Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-03-06 Thread Nils Philippsen
On Mon, 5 Mar 2001, Julie wrote: > From: Thomas Dodd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > > Julie wrote: > > > My reading of the GPL is that you only get in trouble if you > > > distribute a GPL'd work as an essential part of a larger non-GPL'd > > > product. If you distribute the two separately, the terms o

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-03-05 Thread Julie
From: Thomas Dodd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Julie wrote: > > My reading of the GPL is that you only get in trouble if you > > distribute a GPL'd work as an essential part of a larger non-GPL'd > > product. If you distribute the two separately, the terms of > > distribution of the non-GPL'd work have

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-03-05 Thread Thomas Dodd
Julie wrote: > > From: Thomas Dodd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Ivan Jager wrote: > > > > > > I think this is the relevant part of the GPL, but you should still read > > > the whole license. > > > > Read Donald Becker's take on this. He wrote many of the NIC > > drivers in/for the linux kernel (includ

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-03-02 Thread Julie
From: Thomas Dodd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Ivan Jager wrote: > > > > I think this is the relevant part of the GPL, but you should still read > > the whole license. > > Read Donald Becker's take on this. He wrote many of the NIC > drivers in/for the linux kernel (including the DEC tulip driver) [ T

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-27 Thread Ed Hill
http://www.tux.org/lkml/ Jalaja Devi wrote: > > HI, > > We are going to port Lucent's OCB PCI card driver in > to QNX. > can you tell me the mail-id to subscribe for > linux-kernel mailing list??? > > Thanks in advance - Jalaja -- // Ed Hill _ _ _ ___ <[EMAIL PR

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-27 Thread Jalaja Devi
HI, We are going to port Lucent's OCB PCI card driver in to QNX. can you tell me the mail-id to subscribe for linux-kernel mailing list??? Thanks in advance - Jalaja --- Karen Shaeffer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Good for you. Now you can move forward with > confidence. > > Which driver

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-27 Thread Karen Shaeffer
Good for you. Now you can move forward with confidence. Which driver are you going to port? BTW, kernel related questions are best dealt with on the Linux kernel mailing list. c, -- Karen Shaeffer Neuralscape; Santa Cruz, Ca. 95060 [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.neuralscape.com On Tue, Feb

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-27 Thread Jalaja Devi
Hi, all, The company for whom i am working for has the written permission from the author to goahead with porting the code. So, I guess there should not be any prb now!!! Jalaja --- Karen Shaeffer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On Mon, Feb 26, 2001 at 09:30:54AM -0600, Thomas > Dodd wrote: > > Iva

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-26 Thread Thomas Dodd
Karen Shaeffer wrote: > > On Mon, Feb 26, 2001 at 09:30:54AM -0600, Thomas Dodd wrote: Non-GPL drivers for the linux kerenl are allowed > > explicitly by Linus. > > This is true. But it is not what the questioner was intending to do. The > questioner specifically stated the intent was to port a

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-26 Thread Karen Shaeffer
On Mon, Feb 26, 2001 at 09:30:54AM -0600, Thomas Dodd wrote: > Ivan Jager wrote: > > > > I think this is the relevant part of the GPL, but you should still read > > the whole license. > > Read Donald Becker's take on this. He wrote many of the NIC > drivers in/for the linux kernel (including the

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-26 Thread Thomas Dodd
Ivan Jager wrote: > > I think this is the relevant part of the GPL, but you should still read > the whole license. Read Donald Becker's take on this. He wrote many of the NIC drivers in/for the linux kernel (including the DEC tulip driver) http://www.scyld.com/expert/license.html Non-GPL drive

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-26 Thread Mario Torre
On Fri, Feb 23, 2001 at 08:14:36AM -0800, Jalaja Devi wrote: > Yes the driver is GPL!! Don't worry!! > Well, Jalaj, there is something I think, and RedHat can help me to better understand if wrong. If you plan to port a GPL driver to a non free (and open) OS, you may run in trouble, that's rig

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-24 Thread Ivan Jager
Lars Nordin wrote: > > Not knowing that can get you in trouble - see these sites on the definition > of GPL, LGPL and licensing: > > http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/license-list.html > http://www.opensource.org/licenses/index.html > > Just because it open for distribution does not necessarily mea

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Lars Nordin
Not knowing that can get you in trouble - see these sites on the definition of GPL, LGPL and licensing: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/license-list.html http://www.opensource.org/licenses/index.html Just because it open for distribution does not necessarily mean that you can use it for commeric

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Karen Shaeffer
On Fri, Feb 23, 2001 at 08:14:36AM -0800, Jalaja Devi wrote: > Yes the driver is GPL!! Don't worry!! > > > Jalaja Devi wrote: > > > > > > HI, > > > I have to port a Linux2.x PCI device driver to QNX > > > platform. How to estimate the time duration of > > this > > > work? > > > > Is the driver

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Jalaja Devi
The documentation of the driver sez that it is GNU and open for distribution. I don't know the difference bet GPL, LGPL, GNU etc!! --- Thomas Dodd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Jalaja Devi wrote: > > > > Yes the driver is GPL!! Don't worry!! > > That the issue. You may have problems if the driv

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Thomas Dodd
Jalaja Devi wrote: > > Yes the driver is GPL!! Don't worry!! That the issue. You may have problems if the driver is GPL and the OS isn't. Is QNX GPL? Do you plan to distribute the driver or the patches? -Thomas > --- Thomas Dodd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Jalaja Devi wrote: > > >

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Lars Nordin
On Friday 23 February 2001 11:21, Lars Nordin wrote: > First, this is the work list to ask about QNX this is Red-Hat Development. ^^^ make that "wrong" not "work" ___ Redhat-devel-list mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://listma

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Lars Nordin
First, this is the work list to ask about QNX this is Red-Hat Development. Second, that was not what Thomas Dodd meant; You can not take the GPL'ed PCI device driver and put it into QNX since QNX is not GPL. You can rewrite the whole thing or use the device driver for the same PCI device from

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Jalaja Devi
Yes the driver is GPL!! Don't worry!! --- Thomas Dodd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Jalaja Devi wrote: > > > > HI, > > I have to port a Linux2.x PCI device driver to QNX > > platform. How to estimate the time duration of > this > > work? > > Is the driver GPL? > You should contact the author abo

Re: Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Thomas Dodd
Jalaja Devi wrote: > > HI, > I have to port a Linux2.x PCI device driver to QNX > platform. How to estimate the time duration of this > work? Is the driver GPL? You should contact the author about do the port since it may violate the driver's license to link it with a non GPL OS. This just came

Estimation of Device Driver!!

2001-02-23 Thread Jalaja Devi
HI, I have to port a Linux2.x PCI device driver to QNX platform. How to estimate the time duration of this work? I could not do this cuz, I dint write a full fledged device driver before. All i did was some maintenance stuff and the top half. regards, Jalaja __