Grand narratives vs Identitarianism

2018-11-06 Thread bbbbbb
This bogus standoff between Marxist and ‘Rousseauian' factions is not only shallow, but seems (despite calls for a grand unifying narrative for ’the left’) to be used to draw lines in the sand, fostering divisiveness, rather than a vision that will mobilise and empower. Perhaps some shadow of the

Re: a propos of nothing

2018-11-06 Thread Sean Cubitt
ect: > > # distributed via : no commercial use without permission > #is a moderated mailing list for net criticism, > # collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets > # more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l > # archive: http://www.nettime.or

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Keith Hart
Julia and Angela, Nettime was originally a club for the class of white male geeks who thought they were making a new internet in the 90s. This class, in vehicles such as unlike us, now fights a rearguard action against the FAANG monopolists. Ted and Felix at one time proposed winding up the list,

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Andreas Broeckmann
friends, i'm an active lurker on this list since 1996; my answer to angela's question ("What is Nettime's policy on whether or not it should give fascists a platform from which to recruit?") would be that "nettime" probably doesn't have a "policy" on anything, other than the openness to questio

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Willem van Weelden
Hi, just to make this clear once and for all : • I am not a bigot, fascist, alt-right troll or what not. • maybe i was a bit naiev in thinking that Alexander Bard was just a nuisance and someone with a rather unpleasant talk. Florian was so kind to notify me of his connections and rather suspect

Re: Taking sides

2018-11-06 Thread David Garcia
Yes please. This tiny splinter of the community says. Bard just stop. David On 6 Nov 2018, at 04:30, Lunenfeld, Peter B. wrote: > Hello All - > > Bard asked if the community wanted him to cease and desist. My vote > is yes. Not only are his politics abhorrent, he’s not here to engage in

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Jo M2M
Yes, the fundamental question lurking in any collective is "who cleans the toilet?". -- * please, don't other me * Jo van der Spek M2M v. Ostadestraat 49 1072SN Amsterdam http://schipholbrand.net dinsdag, 06 november 2018, 00:19p.m. +01:00 van Andreas Broeckmann a...@mikro.in-berlin.de : >frie

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread tbyfield
Julia, your questions — 'so, is that it?' and 'is this normal?'— are really important. A few years ago Felix and I pranked the list on April 1st by announcing that we were shutting down nettime: https://nettime.org/Lists-Archives/nettime-l-1504/threads.html But it wasn't entirely a p

Re: Taking sides

2018-11-06 Thread Alice Yang
> These two young women do they exactly what I have been asking for, they put > class first and identities second and thereby arrive at a Marxist analysis of > contemporary society from which we can build a proper left for the future. God! Asking women to put a gender and race neutral class firs

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Sean Smith
"Sorry" could also work very well here --- maybe even better than a recommendation. From: Willem van Weelden To: Julia Röder Cc: nettime-l@mail.kein.org Sent: Tuesday, November 6, 2018 7:09 AM Subject: Re: apropos "relax dear" Hi,just to make this clear once and for all :• I am

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Felix Stalder
At the moment, nettime is largely unmoderated, with a very small number of people set to manual approval by the moderators. The difficult part is, of course, to decide when to put someone on "moderation watch". Personally, I've been quite reluctant to do that, not for some absolutist notion of fr

Re: apropos of nothing

2018-11-06 Thread Nina Temporär
With all genuine due respect to Ted and Felix for the amount of work that comes with it - And with appreciation for your reflections on what needs to be changed, Ted, that came in while I was writing this - How can you seriously all repeat your trust in the moderation poiicies after what happen

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Menno Grootveld
Dear all, Although I certainly do not share all of Alexander's notions and ideas, and although I do not discount the possibility that he actually is one of these 'trolls', I don't support banning him from nettime permanently. I have to admit that I am a bit shocked by the eagerness with which

Re: Taking sides

2018-11-06 Thread Keith Sanborn
One can say gender and identity are de facto markers of disenfranchisement and hence of class. It is the understanding of “class” which needs deeper analysis. And it is the undoing of hierarchies of gender and identity within class struggle which might make possible future advances. On Nov 6,

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Alice Yang
A quick google search with his name brought me this gem: https://goo.gl/images/94Nics In my experience, only predators use this sort of rationale. Since nettime is a mostly male space, I’d like to propose that we adopt a community guideline asking participants to watch their misogyny and, when th

Re: apropos of nothing

2018-11-06 Thread tbyfield
I'd like to go back to lurking, but a few replies below. Mainly, this: Bard occupied too much space, so I hope we de-occupy it with more forward- or outward-looking things. Nettime does best when mods are seen and not heard. On 6 Nov 2018, at 15:22, Nina Temporär wrote: A Nazi gets granted th

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Willem van Weelden
Hi Sean, Ok point taken! I apologize for being unintentionally rude or insensitive. My intentions were other. gr w > On 06 Nov 2018, at 14:29, Sean Smith wrote: > > "Sorry" could also work very well here --- maybe even better than a > recommendation. > > > > From: Willem van Weelden >

Re: apropos of nothing

2018-11-06 Thread Sascha D. Freudenheim
As one of the (very?) few conservatives on this list—by which I mean conservative relative to the list as a whole—and someone who has been on the list for something like 20 years, I have a few observations: — Overall, I am impressed with the degree to which the move away from active moderating

Grzinic, Vienna, 8-10.11.2018, symposium GENEALOGY OF AMNESIA, MUMOK

2018-11-06 Thread Marina Grzinic
8., 9., and 10. November 2018 MUMOK//, Museumsplatz 1, 1070 Vienna, Austria SYMPOSIUM GENEALOGY OF AMNESIA Crushing Silences, Constructing Histories at MUMOK Museum of Modern Art Foundation Ludwig Vienna A symposium on the silencing of colonialism, anti-Semitism, and contemporary turbo-fasci

taking sides

2018-11-06 Thread allan siegel
Dear Nettime/rs I have also been lurking throughout this infuriating conversation that became increasingly self-indulgent and irrelevant and down the rabbit hole of leftist jargon, name dropping and other forma of grandstanding. To put it another way the discussion devolved rapidly and densely

Fascist "trolls," meta

2018-11-06 Thread Angela Mitropoulos
As briefly as possible, responses to various threads/remarks bundled up below: I've been on this list since, I think, 2003. This was the first time I've ever suggested someone be thrown off. As someone else noted, times have changed; but also, I can spot a fascist set of talking points because I'v

Re: Fascist "trolls," meta

2018-11-06 Thread Johnatan Petterson
hy. thank you for the thoughts suggested into me from your writing. i have obviously not been educated enough in US Politics to find an audience in my reply, i wish i knew if the Toqueville book i am currently reading on Democracy in USA (shall along my further reading )cross refer(s ) this followi

Re: Fascist "trolls," meta

2018-11-06 Thread Nina Temporär
Brilliant, thanks. Looking forward to read the links. And glad you went „meta“ and pulled this off with a certain authority, not allowing him to make you react to his/their game, In which they eternally try to assign to you either the part of a self-pitying, worthless victim, or that of an evil

Re: apropos "relax dear"

2018-11-06 Thread Julia Röder
about that > dear angela, > relax dear. > it is ok. > noone is recruiting anyone here. > chill. > best, > w so, is that it? silence about this from the whole list except from angela? do you all not say anything because you think this is trolling or this is normal?? On Sun, 4 Nov 2018 at 23:29,

mod note

2018-11-06 Thread nettime mod squad
[[ I'm going through the queue of messages that were held for various reasons — mainly because they came from addresses that don't precisely match the subscriber database or some other 'technical' problem. So the small burst of messages that seem to be out of sync with the discussion reflects p

Re: Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)

2018-11-06 Thread Rob Lucas
I’m glad to see that this interview has sparked an interesting debate. It’s been a pleasure to read all your thoughts, and I only regret that I didn’t push more on some of these important issues myself in the interview. But we could only cover so much ground. In private conversation with RMS I

Grand narratives vs Identitarianism

2018-11-06 Thread bbbbbb
This bogus standoff between Marxist and ‘Rousseauian' factions is not only shallow, but seems (despite calls for a grand unifying narrative for ’the left’) to be used to draw lines in the sand, fostering divisiveness, rather than a vision that will mobilise and empower. Perhaps some shadow of the

Re: apropos of nothing

2018-11-06 Thread hiya me
This. Morlock, come back to us. On Mon, Nov 5, 2018 at 6:54 PM tbyfield wrote: > Angela, all — > > Felix Stalder and I are the two people who've consistently moderated the > list for the last twenty years. We don't speak for each other, but for > my part the simple and straightforward answer to

Re: Identity and difference

2018-11-06 Thread Rachel O'Reilly
https://www.upress.umn.edu/book-division/books/toward-a-global-idea-of-race Rachel O'Reilly Artist | Writer | Curator | Research Curatorial Advisor, Ex-Embassy http://ex-embassy.com/en/ Seminar Leader, How to Do Things with Theory, Dutch Art Institute https://dutchartinstitute.eu Current Phone: +

Re: Taking sides

2018-11-06 Thread Lunenfeld, Peter B.
Hello All - Bard asked if the community wanted him to cease and desist. My vote is yes. Not only are his politics abhorrent, he’s not here to engage in dialogue at all, from what I gleaned from his shit-postings. He’s just a typist with a broadband connection and a Tourette twitch that compels