Re: [MediaWiki-l] Announcing new MediaWiki forum

2017-11-08 Thread Sam Wilson
On Thu, 9 Nov 2017, at 07:07 AM, Ryan Schmidt wrote: > From my understanding, the point of Discourse was to be simply a Q&A > site. This forum has this as well, however it aims to also build a > community of MediaWiki users and admins beyond just a Q&A so that there's > a place to go to just talk a

Re: [MediaWiki-l] Announcing new MediaWiki forum

2017-11-08 Thread Ryan Schmidt
Chris, That is indeed the main problem I forsee with it, as with any new community-oriented site. Building up a community organically is hard and time-consuming. This is why I'm promoting it in a respectful manner here and elsewhere. Around 10 years ago, there was a successful forum with a very

Re: [MediaWiki-l] Announcing new MediaWiki forum

2017-11-08 Thread chris tharp
Hi Ryan, Sounds like a great idea, but as it is won't it have a critical mass problem? Meaning the other methods used right now, like this mailing list, are attached one way, or another, to mediawiki.org and therefore draw people in. Without a lot of conversations, and questions answered, it wo

Re: [MediaWiki-l] Announcing new MediaWiki forum

2017-11-08 Thread Ryan Schmidt
From my understanding, the point of Discourse was to be simply a Q&A site. This forum has this as well, however it aims to also build a community of MediaWiki users and admins beyond just a Q&A so that there's a place to go to just talk about MediaWiki in general, share tips, spitball ideas to m

Re: [MediaWiki-l] Announcing new MediaWiki forum

2017-11-08 Thread Sam Wilson
Isn't this rather a replication of the trial Discourse forum at https://discourse.wmflabs.org/ ? (Which, unfortunately, is offline for an upgrade at the moment!) But anyway, sounds like an interesting idea. :-) What software is it using? On Thu, 9 Nov 2017, at 06:10 AM, Ryan Schmidt wrote: > Al

[MediaWiki-l] Announcing new MediaWiki forum

2017-11-08 Thread Ryan Schmidt
All, Right now, all methods of getting support for and general discussion about MediaWiki fall flat in many areas. * This mailing list is good for long-form questions and answers, but is difficult to search leading to multiple duplicate questions. The nature of the list also makes thi

Re: [MediaWiki-l] edit sections with different forms

2017-11-08 Thread Evans, Richard K. (GRC-H000)
Hi Yaron, Thanks for responding.. Yes, Page Forms ... oh.. are you saying that the edit sections link will edit the sections of the forms separately if the "edit with form" form has sections as well? Maybe I just need to experiment with it. -Rich -Original Message- From: MediaWiki

Re: [MediaWiki-l] edit sections with different forms

2017-11-08 Thread Yaron Koren
Hi, I assume you're asking about the Page Forms extension. There are ways to do that using actual Page Forms forms, although I would think it's not necessary, because each section should already have an "Edit" link above it, letting the user edit that one section. Isn't that enough? -Yaron On Tu