Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-09-03 Thread Petri Helenius
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: A similar problem would be created if a web server relied on DNS that was only hosted on servers in New Orleans. Do you (or somebody) know of recent numbers of what percentage of domains have all their DNS servers in; a) same subnet b) same AS c) same geographic

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-09-02 Thread Bob Snyder
On Thu, Sep 01, 2005 at 09:41:40AM -0700, jc dill wrote: > It is sometimes the case in disasters that people from inside can call > out but that people from outside can't call in because the circuits into > the disaster area become overloaded. This would hold true especially in > the case wh

RE: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-09-02 Thread Scott @ .net
, 2005 5:57 AM To: nanog@merit.edu Subject: Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake > I've had several reports that cell phone users who can't make *or* > receive calls are successfully sending *and* receiving SMS. It

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-09-02 Thread Michael . Dillon
> I've had several reports that cell phone users who can't make *or* > receive calls are successfully sending *and* receiving SMS. It could be > that the problem is one of not enough cell channels and working phone > circuits for all the phone calls people want to make, but that the SMS > ch

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-09-01 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Thu, 01 Sep 2005 08:48:04 +0300, Petri Helenius said: > [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > > >It's clearly possible to find telco engineers with 5/10/15 years experience > >in > >running PSTN (might even find somebody with 40-50 years? :). It's possible > >to > >find network engineers with lots of B

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-09-01 Thread jc dill
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: But then, people don't really care about this, as cell is in the exact same boat and huge numbers of people rely on just their cell phone and no longer have a fixed line (in Europe at least). I have read accounts that suggest that cellphone subscribers from New Orlea

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-09-01 Thread Michael . Dillon
> But then, people don't really care about this, as cell is in the > exact same boat and huge numbers of people rely on just their cell > phone and no longer have a fixed line (in Europe at least). I have read accounts that suggest that cellphone subscribers from New Orleans only have one way s

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Petri Helenius
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It's clearly possible to find telco engineers with 5/10/15 years experience in running PSTN (might even find somebody with 40-50 years? :). It's possible to find network engineers with lots of BGP experience. Where do you find a senior engineer with 5+ years experience

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 31-aug-2005, at 21:19, Andy Davidson wrote: There are two types of VoIP: voice over a private, tightly controlled IP network, and voice over the public internet. Now obviously the latter is a risky proposition, as it imports all the limitations of the internet into the voice service.

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Wed, 31 Aug 2005 20:19:23 BST, Andy Davidson said: > Perhaps you've made a fair and good comment on the marurity of most > off-the-shelf voip products or implementations. But the key, in my > mind, is that VoIP across the internet, when done well, imports all of > the opportunities of intern

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Michael Loftis
--On August 31, 2005 2:03:01 PM +0100 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: <...> On the other hand, in a circuit switched network you can do all kinds of interesting stuff (such as restarting all your control software) without breaking your sessions. We're only now seeing this in IP, and I think it's not

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Andy Davidson
Iljitsch van Beijnum wrote: There are two types of VoIP: voice over a private, tightly controlled IP network, and voice over the public internet. Now obviously the latter is a risky proposition, as it imports all the limitations of the internet into the voice service. I'm not so sure; som

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Barry Shein
Sorry for the interruption but I wish just once I could follow a topical list where 50% or more of the traffic wasn't people posting or arguing about how this or that post was off-topic! The meta-banter gets worse than the banter; the latter at least usually touches on some possibly interesting

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Jay R. Ashworth
On Tue, Aug 30, 2005 at 03:48:52PM -1000, Randy Bush wrote: > the steering committee has been discussing the idea of a nanog blog. > of course it would be directed to operational content and not your > daily pointer to some cartoon etc. Manners, Randy. Cheers, -- jra -- Jay R. Ashworth

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Michael . Dillon
> With VoIP, packet loss and delay > eventually make the service useless. So VoIP fails harder than either > traditional IP apps and PSTN. That is only in theory. In practice, during times of impending congestion collapse, IP network operators reconfigure the network to cope. For instance when

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 31-aug-2005, at 10:04, Mark Foster wrote: I do see a risk in the move toward IP systems at the edge. At the core is a different story to at least some degree. Twas also pointed out that British Telecom are heading down the same track as Telecom NZ, and their rollout should be completed

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Michael . Dillon
> "Red Cross looks to IT for post-Katrina recovery" > http://www.computerworld. > com/securitytopics/security/recovery/story/0,10801,104250,00.html > > ..would perhaps elicit some operational suggestions from the peanut > gallery on how to perhaps assist in this effort, or prhaps contribute > to

Re: Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread Mark Foster
At the risk of replying to myself, The below article is about the core, not the edge Theres another article on Telecom's site relating to trials for edge IP equipment. So my take on the NZ situation was a bit warped. I do see a risk in the move toward IP systems at the edge. At the core i

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-31 Thread jc dill
Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote: Telephone companies struggled to restore service FYI - if you are trying to reach someone in the impacted area who has a cell phone but you can't get thru because "all circuits are busy" then give SMS a try. I exchanged 8 SMS messages[1] between 15:58 and 16:2

Replacing PSTN with VoIP wise? Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Mark Foster
Telecom New Zealand announced the other day their intention to do precisely this. "In relatively short order we will replace the entire PSTN and be delivering all our services for customers over the IP network. That has the potential to reduce costs for customers and put a lot more control a

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Matt Ghali
On Wed, 31 Aug 2005, Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote: If I was mistaken in thinking that the referenced article: "Red Cross looks to IT for post-Katrina recovery" http://www.computerworld.com/securitytopics/security/recovery/story/0,10801,104250,00.html ..would perhaps elicit some ope

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Michael Greb
On Tue, Aug 30, 2005 at 09:12:51PM -0400, Richard A Steenbergen wrote: > > > >>"In this age of cheap commoditized consumer electronics and > > >>advanced mobile technology, why can't all the people of a city make > > >>contact during an emergency? > > > > > >Simple: it's too expensive. > > > > >

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Steve Gibbard
On Wed, 31 Aug 2005, Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote: I'll file that comment where it belongs -- in file 13. If a major catastrophe, albeit more human than network-related (although lots of network-related issues here, too), isn't on-topic, than I fail to see what is. The danger here is that if

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
Wrong Paul. - ferg p.s. I'm doing a blog already. I also run a few networks. It's all relative. Feel free to experiment at will! ;-) - ferg -- Randy Bush <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> I'll file that comment where it belongs -- in file 13. manners, paul >> If a major catastrophe, albeit

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
You get high marks for your crumudgeon level. However, if I have to point it out and lead you to it like a child, then so be it. If I was mistaken in thinking that the referenced article: "Red Cross looks to IT for post-Katrina recovery" http://www.computerworld.com/securitytopics/security/reco

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Randy Bush
>> I'll file that comment where it belongs -- in file 13. manners, paul >> If a major catastrophe, albeit more human than network-related >> (although lots of network-related issues here, too), isn't on-topic, >> than I fail to see what is. > operational material maybe? nah, i'm just a confused

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
On Wed, Aug 31, 2005 at 01:22:13AM +, Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote: > > I'll file that comment where it belongs -- in file 13. > > If a major catastrophe, albeit more human than network-related > (although lots of network-related issues here, too), isn't on-topic, > than I fail to see what i

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Paul G
- Original Message - From: "Fergie (Paul Ferguson)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc: Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2005 9:22 PM Subject: Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake > > I'll file that comment where it

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
I'll file that comment where it belongs -- in file 13. If a major catastrophe, albeit more human than network-related (although lots of network-related issues here, too), isn't on-topic, than I fail to see what is. - ferg -- Richard A Steenbergen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Did I miss the memo

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
> >>"In this age of cheap commoditized consumer electronics and > >>advanced mobile technology, why can't all the people of a city make > >>contact during an emergency? > > > >Simple: it's too expensive. > > > >Keep this in mind when trading in your POTS service for VoIP service > >over the int

Donate [Was Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake]

2005-08-30 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
Apologies for the multiple posts, but I think this is important enough to warrant a follow-up. I send out a public challenge to each and every one of you reading this to make a donation to the American Red Cross, if for nothing else, think of it as a small effort to assist the Red Cross in their

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Jerry Pasker
On 30-aug-2005, at 22:08, Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote: "In this age of cheap commoditized consumer electronics and advanced mobile technology, why can't all the people of a city make contact during an emergency? Simple: it's too expensive. Keep this in mind when trading in your POTS servi

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
Me? I personally never trade my POTS for VoIP... - ferg -- Iljitsch van Beijnum <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On 30-aug-2005, at 22:08, Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote: > "In this age of cheap commoditized consumer electronics and > advanced mobile technology, why can't all the people of a city

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 30-aug-2005, at 22:08, Fergie (Paul Ferguson) wrote: "In this age of cheap commoditized consumer electronics and advanced mobile technology, why can't all the people of a city make contact during an emergency? Simple: it's too expensive. Keep this in mind when trading in your POTS serv

Re: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
And via Slashdot: [snip] "In this age of cheap commoditized consumer electronics and advanced mobile technology, why can't all the people of a city make contact during an emergency? Cell phone circuits filled up during 9/11 attacks and in the wake of hurricane Katrina very few victims can mak

RE: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Peering
lf Of Fergie (Paul Ferguson) Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2005 2:46 PM To: nanog@merit.edu Subject: Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake Via Reuters. [snip] Telephone companies struggled to restore service and measure the damage to their networks in Louisiana and Mississippi on Tue

Phone networks struggle in Hurricane Katrina's wake

2005-08-30 Thread Fergie (Paul Ferguson)
Via Reuters. [snip] Telephone companies struggled to restore service and measure the damage to their networks in Louisiana and Mississippi on Tuesday after Hurricane Katrina cut power and triggered severe flooding. A spokesman for BellSouth Corp., the largest local telephone company in the r