RE: Abwesenheitsnotiz: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-27 Thread Stanley, Jeremy
am my homecomputer; beam myself into the future." --Kraftwerk, 1981 > -- > From: Schackel, Fa. Integrata, ZRZ > DA[SMTP:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 1999 3:54 PM > To: Stanley, Jeremy > Subject: Abwesenheitsnotiz: Booti

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-25 Thread jakob
On Wed, Aug 25, 1999 at 10:12:18AM -0400, Stanley, Jeremy wrote: > Shouldn't be too hard to throw together a bash script that reruns LILO > for each MBR, with different parameters, I wouldn't think... Anyone > disagree? If anyone has the time to do that (eh, takes the time to do that), then why

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-25 Thread James Manning
> Shouldn't be too hard to throw together a bash script that reruns LILO > for each MBR, with different parameters, I wouldn't think... Anyone > disagree? Hmmm here's a question... If you run the raid on the whole drives instead of creating partitions, do you even need to re-run lilo for all dev

RE: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-25 Thread Stanley, Jeremy
OTECTED] > Subject: Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible > > > This does open RAID-5 systems up for a full-redundancy solution with > > little loss in capacity... Allocate the first 5 or 10MB on each > drive > > in your array for /boot as an n-way RAID-1 mir

RE: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-25 Thread Stanley, Jeremy
anley, Jeremy > Subject: RE: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible > > On Tue, 24 Aug 1999, Stanley, Jeremy wrote: > > This does open RAID-5 systems up for a full-redundancy solution with > > little loss in capacity... Allocate the first 5 or 10MB on each > dri

RE: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-24 Thread Stanley, Jeremy
Ferrell > Cc: Harald Nordgård-Hansen; James Manning; Linux RAID Mailing List > Subject: Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible > > On Tue, 24 Aug 1999, Mark Ferrell wrote: > [clip] > Don't forget, though, that we're only talking about booting RAID 1 > here... > [snip]

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-24 Thread Andy Poling
On Tue, 24 Aug 1999, Mark Ferrell wrote: > Maybe you two could work together and make a RaidRoot-HOWTO that covers both lilo > and grub?? I think that's an excellent idea - one stop shopping. Don't forget, though, that we're only talking about booting RAID 1 here... not RAID booting in general.

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-24 Thread Mark Ferrell
Maybe you two could work together and make a RaidRoot-HOWTO that covers both lilo and grub?? -- Mark Ferrell : [EMAIL PROTECTED] Andy Poling wrote: > On 23 Aug 1999, Harald Nordgård-Hansen wrote: > > James Manning <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > > > How come I've been running this for about a

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-23 Thread Luca Berra
On Sun, Aug 22, 1999 at 01:28:32PM +0200, Harald Nordgård-Hansen wrote: > disk=/dev/md1 > bios=0x80 > sectors=32 > heads=64 > cylinders=4341 > partition = /dev/md0 > start = 32 Gosh, you are a genius, or pheraps i am just a dumbass i spent a lot of time trying

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-23 Thread Andy Poling
On 23 Aug 1999, Harald Nordgård-Hansen wrote: > James Manning <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > > How come I've been running this for about a year and a half, then? > > > > I believe he's talking about not having to do *any* non-raid partitions > > (ie your /boot I believe, reading your lilo.conf)

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-23 Thread Tim Walberg
One method I've seen on another platform (Solaris/Veritas) is as follows: 1) boot loader knows about a list of the various components of the boot RAID device (accomplished via eeprom on SPARC) and will attempt to boot from the first of these it can talk to 2) first component is accessed

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-23 Thread Harald Nordgård-Hansen
James Manning <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > How come I've been running this for about a year and a half, then? > > I believe he's talking about not having to do *any* non-raid partitions > (ie your /boot I believe, reading your lilo.conf) > (...) > > Please enlighten if I missed the point in hi

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-23 Thread James Manning
> How come I've been running this for about a year and a half, then? I believe he's talking about not having to do *any* non-raid partitions (ie your /boot I believe, reading your lilo.conf) I have to admit, his success with GRUB has been good to hear about. Adding in the code to handle raid wi

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-22 Thread Harald Nordgård-Hansen
Andy Poling <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > LILO is just not going to let me boot my RAID 1 root. > > This is not a slam on LILO. Heck, I've happily used it for years to boot my > Linux systems, and probably will continue to on my non-root-raid systems > just because it works out of the box. How

Re: Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-21 Thread Marc Mutz
Andy Poling wrote: > > > I'm willing to put together a cookbook description, of sorts, to patch and set > up GRUB to boot RAID 1, and post it to the list. I guess my question is > whether there's any interest in such a thing. It's entirely possible that > most people are smarter than me, and

Booting Root RAID 1 Directly _Is_ Possible

1999-08-21 Thread Andy Poling
OK maybe this isn't rocket science, but I've seen it asked plenty of times, and the only solutions I've seen presented required seperate /boot partitions and/or ramdisks. Yech (IMHO). I don't want a 12-step boot process involving a bunch of different partitions... I just want it to work. The pr