RE: BioRDF: URL Statements

2006-10-02 Thread Booth, David (HP Software - Boston)
> From: Matthias Samwald > . . . > 3) What current proposals about the 'resolution' of URIs do > is trying to force four different things into a single URI: I don't know which proposals you mean, but forcing these into the same URI is definitely not what the TAG recommends in the WebArch[1], e

Re: BioRDF: URL Statements

2006-09-30 Thread Eric Neumann
Matthias,These points wrt LS URIs resonate quite well with me... Continuing on with this reasoning, it would appear the only difference URI resolution offers (for pure RDF data only) is getting back a set of RDF statements from the URI authority. This does not represent all the existing RDF triples

Re: BioRDF: URL Statements

2006-09-29 Thread Susie Stephens
Xiaoshu, The idea behind the short URI statements is to get some input as to what people's thoughts are regarding URIs. The short statements are therefore just a tool for helping us to generate a document. They will not form part of a URI. The short statements are being collecting on the Bi

Re: BioRDF: URL Statements

2006-09-29 Thread Matthias Samwald
1) Most URIs on the Semantic Web are symbols for things, e.g. a concept or a physical object 2) Things like concepts and objects cannot be 'resolved' through the internet. 3) What current proposals about the 'resolution' of URIs do is trying to force four different things into a single URI: a.

RE: BioRDF: URL Statements

2006-09-26 Thread Xiaoshu Wang
--Susie, > John Barkley has proposed the following examples of short statement: > 1. Identify MIME Types of URIs. > 2. Identify versions of URIs > 3. URIs should dereference to something, even if it is only > documentation,e.g., rdfs:comment 4. Use LSIDs I might missed a bit of background, but

Re: BioRDF: URL Statements

2006-09-26 Thread Phillip Lord
> "SS" == Susie Stephens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: SS> John Barkley has proposed the following examples of short SS> statement: SS> 1. Identify MIME Types of URIs. SS> 2. Identify versions of URIs SS> 3. URIs should dereference to something, even if it is only SS> documentatio

Re: BioRDF: URL Statements

2006-09-25 Thread Susie Stephens
It was decided during a recent BioRDF call, that a good way forward in the creation of a URI document would be to collect short recommended practice statements from individuals. This would help us to more easily see where we agree and where there is controversy. Please either post your shor