Re: [qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-16 Thread thron7
On 12/16/2011 09:44 AM, Stefan Andersson wrote: T! This was answering the second part of my questions. Still one more: I agree completely with your opinion here. No overhead and total distribution -> less work and control = more focus on better and more code. How and when will it be integ

Re: [qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-16 Thread Stefan Andersson
T! This was answering the second part of my questions. Still one more: I agree completely with your opinion here. No overhead and total distribution -> less work and control = more focus on better and more code. How and when will it be integrated with the generator like with "svn://" ? Stefan

Re: [qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-16 Thread thron7
- I'd like to refer you back to a recent discussion of the same topic, here [1] and here [2], no need to re-iterate all the arguments from there. - But on a general note, I find the idea of a central 'qooxdoo-contrib' organisation on Github less attractive, because less contemporary. It forces

Re: [qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-15 Thread Martin Wittemann
Hey, What would be the best git solution of contributed code? We don't have a clear vision what to do with the contrib and how to move it to git. But I think one thing is clear. In times of github, where everybody can create a repo with one click, is no need for having such a general repositiry

Re: [qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-15 Thread Stefan Andersson
I think you seem to have answered the necessary questions and what you have been doing here can be used for qooxdoo-contrib. I would be glad to adhere to this approach if the core team can tell their opinion. Two more questions to the core team: 1. How does the generator comply with this? Can

Re: [qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-15 Thread Derrell Lipman
On Thu, Dec 15, 2011 at 14:35, Stefan Andersson wrote: > Derrell! > > Good to see it sharp in action! > > How do you solve the login credentials for different users? Is it possible > to separate different users? > Each user has his own github account and ssh keys. Now a submodule is as a branch

Re: [qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-15 Thread Stefan Andersson
Derrell! Good to see it sharp in action! How do you solve the login credentials for different users? Is it possible to separate different users? Now a submodule is as a branch and which makes it difficult to branch the submodules without getting plotted. What is your solution to that? Isn't

Re: [qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-15 Thread Derrell Lipman
On Thu, Dec 15, 2011 at 10:47, Stefan Andersson wrote: > Dear core team! > > What would be the best git solution of contributed code? > > - one repository independent of each contributed project? > > Should every contribution have its own branch in a common repository i.e. > different from qooxdo

[qooxdoo-devel] Git solution av contributions

2011-12-15 Thread Stefan Andersson
Dear core team! What would be the best git solution of contributed code? - one repository independent of each contributed project? Should every contribution have its own branch in a common repository i.e. different from qooxdoo? - this might be messy due to branches of each project Submodule