I am a firm believer in the ReleaseArtist should be the DJ mixer.
Especially when it is as blatant as being the artist on the
cover of the
CD. Almost any music store you walk into has these releases
under the DJ
who mixed them.
I just like to bring it to attention that its dangerous
Mmmmh you didn' let me lurk very long did you ? :) Moreover, I have my
main PC going in pieces, so I'll try be concise.
(FYI mangled refers to the discussion at the bottom of
http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/CapitalizationStandardFrench)
First, I want to precise that french is my mother tongue,
On Wed, Jul 26, 2006 at 06:22:28PM -0600, Beth wrote:
I think it Is a mistake to simplify if there are standard rules known.
After all, we could easily say, it's easier not to fight through artist
intent with an artist that has all their name in lowercase (matchbox
twenty) or Japanese tracks
Yes, if they are obviously credited as such, like the Tiesto releases.
But not if the DJ mix is just a minor credit or guest appearance, such as
the Gatecrasher series, Tunnel Trance Force series, DJ Networx series and
other releases similar.
Though I am a classical lover and I like it that MB uses the composer
for artist in classical, I am not so sure we should make a difference
between clasical soundtracks and other soundtracks. I'd prefer a
general rule. I am not sure classical users will check the
soundtracks to see if some of
On 7/27/06, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I think it Is a mistake to simplify if there are standard rules known. [...]
I think we need to respect the language and artist for each demographic
and culture if infact we are going to respect any.
I absolutely agree with this. The problem is that
On 7/26/06, Arturus Magi [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
On 7/25/06, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
The albums that are usually called in Japanese Image Albums and in
Hollywood Music inspired by This is pretty common, they can be
both instrumental (when inspired from the score) and/or pop/rock
I appreciate your thoughts, and I know I opened that sort of by stating what
the general rules are and how they are generally categorized. I will keep
this for the next phase be assured. Right now though, I am just seeking a
common ground on what different types of soundtracks there are, and how
On Thu, Jul 27, 2006 at 12:13:00AM +0200, Mangled wrote:
Personally I much prefer standard sentence case because it's much
simpler
Being simpler doesn't make it good, or even better. Argument
discarded, says the prosecutor :D
When did I say that it makes it good or better? I simply stated
On 7/27/06, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I agree they merit mentioning, and I will include them, but I will need your
help on that, since I know nothing about them. Basically in case I didn't
make it clear, I want to define this so we can then say, this should apply
to the soundtrack style,
On 27/07/06, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Does anyone else have any more types of soundtracks? I know they can be
added later. Just figured I'd get as many outlooks as I could before drawing
up the wiki for it.
not sure if it really counts, but perhaps deserves a mention:
-Original Message-
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Nikki
Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2006 7:51 AM
To: MusicBrainz style discussion
Subject: Re: [mb-style] Is french silly? :p (French capitalization rules)
snip
Again, to me, the fact some/most people don't
Can you go into a little more detail? How is it a concept album of the
soundtrack? Is it because it was inspired by the movie? Such as Boiled in
Lead's Gypsy is inspired by a book? What is the theme, I am sorry, I am
unfamiliar with this. Is it similar to what Lauri defined?
Thanks Chris, sorry
On 27/07/06, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Can you go into a little more detail? How is it a concept album of the
soundtrack? Is it because it was inspired by the movie
well, there is no movie :) the basically made a soundtrack album to a
movie that doesn't exist (or at least, only in their
On Thu, Jul 27, 2006 at 07:57:48AM -0600, Beth wrote:
I didn't say that the rules are wrong. However, there is no point in
deciding on rules that nobody except a couple of people use.
I disagree, why else did we have such a discussion on latin, and I feel
if there are rules in place before
Also there are the actual game discs which sometimes have cd-player-playable
music tracks on them. There are loads of them in the database, usually with a
quite massive datatrack as track one, and then some music tracks at the end.
//[bnw]
Citerar Bogdan Butnaru [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
On
Just like me, to forget the most common case :)
-- Bogdan Butnaru — [EMAIL PROTECTED]
I think I am a fallen star, I should wish on myself. – O.
On 7/27/06, Thomas Tholén [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Also there are the actual game discs which sometimes have cd-player-playable
music tracks on
On 7/27/06, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
[beth] Nikki, sorry, you have extreme knowledge on the Japanese artists,
many of us don't. In my opinion your instance here is looking at this in the
same light many of us see the Japanese guidelines. I believe this was
specifically speaking in terms of
18 matches
Mail list logo
