wrote: on 12/26/02 9:17 PM, Harold Owen at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I can see it now - the dancers come out and stand there for 4' 33. as i understand it, cage conceived of that piece based on a study that measured the average attention span to

Re: [Finale] OT: 4'33: can anyone confirm that it isn't [only] music?

2002-12-27 Thread Ken Durling
as i understand it, cage conceived of that piece based on a study that measured the average attention span to be...you guessed it...4 minutes and 33 seconds. the idea is that early on in the piece the audience would be enthralled by the idea and as time wears on (about 4 and a half minutes) they

Re: [Finale] OT: 4'33: can anyone confirm that it isn't [only]music?

2002-12-27 Thread Michael Cook
When I played 4'33 last year, I did an internet search on the piece and found all sorts of stuff. There's an interesting article by Larry J. Solomon at http://www.azstarnet.com/~solo/4min33se.htm Here's a short quote from it: Liberties are sometimes taken with the music, from performing it as

Re: [Finale] OT: 4'33: can anyone confirm that it isn't [only]music?

2002-12-27 Thread John Howell
a friend recently brought up an interesting point: as far as he knew, no staging of 4'33 has ever been produced in the realm of dance or theatre. jef Piece of cake. But remember, if you use Cage's composition, you have to pay performance royalties. John John Susie Howell Virginia Tech

[Finale] OT: 4'33: can anyone confirm that it isn't [only] music?

2002-12-26 Thread jef chippewa
a friend recently brought up an interesting point: as far as he knew, no staging of 4'33 has ever been produced in the realm of dance or theatre. all of the discussions i have witnessed of this work took place in a musical context, consisting predominantly of arguments regarding the [non-]

Re: [Finale] OT: 4'33: can anyone confirm that it isn't [only]music?

2002-12-26 Thread Harold Owen
a friend recently brought up an interesting point: as far as he knew, no staging of 4'33 has ever been produced in the realm of dance or theatre. all of the discussions i have witnessed of this work took place in a musical context, consisting predominantly of arguments regarding the [non-]