[peirce-l] Christop Koch's science / religion paper

2006-07-02 Thread Steven Ericsson Zenith
For those curious about the paper I mentioned previously - you can find it here : http://www.klab.caltech.edu/~koch/religion-06.pdf With respect, Steven --- Message from peirce-l forum to subscriber archive@mail-archive.com

[peirce-l] Re: Neuroquantology Journal

2006-07-02 Thread Steven Ericsson Zenith
Dear Patrick, My thanks for your interesting response. At the start of the 20th Century it was, perhaps, still acceptable for Peirce and Whitehead to contend that "that holding religious beliefs and maintaining a responsible and coherent scientific attitude were fully compatible with one anot

[peirce-l] Re: Sinsign, Legisign, Qualisign - help!

2006-07-02 Thread Bill Bailey
Patrick, I'm don't know what in my post you're replying to. I don't keep my posts, so I can't be sure, but I don't recall mentioning an "expression continuum," "segments" or "meaning continuum." I may have; I sometimes think I only think I know what I say or mean. My post (I think) had to do wi

[peirce-l] Re: Neuroquantology Journal

2006-07-02 Thread gnusystems
Re Crick and Koch and their theories of consciousness: What Koch actually says in his recent book is "that consciousness emerges from neuronal features of the brain" (p. 10). For a detailed review, see http://users.vianet.ca/gnox/Koch.htm . Koch and Crick are near the reductionist end of the co

[peirce-l] Re: Neuroquantology Journal

2006-07-02 Thread Patrick Coppock
Hi Steven, You wrote: Koch is fairly religious (Catholic) - and has recently written about his religion on his web site - and without making aspersions upon his integrity I do find that a number of scientists in the field that are prepared to accept such magic are also religious. As a resul

[peirce-l] Re: Sinsign, Legisign, Qualisign - help!

2006-07-02 Thread Jerry LR Chandler
Dear Patrick:A few quick notes from Salzburg as I found your comments of interest and perhaps I can clarify some issues.My goals are more concerned with a coherent philosophy of science, especially a coherent relation between chemical philosophy and biological philosophy and medical philosophy.  Pe

[peirce-l] Re: Sinsign, Legisign, Qualisign - help!

2006-07-02 Thread Patrick Coppock
Hi Bill, you wrote: I think it is not very useful to speak of signs as existing in the same process as existential objects, but if we must, perhaps we can say, "Yes, signs exist, but much faster than objects do." Well yes I guess so. The sign function may be construed (rather simplistically

[peirce-l] Re: 1st image of triangle of boxes (MS799.2)

2006-07-02 Thread merkle
Dear Joe, WOW! :) Thank you for the comments. Within Peirce's Systematic Philosophy, the scope of a visualization of Peirce's classes of signs, as I develop in my thesis, is grounded on mathematics (discrete or finite), assumes phenomenology (the cenopythagorean categories), and only touches u