Re: ODF Toolkit may need help

If the podling *has* cleared all IP, then I could see allowing it. But we certainly don't want improper IP residing in the Attic. These aren't Apache projects until graduation, so don't really belong. I can see releases strengthening the argument for archival. Henri should be able to clarify.

[NOTICE] corinthia PPMC+committer -= dortef, franz, gbg, ianc, jani, louis, pmkelly

Hereby the official notice that multiple developers have left apache Corinthia. I am sad that I as (former) mentor, was not able to keep the community in apache. A little constructive support from the IPMC had probably prevented the meltdown. The developer community continues the teamwork in a

Re: ODF Toolkit may need help

As this discussion is taking place someone just asked to join the project On Sat, Sep 5, 2015 at 3:34 AM, Dave Fisher wrote: > I recollect seeing a retiring podling with releases go to the attic. If that > is not correct or it was an exceptional case then thanks for

Re: [NOTICE] corinthia PPMC+committer -= dortef, franz, gbg, ianc, jani, louis, pmkelly

Both Bertrand and I have tried to become involved in this and help avert this melt-down. There is clearly quite a lot of back-channel happening that is not visible to the Apache mailing lists and I (and apparently Bertrand) have been unable to get our sub requests moderated through in time. It

Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Kylin-1.0-incubating

Thanks Justin, we will double check all those files and licenses to make sure clean in next release (will kick off soon after this release). JIRA created for tracking here: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KYLIN-999 Thanks. Best Regards! - Luke Han On Sat, Sep 5,

Re: [NOTICE] corinthia PPMC+committer -= dortef, franz, gbg, ianc, jani, louis, pmkelly

On Saturday, September 5, 2015, Ted Dunning wrote: > Both Bertrand and I have tried to become involved in this and help avert > this melt-down. There is clearly quite a lot of back-channel happening that > is not visible to the Apache mailing lists and I (and apparently

Re: [NOTICE] corinthia PPMC+committer -= dortef, franz, gbg, ianc, jani, louis, pmkelly

On Sat, Sep 5, 2015 at 3:36 PM, jan i wrote: > As noted elsewhere, I saw the request from bertrand and he had access > within an hour, I never saw yours (Dennis is also moderator, so he > should/can have seen it), so I do not understand the delay. Ted is doing what he can, and

Re: [NOTICE] corinthia PPMC+committer -= dortef, franz, gbg, ianc, jani, louis, pmkelly

On Sat, Sep 5, 2015 at 6:16 PM, Marvin Humphrey wrote: > PS: Surely this response is imperfect as well. > Such imperfections are not visible to humans. At the least, it is pretty damned good. Thanks.

Re: ODF Toolkit may need help

Thanks. Regarding domain names that's good advice. Should retirement happen we can follow that course. There seems to be fresh blood in the project. We will need to see. Regards, Dave Sent from my iPhone > On Sep 5, 2015, at 6:59 PM, Henri Yandell wrote: > > I don't see

[Result][VOTE] Release Apache Kylin-1.0-incubating

This vote passes with 5 +1s +1 Henry Saputra (binding) +1 P. Taylor Goetz (binding) +1 Marvin Humphrey (binding) +1 Julian Hyde (binding) +1 Luke Han (none-binding) and 0 votes, and 1 -1s: Justin Mclean (binding) As discussion, Kylin community will process to release this version and tracked

Re: Shepherd notes for ODF Toolkit

Having extra hands is really important. On Thu, Sep 3, 2015 at 4:05 AM, Rob Weir wrote: > On Wednesday, September 2, 2015, John D. Ament > wrote: > > > All, > > > > I'm adding some shepherd notes for ODF Toolkit. I think my main concern > is > > lack

Re: ODF Toolkit may need help

I don't see any project within the Attic that came there from the Incubator. If one did, it should have passed its IP items already. My opinion on domain names for a project not graduating is that we give it back to who gave it to us, or if they don't want it back, let them decide who we should

Re: [NOTICE] corinthia PPMC+committer -= dortef, franz, gbg, ianc, jani, louis, pmkelly

Hi Marvin, Very true. I am sorry that we did not come to the IPMC sooner. Perhaps after my second attempt to cool things. Maybe a mentor should use frustration to determine when ask for help. Maybe it should not be private@. What if there was a mentor@ private ML explicitly for this help?