Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-24 Thread Igor Sysoev
On Wed, 18 Sep 2002, Peter Bi wrote: > Problem in authentication: if mod_perl returns cached header and the > document is proxy cached in the plain Apache, the backend authentication > handler (in the mod_perl server) will not be able to protect it. If you use HTTP Basic authentication then res

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-23 Thread Ask Bjoern Hansen
On Wed, 18 Sep 2002, Peter Bi wrote: > The linked page is great, especially the first picture. > > Problem in authentication: if mod_perl returns cached header and > the document is proxy cached in the plain Apache, the backend > authentication handler (in the mod_perl server) will not be able >

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-23 Thread Vivek Khera
> "PB" == Peter Bi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: PB> The linked page is great, especially the first picture. PB> Problem in authentication: if mod_perl returns cached header and the PB> document is proxy cached in the plain Apache, the backend authentication PB> handler (in the mod_perl server

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-18 Thread Peter Bi
Message - From: "Ask Bjoern Hansen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc: "Josh Chamas" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, September 18, 2002 3:36 AM Subject: Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl &g

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-18 Thread Ask Bjoern Hansen
On Thu, 12 Sep 2002 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Hi Josh, > > How about the "dual setup", a plain Apache + a mod_perl > Apache, which some mod_perl sites are based on? You don't do that for "raw performance" as measured in a typical simple benchmark environment. The dual setup is used to not need

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-12 Thread mod_perl
Hi Josh, How about the "dual setup", a plain Apache + a mod_perl Apache, which some mod_perl sites are based on? Another interesting candidate is fastCGI. Peter > We get very similar numbers in our benchmarking. Please see > the benchmarks I have published on this at: > >http://chamas.

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-12 Thread Perrin Harkins
Pierre Laplante wrote: > I do not use mod_perl with CGI emulation. Actually PerlSetupEnv is on by default. Put PerlSetupEnv Off in your httpd.conf. > Here is my mod_perl code: You are not running the same Perl code in both situations. Under mod_perl, you are using Apache::File and various m

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-11 Thread Josh Chamas
Pierre Laplante wrote: > If I compiled a c module that embed a perl interpreter and > I benchmark this again the same module in mod_perl > > I got a big difference in favor of mod_c. > .5 ms per request is not a big difference. It seems that way when you are a benchmarking a trivial applicatio

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-11 Thread Pierre Laplante
On Wed, 11 Sep 2002, Perrin Harkins wrote: > Pierre Laplante wrote: > > If I compiled a c module that embed a perl interpreter and > > I benchmark this again the same module in mod_perl > > > > I got a big difference in favor of mod_c. > > It will be hard for anyone to give you a good answer un

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-11 Thread Perrin Harkins
Pierre Laplante wrote: > If I compiled a c module that embed a perl interpreter and > I benchmark this again the same module in mod_perl > > I got a big difference in favor of mod_c. It will be hard for anyone to give you a good answer unless you post the code that you benchmarked. At a guess,

Re: performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-10 Thread mod_perl
Interesting but isn't the difference within statistical "fluctuation" ? :-) Did you compare them to the pure C module (without embed Perl)? Peter Bi > If I compiled a c module that embed a perl interpreter and > I benchmark this again the same module in mod_perl > > I got a big difference i

performance regarding mod_perl vs mod_c with embedded perl

2002-09-10 Thread Pierre Laplante
If I compiled a c module that embed a perl interpreter and I benchmark this again the same module in mod_perl I got a big difference in favor of mod_c. For example mod_c give with ab: Requests per second:674.76 [#/sec] (mean) Time per request: 11.86 [ms] (mean) Time per request: