Re: [Flightgear-devel] build identification

2003-01-06 Thread Andy Ross
Bernie Bright wrote: > The very first thing FG displays is its version number and compiler > info: > [...] > It would be trivial to add a timestamp. A much better idea would be to store a time in the CVS archive. Relying on a compilation date can bite you in very strange ways. Who knows when the

Re: [Flightgear-devel] build identification

2003-01-06 Thread Bernie Bright
On Mon, 6 Jan 2003 22:55:56 -0600 "Jon Berndt" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I found it very helpful to capture a compile date and cvs tag into a > > chip design that verification people could use to direct me to a > > particular verilog code base to reproduce and debug problems. > > Good idea.

RE: [Flightgear-devel] build identification

2003-01-06 Thread Jon Berndt
> I found it very helpful to capture a compile date and cvs tag into a > chip design that verification people could use to direct me to a > particular verilog code base to reproduce and debug problems. Good idea. We sort of do this for JSBSim. Isn't there a command that you can type to get informa

[Flightgear-devel] build identification

2003-01-06 Thread Matt Fienberg
It seems that you guys get hundreds of build-related and/or platform problems to diagnose, and you spend way too much time having to get people to identify their configurations... Something I've done in the past is to generate a string of information at compile time that identifies when and how so

RE: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Tony Peden
On Mon, 2003-01-06 at 17:54, Curtis L. Olson wrote: > Jon Berndt writes: > > > > There might be a yaw rate effect too. When the aircraft is yawing, > > > > the wingtip going "back" also sees a higher AoA and will drop if it > > is > > > > past the stall. Same deal. The snap roll needs a stall

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Tony Peden
On Mon, 2003-01-06 at 15:26, Andy Ross wrote: > David Megginson wrote: > > I found it easier simply to picture different 2D sections of the > > wing stalling at different times, but I can see how your explanation > > might lead to a programmatic solution faster. > > Right, but what is it about dif

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Tony Peden
On Mon, 2003-01-06 at 11:31, Andy Ross wrote: > [Sorry for the delay. This one was hard, and had to wait for the > weekend for an investigation.] > > David Megginson wrote: > > Andy: unfortunately, none of your suggestions helped (details > > below). How are you modelling washout in YASim? Fro

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Norman Vine
David Megginson writes: > Norman Vine writes: > > > Easiest way I know of to learn about airfoil stall is to stick a bunch > > of yarns into an iceboat sail and go for a ride :-) > > That's a lot of work, when you can just go flying in light snow and > watch the flakes around the wings. I hav

RE: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Curtis L. Olson
Jon Berndt writes: > > > There might be a yaw rate effect too. When the aircraft is yawing, > > > the wingtip going "back" also sees a higher AoA and will drop if it > is > > > past the stall. Same deal. The snap roll needs a stalled "down" > > > wingtip to get the divergence, in any case. >

RE: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Jon Berndt
> > There might be a yaw rate effect too. When the aircraft is yawing, > > the wingtip going "back" also sees a higher AoA and will drop if it is > > past the stall. Same deal. The snap roll needs a stalled "down" > > wingtip to get the divergence, in any case. > > That makes sense -- thanks

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Curtis L. Olson
David Megginson writes: > Norman Vine writes: > > > Easiest way I know of to learn about airfoil stall is to stick a bunch > > of yarns into an iceboat sail and go for a ride :-) > > That's a lot of work, when you can just go flying in light snow and > watch the flakes around the wings. I have

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread David Megginson
Norman Vine writes: > Easiest way I know of to learn about airfoil stall is to stick a bunch > of yarns into an iceboat sail and go for a ride :-) That's a lot of work, when you can just go flying in light snow and watch the flakes around the wings. I haven't tried that yet, though. All the

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread David Megginson
Andy Ross writes: > > Isn't the snap roll usually uncoordinated? I've never done aerobatics > > myself. If it is, then I wonder what the role of the uncoordination > > is. > > If there is any wing sweep or dihedral, then a non-zero yaw angle also > changes the relative AoA of the wings to

Re: [Flightgear-devel] 747 segfault

2003-01-06 Thread Andy Ross
Major A wrote: > #0 ssgSGIHeader::getRow() at ssgLoadSGI.cxx:211 > #1 ssgSGIHeader::ssgSGIHeader(... > >"/usr/local/FlightGear/lib/FlightGear/Aircraft/747/Models/boeing747-400-jw-08.rgb", >...) > at ssgLoadSGI.cxx:328 This is plib crashing while trying to load a texture file. My gue

Re: [Flightgear-devel] 747 segfault

2003-01-06 Thread Matthew Johnson
Works fine on SuSE 8.1, after CVS update. Well apart from a blank panel... Matt PS Build also went through without a hitch. On Mon, 2003-01-06 at 15:58, Major A wrote: > > Can one of you get a stack trace in gdb to see where it's crashing? > > This is the command line: > > /usr/local/FlightGe

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Norman Vine
David Megginson writes: >> > I found it easier simply to picture different 2D sections of the wing > stalling at different times, but I can see how your explanation might > lead to a programmatic solution faster. Easiest way I know of to learn about airfoil stall is to stick a bunch of yarns into

Re: [Flightgear-devel] 747 segfault

2003-01-06 Thread Major A
> Can one of you get a stack trace in gdb to see where it's crashing? This is the command line: /usr/local/FlightGear/bin/fgfs --fg-root=/usr/local/FlightGear/lib/FlightGear --aircraft=747 This is what gdb says: Program received signal SIGSEGV, Segmentation fault. [Switching to Thread 16384

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Andy Ross
David Megginson wrote: > I found it easier simply to picture different 2D sections of the > wing stalling at different times, but I can see how your explanation > might lead to a programmatic solution faster. Right, but what is it about different secions of the wing stalling at different times tha

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Andy Ross
Arnt Karlsen wrote: > ..some planes use distinctly different airfoils, leading edge cuffs, > slots etc, to"wash out". Some different-airfoil wings transform > gradually towards the tip, and not neccesarily in a linear fashion, > some of these can get really weird. Actually, this is supported alre

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Arnt Karlsen
On Mon, 06 Jan 2003 11:31:46 -0800, Andy Ross <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > So anyway, YASim needs to model washout. In principle, this should be > pretty easy. Each wing segment (Surface object, as currently > implemented) gets its own orientation already. We

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread David Megginson
Andy Ross writes: > The real reason for washout (or at least a better physical > explanation) is this: the washout that maintains the tips below > stall AoA keeps as much of the "stable" derivative as possible out > on the wing tips where the moment arm is long. If the early stall > happens

Re: [Flightgear-devel] FlightGear Modification Project

2003-01-06 Thread Arnt Karlsen
On 05 Jan 2003 23:07:47 -0800, Matthew Johnson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > > > ..I'll ask and cc here, look for > > "http://www.dlsproductions.com/fg/"; in the "Subject: " header. > > You're all taking this rather well, as far as I can tell... ..I've recei

Re: [Flightgear-devel] 747 segfault

2003-01-06 Thread Jim Wilson
"Curtis L. Olson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: > Andy Ross writes: > > I can't reproduce this with the command line solver (and can't run > > fgfs from work). Crashes in YASim are (well, have been) almost always > > in the parser, and happen due to unhandled syntax errors. Are you > > sure you have

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Problem: unrealistic YASim stalls

2003-01-06 Thread Andy Ross
[Sorry for the delay. This one was hard, and had to wait for the weekend for an investigation.] David Megginson wrote: > Andy: unfortunately, none of your suggestions helped (details > below). How are you modelling washout in YASim? From the violent > roll that comes with every stall, it looks

Re: [Flightgear-devel] 747 segfault

2003-01-06 Thread Curtis L. Olson
Andy Ross writes: > I can't reproduce this with the command line solver (and can't run > fgfs from work). Crashes in YASim are (well, have been) almost always > in the parser, and happen due to unhandled syntax errors. Are you > sure you have the proper base package and an unmodified 747.xml file

Re: [Flightgear-devel] 747 segfault

2003-01-06 Thread Andy Ross
Matthew Johnson wrote: > Major A wrote: > > does the 747-yasim segfault fgfs on everyone's computer? > > Yes I get a segfault too I can't reproduce this with the command line solver (and can't run fgfs from work). Crashes in YASim are (well, have been) almost always in the parser, and happen due

Re: [Flightgear-devel] FlightGear Modification Project

2003-01-06 Thread David Megginson
Matthew Johnson writes (quoting an online review): > "Overall the system structure and coding is poor - and reflects the > checkered and disrupted development history" That is true, unfortunately. FlightGear's code is better organized than many open source projects (and far better than nearly