Re: [IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-25 Thread sebb
In the past, SVN repos have just been made read-only. (The intention was to move them to http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/incubator/RETIRED/ but that never happened) I think it would be a mistake to drop the repos. There's no guarantee that the code is available anywhere else, and it seems wrong to

Re: [IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-25 Thread Daniel Gruno
Just a note from infra that we'll need a decision from the IPMC on this matter no later than February 7th, preferably before :) With regards, Daniel. On 1/13/19 10:14 AM, Daniel Gruno wrote: Hello IPMC and other folks, We have a big bunch of retired podlings with git repositories on

Re: [IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-14 Thread Sharan Foga
Hi Daniel Yes I'll be using Kibble so a great suggestion! Sounds like a win-win situation to me :-) Thanks Sharan On 2019/01/14 11:14:26, Daniel Gruno wrote: > On 1/14/19 12:12 PM, Sharan F wrote: > > Hi Greg > > > > You have a good point and my need is a more of a personal one (rather > >

Re: [IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-14 Thread Daniel Gruno
On 1/14/19 12:12 PM, Sharan F wrote: Hi Greg You have a good point and my need is a more of a personal one (rather than an IPMC one) so if delete is the consensus,  then go for it. I won't hold it up. If you are doing research on them, and you are (presumably) using Kibble there, you could

Re: [IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-14 Thread Sharan F
Hi Greg You have a good point and my need is a more of a personal one (rather than an IPMC one) so if delete is the consensus, then go for it. I won't hold it up. Thanks Sharan On Mon, 14 Jan 2019, 11:25 Greg Stein If they didn't graduate, then they aren't Apache projects. So as Myrle >

Re: [IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-14 Thread Greg Stein
If they didn't graduate, then they aren't Apache projects. So as Myrle says, "what are they doing on our servers?" For the retired podlings, our copy of their code could be misleading, relative to where it came from, or where the community may have newly forked it. Not an Infra opinion, -g On

Re: [IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-13 Thread Sharan F
Hi I am doing some research on incubator projects and the ones that didn't make it to TLP could be interesting to analyse so I'd be in favour of the rename rather than a delete for now. Thanks Sharan On Mon, 14 Jan 2019, 07:12 Myrle Krantz If we can’t name a reason for keeping the data,

Re: [IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-13 Thread Myrle Krantz
If we can’t name a reason for keeping the data, I’d be inclined to just delete. We are not data squirrels. : o), Myrle On Sun, Jan 13, 2019 at 10:15 AM Daniel Gruno wrote: > Hello IPMC and other folks, > > We have a big bunch of retired podlings with git repositories on > git-wip-us. As we

[IPMC] What to do with retired podling repositories

2019-01-13 Thread Daniel Gruno
Hello IPMC and other folks, We have a big bunch of retired podlings with git repositories on git-wip-us. As we are working on retiring this service, we need to address what happens with these old project repositories. The retired podlings we need to address are: blur, cmda, concerted,