[opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread Tim Hempstead
Hi, I am having performance issues with my file server running SUSE Linux 10.0 (64bit on an Athlon64). The systems data disks consist of 4 200GB Samsung SATA drives on separate onboard ports on the motherboard which are then configured together as md0 using Linux software raid5 (giving 600GB usa

[opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread Tim Hempstead
John, Ok, I've tested again with both samba and SFTP. Samba is significantly quicker than SFTP with the iso file copying in ~5-6 minutes instead of the 35+ being shown by SFTP. But looking at top whilst the processes are running the system is doing virtually nothing during both transfers, (both

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread John Andersen
On Tuesday 13 March 2007, Tim Hempstead wrote: > Accessing the system via samba from a Windows XP box seems quite slow > as does accessing it via SFTP, (a sustained SFTP transfer using > Filezilla peaked at 310kb/s a 670MB iso image has just taken 35+ > minutes to transfer across between them)

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread Anders Johansson
Am Dienstag, den 13.03.2007, 09:50 -0900 schrieb John Andersen: > I just copied a 350meg iso across 100mbit network via samba in under 10 > minutes. > It pegged my linux nic at 7.4 meg for the duration according to gkrellm. I normally see 10M traffic in gkrellm when I copy stuff to and from my nf

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread John Andersen
On Tuesday 13 March 2007, Anders Johansson wrote: > Am Dienstag, den 13.03.2007, 09:50 -0900 schrieb John Andersen: > > I just copied a 350meg iso across 100mbit network via samba in under 10 > > minutes. > > It pegged my linux nic at 7.4 meg for the duration according to gkrellm. > > I normally se

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread Sunny
On 3/13/07, John Andersen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I think you will find that on local networks where nothing is less than 100meg that ssh is quite a bit slower than a well tuned nfs. As you said the magic word "well tuned nfs" ... :) Please, define well-tuned. Or direct me to a very nice

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread Magnus Boman
On Tue, 2007-03-13 at 16:17 -0500, Sunny wrote: > On 3/13/07, John Andersen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > I think you will find that on local networks where nothing is less > > than 100meg that ssh is quite a bit slower than a well tuned > > nfs. > > > > As you said the magic word "well tuned

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread John Andersen
On Tuesday 13 March 2007, Sunny wrote: > Please, define well-tuned. Or direct me to a very nice tutorial for > this. Oh, no you don't Fella! ;-) I am not an nfs techie. I know very little about it, and only use if for MythTV shares, and I took the parms directly out of the mythtv how-to. So I'm

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread John Andersen
On Tuesday 13 March 2007, Tim Hempstead wrote: > John, > > Ok, I've tested again with both samba and SFTP. Samba is > significantly quicker than SFTP with the iso file copying in ~5-6 > minutes instead of the 35+ being shown by SFTP. But looking at top > whilst the processes are running the syste

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-13 Thread Tim Hempstead
Its certainly strange, the samba transfer rate is more the sort of level I was expecting. Top is supposedly showing nice time as well, and running a straight sar instead also gave the same results. Disabling ipv6, UseDNS(*), compression on the SFTP windows client all made little or no difference

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-14 Thread Anders Johansson
On Tuesday 13 March 2007 21:14, John Andersen wrote: > Have you tried to move a 650meg iso across nfs, and then do the > same move across ssh from and to the same source/destination? > > I think you will find that on local networks where nothing is less > than 100meg that ssh is quite a bit slower

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-14 Thread John Andersen
On Wednesday 14 March 2007, Anders Johansson wrote: > Just in case you're still interested, I'm doing this now, and I'm getting a > constant data rate of over 10MB/s (in real data, not bits over the wire). > This means a 100MB file transfers in 9 seconds, or 1024MB in 1 minute 34 > seconds. All usi

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-15 Thread Anders Johansson
On Thursday 15 March 2007 06:48, John Andersen wrote: > On Wednesday 14 March 2007, Anders Johansson wrote: > > Just in case you're still interested, I'm doing this now, and I'm getting > > a constant data rate of over 10MB/s (in real data, not bits over the > > wire). This means a 100MB file trans

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-16 Thread David Brodbeck
John Andersen wrote: > My point was, that without testing a samba or nfs transfer > you have no way of judging the load imposed by scp. > I kind of wish there was a flag to tell scp to negotiate the password in a secure way, but *not* to encrypt the transfer. Often, when I'm copying files over

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-16 Thread John Pierce
But scp is so convenient for doing copies compared to the trouble of setting up an NFS mount (and then dealing with processes hanging in the D state every time the server is down.) -- I use rsync and ssh to backup our home directories and the initial transfer of my folder was about 2.0+ GB and

Re: [opensuse] [SLE] Slow transfers from Linux Server

2007-03-16 Thread John Andersen
On Friday 16 March 2007, David Brodbeck wrote: > John Andersen wrote: > > My point was, that without testing a samba or nfs transfer > > you have no way of judging the load imposed by scp. > > I kind of wish there was a flag to tell scp to negotiate the password in > a secure way, but *not* to encr