[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread Bill M.
The article leaves many unanswered questions. How much did he carry on his commute, how often did he need to stop, were there hills to climb, did he monitor his efforts by heart rate to screen out unintentional bias, was he trying to ride to the same perceived effort or the same speed? What

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread MKahrl
Do you think some unintentional bias was causing him to ride harder on the steel bike in order to keep the same time? If so, it was remarkably consistent over the course of 56 rides and nearly 1500 miles. Commuting with stop signs would give the lighter bike an even bigger advantage than in

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread Kelly Sleeper
In this case it's more of a riding style than the bike. As much as we would like to ignore or minimize the speed difference weight and equipment makes, it does exist. Even if in most cases it's areodynamics. 1 2 or 3 mph average speed is nothing right? It could still add up to 15 percent if you

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread cyclotour...@gmail.com
Here's the original article in the BMJ: http://tinyurl.com/23d7pmj or http://www.bmj.com/content/341/bmj.c6801.full?sid=da3c0aec-7122-47d1-bce4-a96cfdc1a583 On Dec 14, 8:14 am, Kelly Sleeper tkslee...@gmail.com wrote: In this case it's more of a riding style than the bike.  As much as we would

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread JoelMatthews
Thanks for the link. While the author does not describe the hubs on either bike, he does point out the plastic bike had lighter and obviously more expensive wheels than the steel (obviously as the entire steel bike cost him 50 pounds). Appears there are modest hills on his commute. Not sure

RE: [RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread jim phillips
It seems like he did the best he could to be unbiased. I cannot imagine doing this starting out with a particular result in mind. I think the results are valid. Jim Date: Tue, 14 Dec 2010 07:15:01 -0800 Subject: [RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious.. From: mkah...@gmail.com

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread cyclotour...@gmail.com
are valid. Jim Date: Tue, 14 Dec 2010 07:15:01 -0800 Subject: [RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious.. From: mkah...@gmail.com To: rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com Do you think some unintentional bias was causing him to ride harder on the steel bike in order to keep the same

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread William
the results are valid. Jim Date: Tue, 14 Dec 2010 07:15:01 -0800 Subject: [RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious.. From: mkah...@gmail.com To: rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com Do you think some unintentional bias was causing him to ride harder on the steel bike in order

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread William
That's true. In the news today, stem cell transplant cured HIV on the berlin subject. I think they threw in that the berlin subject should also lose some weight. On Dec 14, 3:09 pm, Steve Palincsar palin...@his.com wrote: On Tue, 2010-12-14 at 14:59 -0800, William wrote: I don't get why he

Re: [RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread cyclotourist
And wear a helmet. On Tue, Dec 14, 2010 at 3:55 PM, William tapebu...@gmail.com wrote: That's true. In the news today, stem cell transplant cured HIV on the berlin subject. I think they threw in that the berlin subject should also lose some weight. On Dec 14, 3:09 pm, Steve Palincsar

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread Kelly Sleeper
Oh NO.. not the helmet! On Dec 14, 6:59 pm, cyclotourist cyclotour...@gmail.com wrote: And wear a helmet. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To post to this group, send email to rbw-owners-bu...@googlegroups.com. To unsubscribe

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread charlie
Actually a cyclist should gain weight in the form of muscle in his legs (horsepower) and lose body fat overall thereby increasing his cardiovascular efficiency. Aerodynamics influence speed more than any factor including power output of the cyclist but given a similar riding position between the

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread doug peterson
I especially enjoyed Grant's notion that if cycling is fun, why would one want to rush it? ...muddle on... has been a successful riding technique I've enjoyed (thanks for giving it a name!) for quite a while. Hey, nothing like a good muddle on my Atlantis with no particular place to go nor

[RBW] Re: A blinding glimpse of the obvious......

2010-12-14 Thread charlie
Right on Doug..I enjoy coffee also. Glad to have contributed to the vernacular of cycling lingo. Confused as the word muddle is, that is exactly what we do when we ride with the idea that we must go ever faster from point A to point B on our bicycles or we just aren't doing it right.