Ideally I’d like a stronger guarantee than that, e.g that all YANG modules in
WG-adopted IDs MUST have revision dates that reflect the most recent change to
that YANG (*). The key point is that other SDOs (such as BBF!) will often
develop YANG modules that (during the development phase) depend o
Hi -
I read the text as intended to make a distinction between the *date*
portion and the rest
of the revision statement. When a module is under development,
retaining a history
of specific incremental changes isn't terribly helpful, but changing the
date is essential
to helping tools d
Thanks. e.g rather than i.e sounds good, BUT my point (sorry if that wasn’t
clear) is that this sentence seems to be contradictory. It says:
Unpublished versions, i.e IDs, can reuse revision statements.
IDs MUST update their revision dates each time they are re-posted.
My suggestion of removing t
I think the issue is at the end of the sentence, my proposal:
- the Internet-Draft is re-posted.
+ the work is published (e.g., it becomes an RFC).
That said, for IETF drafts (not other SDOs), my understanding is that the
revision statement’s date value SHOULD be the date that the I-D i
Hi -
The situation with Internet-Drafts is what motivated this text in the
first place, so
I think it is important to retain that information. However, it seems
to me that
the "i.e." is too limiting, and should be replaced with an "e.g.".
Randy
On 8/11/2016 2:06 AM, William Lupton wrote:
A
All,
The text at the bottom of RFC 6087bis (draft 07) Section 5.8 seems unclear:
"It is acceptable to reuse the same revision statement within unpublished
versions (i.e., Internet-Drafts), but the revision date MUST be updated to a
higher value each time the Internet-Draft is re-posted”
Assumi
> On 10 Aug 2016, at 23:54, Alex Campbell wrote:
>
> I think in this case it would make sense to implement both the hypothetical
> standard module's state data (which would be device-agnostic, such as a
> boolean value indicating whether each configured rule is active) and also a
> device-spe
