Frederic Da Vitoria wrote:
Don and Jan,
You realize this would mean a very big annotation, since each track
was from a different source?
[and]
Not practical, to say the least ;-) And anyhow, annotations are not in
the database way of thinking.
Well then you should propose a track--url
2006/4/10, Jan van Thiel [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
On 4/10/06, Don Redman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Um, sorry if I disagree with everyone here, but IMO this is
ExtraTitleInformation which does not belong into the TrackTitle and should
be left to the AlbumAnnotation (except if it were used to
] On Behalf Of Frederic
Da Vitoria
Sent: Tuesday, April 11, 2006 3:07 AM
To: MusicBrainz style discussion
Subject: Re: [mb-style] Contextual information in track title
2006/4/10, Jan van Thiel [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
On 4/10/06, Don Redman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Um, sorry if I disagree with everyone
Vitoria
Sent: Tuesday, April 11, 2006 3:07 AM
To: MusicBrainz style discussion
Subject: Re: [mb-style] Contextual information in track title
2006/4/10, Jan van Thiel [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
On 4/10/06, Don Redman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Um, sorry if I disagree with everyone here, but IMO
On Tue, 11 Apr 2006, Beth wrote:
Is a large album annotation so daunting? I've seen a few. I offered to do
it. So far I haven't seen even the comment annotation noted. Yet less a
request that I do it. I am more than happy to do it.
Large annotations can currently cause problems with some
2006/4/11, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
I see your point, and I am trying to straddle an argument, and come to
acceptable. Not truly step on toes, simply see to the future and strive for
lack of loss to data. ;)
I know :-) And this is what makes this collective work interesting. No
single person
On Sat, 08 Apr 2006 15:27:32 +0200, Frederic Da Vitoria wrote:
About mod 4578355,
The original title was: Canitque de Jean Racine From the Film Babe,
clearly wrong since From the Film Babe is not really part of the
title. After asking advice in the IRC, Nyght added a mod to change it
to
On 4/10/06, Don Redman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
On Sat, 08 Apr 2006 15:27:32 +0200, Frederic Da Vitoria wrote:
About mod 4578355,
The original title was: Canitque de Jean Racine From the Film Babe,
clearly wrong since From the Film Babe is not really part of the
title. After asking
2006/4/8, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
The way I look at this. We're cataloging albums. Granted, we have a tagger
and tagging capabilities. However, it is not our knowledge if end user does
not have the album, or does not keep the album all together. Eventually the
tagger will be able to add the
2006/4/9, Cristov Russell [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
2006/4/8, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
Therefore, the tag would show the annotation in perhaps the comment
box on whatever supported format the user utilized for
their music library.
The tagger should show information the way the user wants the
2006/4/9, Cristov Russell [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
2006/4/8, Beth [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
Therefore, the tag would show the annotation in perhaps
the comment
box on whatever supported format the user utilized for
their music
library.
The tagger should show information the way the user
About mod 4578355,
The original title was: Canitque de Jean Racine From the
Film Babe, clearly wrong since From the Film Babe is not
really part of the title. After asking advice in the IRC,
Nyght added a mod to change it to Canitque de Jean Racine
(from Babe). I would have rather used
2006/4/8, Cristov Russell [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
About mod 4578355,
The original title was: Canitque de Jean Racine From the
Film Babe, clearly wrong since From the Film Babe is not
really part of the title. After asking advice in the IRC,
Nyght added a mod to change it to Canitque de Jean
After thinking a little more about it, the real problem here is that I
couldn't find a clear style rule about this (although this situation
should not be really rare).
--
Frederic Da Vitoria
___
Musicbrainz-style mailing list
To: MusicBrainz style discussion
Subject: Re: [mb-style] Contextual information in track title
2006/4/8, Cristov Russell [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
About mod 4578355,
The original title was: Canitque de Jean Racine From the
Film Babe, clearly wrong since From the Film Babe is not
really part of the title
15 matches
Mail list logo
