VERY OFF TOPIC: POLITICS

2005-05-05 Thread RichardTomBeck
Hi Arto, I remember the days before the Berlin Wall came down. I was living in Germany at the time. From the Americans helping out in the Berlin blockade, onto the Russian invasion of the then Czechoslovakia in 1968, the Solidarity movement in Poland, and many, many more crises which directly a

VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-05 Thread RichardTomBeck
You ask 'Is this all serious, or some kind of a joke?' It's all quite serious. and how I feel. Why shouldn't someone admire America and the good it's done? I'm no politician, but reading the other messages on this subject, the others don't seem to be either. Cheers TB -- To get on or off th

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC: POLITICS

2005-05-05 Thread ariel abramovich
> > Of course you and I could point to situations where America has acted > badly, > but then, who hasn't? I've never been to America, not have I any desire to > go > there. But I do know that, whatever failings the country may have, I owe > my > life to them, as do countless millions of other

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-05 Thread ariel abramovich
> You ask 'Is this all serious, or some kind of a joke?' It's all quite > serious. and how I feel. Why shouldn't someone admire America and the good > it's done? > I'm no politician, but reading the other messages on this subject, the > others > don't seem to be either. Cheers Sorry, I just w

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-05 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
good. Cheers, Marion Mezzosoprano -Original Message-- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: May 5, 2005 8:50 AM To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS) You ask 'Is this all serious, or some kind of a joke?' It's all quite serious. and how I feel. Why shouldn'

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-05 Thread Craig Allen
Marion wrote: > >Freedom is not free and it is also not cheap. "You can have peace and you can have freedom. Just don't count on having them together." -- Robert A. Heinlein Regards, Craig ___ $0 Web Hosting with up to 200MB web space, 10

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC: POLITICS

2005-05-05 Thread Thomas Schall
I think Arto made the mistake to set the Bush administration equal to the USA. I don't think there is much anti-americanismn in europe but Bush (and others of his administration) would be regarded as a criminal by a very huge percentage of people in europe. The US never had a president like th

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-05 Thread Roman Turovsky
Craig Allen scripsit: > Marion wrote: >> Freedom is not free and it is also not cheap. > "You can have peace and you can have freedom. Just don't count on having them > together." -- Robert A. Heinlein A recipe for Fascism. RT -- http://polyhymnion.org/torban To get on or off this list see list

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC: POLITICS

2005-05-05 Thread lute9
Thomas Schall scripsit: > I think Arto made the mistake to set the Bush administration equal to the USA. But we, as civilized lutenists, know: there is more to Finland than Arto. RT ___ $0 Web Hosting with up to 200MB web space, 1000 MB Tra

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-05 Thread corun
Roman wrote: >I wrote: > > > "You can have peace and you can have freedom. Just don't count on > having them > > together." -- Robert A. Heinlein > >A recipe for Fascism. You appear to have missed the point. If you want to keep your freedom you must be willing to fight for it, and that tends to

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-05 Thread Roman Turovsky
[EMAIL PROTECTED] scripsit: > Roman wrote: > >> I wrote: >> >>> "You can have peace and you can have freedom. Just don't count on >> having them >>> together." -- Robert A. Heinlein >> >> A recipe for Fascism. > > You appear to have missed the point. If you want to keep your freedom you > must

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread Craig Allen
Roman wrote: > >I know what your intent is, but Bob Heinlein is not exactly a model of >intellectual precision, obviously... Obvious to you maybe. Are the conclusions wrong? Craig ___ $0 Web Hosting with up to 200MB web space, 1000 MB Tra

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread lute9
Craig Allen scripsit: > Roman wrote: >> I know what your intent is, but Bob Heinlein is not exactly a model of >> intellectual precision, obviously... > Obvious to you maybe. Are the conclusions wrong? > Craig You might be helped by the original context, but the way the aphorism was presented makes

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread The Other
> I know what your intent is, but Bob Heinlein is not exactly a model of > intellectual precision, obviously... > RT Robert Heinlein. What do you think about his premise in Starship Troopers? (I'll need to reread the book again to be certain.) That the right to vote is only given to those wh

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread lute9
The Other scripsit: >> I know what your intent is, but Bob Heinlein is not exactly a model of >> intellectual precision, obviously... >> RT > > Robert Heinlein. > > What do you think about his premise in Starship Troopers? > (I'll need to reread the book again to be certain.) > > That the r

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread lute9
Craig Allen scripsit: > Roman wrote: >> I know what your intent is, but Bob Heinlein is not exactly a model of >> intellectual precision, obviously... > Obvious to you maybe. Are the conclusions wrong? > Craig Unlike you, I had an 18 years experience of living in a police state. Beware of what you

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread Craig Allen
Roman wrote: > >You might be helped by the original context, but the way the aphorism was >presented makes is sound like advocacy of a police state. Actually you may be helped by the original context. I know what it is. For context read Starship Troopers. Try to pay attention to the messages bein

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread lute9
Craig Allen scripsit: > Roman wrote: >> >> You might be helped by the original context, but the way the aphorism was >> presented makes is sound like advocacy of a police state. > > Actually you may be helped by the original context. I know what it is. For > context read Starship Troopers. Try t

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 08:59 AM 5/6/2005, The Other wrote: >Robert Heinlein. > >What do you think about his premise in Starship Troopers? >(I'll need to reread the book again to be certain.) > >That the right to vote is only given to those who have served in the >military. I don't think anything at all about it.

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread Roman Turovsky
Eugene C. Braig IV scripsit: > At 08:59 AM 5/6/2005, The Other wrote: >> Robert Heinlein. >> >> What do you think about his premise in Starship Troopers? >> (I'll need to reread the book again to be certain.) >> >> That the right to vote is only given to those who have served in the >> milit

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 10:21 AM 5/6/2005, Roman Turovsky wrote: >Is the Right to bear Lutes inalienable? Without doubt! To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread lute9
Eugene C. Braig IV scripsit: > At 10:21 AM 5/6/2005, Roman Turovsky wrote: >> Is the Right to bear Lutes inalienable? > Without doubt! Make it audible in Washington. RT -- http://polyhymnion.org/torban ___ $0 Web Hosting with up to 200MB w

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 10:34 AM 5/6/2005, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >Eugene C. Braig IV scripsit: > > At 10:21 AM 5/6/2005, Roman Turovsky wrote: > >> Is the Right to bear Lutes inalienable? > > Without doubt! >Make it audible in Washington. Oddly enough, part of my day job is to pound the pavement and be audible on

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-06 Thread lute9
>>> At 10:21 AM 5/6/2005, Roman Turovsky wrote: Is the Right to bear Lutes inalienable? >>> Without doubt! Given that a theorbo could take a few lives in one sideways sweep: could it be considered a Lute of Mass Destruction? RT ___ $0

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC (POLITICS)

2005-05-09 Thread Carl Donsbach
--On Friday, May 06, 2005 10:52 AM -0400 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: At 10:21 AM 5/6/2005, Roman Turovsky wrote: > Is the Right to bear Lutes inalienable? Without doubt! > Given that a theorbo could take a few lives in one sideways sweep: could > it be considered a Lute of Mass Destruct

VERY OFF TOPIC: POLITICS - don't read if you are Bush challenged...

2005-05-04 Thread Arto Wikla
Dear lute gang, please forgive me the following... I just try to clear reasons of not understanding the world today. In a private mail I wrote to one of the List members the following. And please, if you dislike politics and/or moral, skip what follows!!! Here comes the quote from a private mail

Civilized lutenists and the continuity of civilization (was RE: VERY OFF TOPIC: POLITICS)

2005-05-05 Thread Stuart LeBlanc
: Re: VERY OFF TOPIC: POLITICS Thomas Schall scripsit: > I think Arto made the mistake to set the Bush administration equal to the USA. But we, as civilized lutenists, know: there is more to Finland than Arto. RT ___ $0 Web Hosting with

Re: VERY OFF TOPIC: POLITICS...but I wish it were on topic and not politics.

2005-05-05 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
Whatever I think of this topic is irrelevant on this list. I get enough of this type of banter from conversation, radio, print media, television, etc. Unfortunately, I get precious little talk of lute kin from most conversation, radio, print media, television, etc. I wish I could get some lu