Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-09 Thread Patrick Falcone
We did this, long ago far away, at our time share NVIP, IBM 3880-11 w/3350's. I'm with you on this Ted, I always liked to keep this, paging environment, simple as possible with paging with own volume. This may be a bit of old school thinking but when there are problems or potential data

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-09 Thread Ted MacNEIL
Ted, I always liked to keep this, paging environment, simple as possible with paging with own volume. This may be a bit of old school thinking but when there are problems or potential data management issues I know straight away what it most probably is not. I agree, obviously. But, some people

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread (IBM Mainframe Discussion List)
In a message dated 5/7/2008 11:57:26 P.M. Central Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: If I am right that resume subchannel is no longer used by ASM, than putting other low to medium use datasets on the same volume will make little or no difference to paging performance. The devil is

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Ted MacNEIL
If I am right that resume subchannel is no longer used by ASM, than putting other low to medium use datasets on the same volume will make little or no difference to paging performance. I disagree. I still think that page volumes (regardless of size) should be dedicated, except the PLPA/CSA

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread (IBM Mainframe Discussion List)
In a message dated 5/8/2008 8:54:18 A.M. Central Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Yes, SUSPEND/RESUME is no longer in use, on supported releases of z/OS. No longer in use by the paging subsystem. But still in use by XCF, at least it was the last time I looked at a GTF I/O

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Ron Hawkins
Bill, The devil is in the detail. If the page datasets are being accessed their own alias UCB then the channel commands, FCP frames and disk IO are being interleaved with all the other volumes that share the same channels, storage ports and disk drives. Even a heavy use sequential use dataset

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Ron Hawkins
Ted, Your free to have your own opinion, but if your storage admin required demonstrable benefit of dedicated page volumes or you lose them, what would you show him? What problems are you avoiding and how is it cleaner for her/him? Ron I disagree. I still think that page volumes

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Ted MacNEIL
Your free to have your own opinion, but if your storage admin required demonstrable benefit of dedicated page volumes or you lose them, what would you show him? What problems are you avoiding and how is it cleaner for her/him? 1. Don't have to back anything up. 2. You don't have the potential

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Mark Zelden
On Thu, 8 May 2008 09:35:01 -0700, Ron Hawkins [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Bill, The devil is in the detail. If the page datasets are being accessed their own alias UCB then the channel commands, FCP frames and disk IO are being interleaved with all the other volumes that share the same channels,

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Ron Hawkins
. For number 3, no comment. Ron -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Ted MacNEIL Sent: Thursday, May 08, 2008 9:43 AM To: IBM-MAIN@BAMA.UA.EDU Subject: Re: [IBM-MAIN] 3 Page Datasets on one Volume Your free to have your own

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Ron Hawkins
] On Behalf Of Mark Zelden Sent: Thursday, May 08, 2008 10:05 AM To: IBM-MAIN@BAMA.UA.EDU Subject: Re: [IBM-MAIN] 3 Page Datasets on one Volume On Thu, 8 May 2008 09:35:01 -0700, Ron Hawkins [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Bill, The devil is in the detail. If the page datasets are being accessed

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Tom Marchant
On Thu, 8 May 2008 10:05:19 -0700, Ron Hawkins wrote: Ted, For number 1, do logical backups and exclude the page datasets. For number 2, on current z/OS releases I believe this is in the MVS myth category. It's only a potential problem if you go back to early OS390 releases, or you do not use

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Ted MacNEIL
There was a time that the recommendation was to put paging data sets on dedicated volumes attached to dedicated control units. I've never seen anyone do that with ordinary DASD. I did it 3330's, 3350's, 3380's from 1981 to 1989. Dedicated DASD, control units and channels. With 3390's, and

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-08 Thread Jim Mulder
IBM Mainframe Discussion List IBM-MAIN@BAMA.UA.EDU wrote on 05/08/2008 11:52:31 AM: In a message dated 5/8/2008 8:54:18 A.M. Central Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Yes, SUSPEND/RESUME is no longer in use, on supported releases of z/OS. No longer in use by the paging subsystem.

3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Eric Bielefeld
I noticed again today that we have 6 local page datasets on 2 volumes - each a 3390-3. I'm sure they have Pavs, or the equivelent on the dasd, but I'm just wondering if that is a good practice or not. Eric -- Eric Bielefeld Systems Programmer Aviva USA Des Moines, Iowa 515-645-5153

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Ulrich Krueger
Subject: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume I noticed again today that we have 6 local page datasets on 2 volumes - each a 3390-3. I'm sure they have Pavs, or the equivelent on the dasd, but I'm just wondering if that is a good practice or not. Eric -- Eric Bielefeld Systems Programmer Aviva USA

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Ted MacNEIL
I noticed again today that we have 6 local page datasets on 2 volumes - each a 3390-3. I'm sure they have Pavs, or the equivelent on the dasd, but I'm just wondering if that is a good practice or not. 1. I wouldn't do it! 2. Rather than being 'sure', 'ensure'. - Too busy driving to stop for

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Schwarz, Barry A
: Wednesday, May 07, 2008 10:10 AM To: IBM-MAIN@BAMA.UA.EDU Subject: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume I noticed again today that we have 6 local page datasets on 2 volumes - each a 3390-3. I'm sure they have Pavs, or the equivelent on the dasd, but I'm just wondering if that is a good practice

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Eric Bielefeld
Ulrich, I was curious, so I ran just an RMF summary report. We have very little paging. For the 5 day period I ran, I think the highest demand paging for a 15 minute interval was 12 PPS. I had ran this same report in February, and the highest was 57. Most intervals are less than 1 PPS.

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Mark Zelden
-Original Message- From: Eric Bielefeld [mailto:snip] Sent: Wednesday, May 07, 2008 10:10 AM To: IBM-MAIN@BAMA.UA.EDU Subject: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume I noticed again today that we have 6 local page datasets on 2 volumes - each a 3390-3. I'm sure they have Pavs, or the equivelent

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Staller, Allan
It depends. In the old SLED days this could be performance crippling, especially if there was a decent paging rate(remember only one actuator/volume). With little or no paging this would not be a large problem. Fast forward 20 years: Data is mapped transparently to many many small drives,

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Eric Bielefeld
There are only the 3 page datasets on each of the 2 volumes, and they take all of the available space. I was going to mention in the original post that our datacenter is contracted out, so there is really nothing I can do about changing our paging configuration. I know someone mentioned that

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread John Laubenheimer
On Wed, 7 May 2008 14:58:21 -0500, Staller, Allan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It depends. In the old SLED days this could be performance crippling, especially if there was a decent paging rate(remember only one actuator/volume). With little or no paging this would not be a large problem. Fast

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Ulrich Krueger
-MAIN@BAMA.UA.EDU Subject: Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume Ulrich, I was curious, so I ran just an RMF summary report. We have very little paging. For the 5 day period I ran, I think the highest demand paging for a 15 minute interval was 12 PPS. I had ran this same report in February

Re: 3 Page Datasets on one Volume

2008-05-07 Thread Ron Hawkins
Laubenheimer Sent: Wednesday, May 07, 2008 2:38 PM To: IBM-MAIN@BAMA.UA.EDU Subject: Re: [IBM-MAIN] 3 Page Datasets on one Volume On Wed, 7 May 2008 14:58:21 -0500, Staller, Allan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It depends. In the old SLED days this could be performance crippling, especially