How to debate slavery on pen-l

2000-10-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Rather than using dueling quotations, perhaps Louis for some of the other heavy hitters in this debate should tell us what is so important. To me, it sounds sort of dogmatic to rule out either the importance of slavery or of internal social relations within Britain. Perhaps it would be similar

Re: How to debate slavery on pen-l

2000-10-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Michael Perelman wrote: Rather than using dueling quotations, perhaps Louis for some of the other heavy hitters in this debate should tell us what is so important. It is important to link slavery with the rise of capitalism as people like Karl Marx, Eric Williams and Robin Blackburn do. In Ellen

Re: Re: How to debate slavery on pen-l

2000-10-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Lou, I have been criticized, and rightly so, for not having enough about discrimination and race in my Pathology book. I don't know that that diminishes the parts that I did discuss. In fact, I can be criticized further concentrating on the U.S. economy, which better than some other subjects.

Re: Re: How to debate slavery on pen-l

2000-10-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Lou, both seem to have been investigating the origins of capitalism, without saying that external factors were not important. They were just exploring the importance of one side of the equation, even saying that they gave it the primary role; but not excluding slavery. If I read this wrong,