Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-20 Thread roy . james
Hey Eric, I think I found the problem, and actually its pretty obvious. On Fetch my version of the build is returning -1 on the MODSEQ, see below 6 UID FETCH 7 (INTERNALDATE UID RFC822.SIZE FLAGS MODSEQ BODY.PEEK[HEADER.FIELDS (date subject from content-type to cc bcc message-id in-reply-to

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-20 Thread Eric Charles
Hi Roy, Good if you can take some time on this. To be honest, I think that MODSEQ has been working somewhere in between beta3 and beta4, but has been broken before beta4 release. So it doesn't work either (I think) with other mail clients (thunderbird,...) but those are maybe a bit more

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-20 Thread roy . james
Hi Eric, So this appears to be an issue with using JPA mailbox only. I assume that its not storing ModSequences? When I try running fetch on my implementation I do see my ModSeq values returning although I'll have to run a full test again using my iPad to confirm thats true with a full

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-17 Thread roy . james
Hi Eric, I mean perhaps zipping my build of beta4 and the config I have? You know what, I'll dropbox it anyway and share the folder, you should be receiving the link. Do you mind just running it and letting me know if you are seeing the same thing I am? I re-read your earlier response and

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-16 Thread Eric Charles
Hi, It seems to be a bit different here:- - CONSTORE-enabled and COMPRESS-disabled ; works fine - CONSTORE-enabled and COMPRESS-enabled ; breaks In any case, it's open different jira, and to link them (make a reference to/from each others). Prolly you mailbox impl has some other issue if it

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-16 Thread roy . james
Hey Eric, Should I send you a zip of what I got so we can confirm behavior? What are you running on btw and which iPad? Regards, Roy Rim On Mon, Apr 16, 2012 at 5:37 AM, Eric Charles e...@apache.org wrote: Hi, It seems to be a bit different here:- - CONSTORE-enabled and COMPRESS-disabled

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-14 Thread roy . james
Hi Eric, So disabling the CONDSTORE definitely resolved my issue with the IPAD (this is without COMPRESS). After disabling CONDSTORE I tried COMPRESS again and the same issue with Mail app breaking out kept happening so these are separate issues. Would you like me to add separate ticket for

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-13 Thread Eric Charles
Hi Roy, Thx for IMAP-366. The version numbering of IMAP modules is different from the server one, this is why you didn't see 3.0-beta3. You can set it to 0.3 which is the version of the IMAP library where the problem resides. I have added a comment on the compatibility wiki page: 'issue

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-13 Thread Eric Charles
Hi Roy, You are on the good track comparing beta3 and beta4 with wireshark! The main difference is the support of CONDSTORE extension (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4551). Could it be the cause? You can disable CONSTORE in beta4 spring-server.xml (1) with bean id=imapProcessor

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-12 Thread Eric Charles
Hi Roy, See comments inline. Thx, Eric On 04/11/2012 08:22 PM, roy.ja...@xemaps.com wrote: Hi Eric, Just to let you know my iPad2 is still doing thousands of loops trying to grab 3 messages from my test inbox even after removing the account and re-adding it. I wonder if I got something

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-12 Thread roy . james
Hey Eric, I created ticket IMAP-366, was not sure what I should add under affected version and fix version as there did not seem to be anything there that matched up with beta 4... I am unsure how to edit the compatibility page. The one on the WIKI seems really out-dated? I'm still seeing

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-12 Thread roy . james
Hi Eric, So loaded up a base installation of beta3, same domain and same test users. I disable the account on my ipad. Start up beta3, on different email clients I send a few messages back and forth between the 2 accounts. Enable the account. No problem. Disable account again. Turn on

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-11 Thread Eric Charles
Hi Roy, I have just migrated to beta4 (release), and indeed IMAP with compression enabled breaks ipad mail client in the way you describe. It works fine with compression disabled. Thunderbird works fine with compression enabled and disabled. Would you mind opening a JIRA [1] for this and

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-11 Thread roy . james
Not sure if I'm sending this twice... looks like original reply got mangled. So even with compress off my iPad keeps attempting to download the second message in the test inbox over and over again. But I will remove account and try from scratch agin and see what happens. BTW, were you asking

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-11 Thread roy . james
Hi Eric, Just to let you know my iPad2 is still doing thousands of loops trying to grab 3 messages from my test inbox even after removing the account and re-adding it. I wonder if I got something funky happening on our network but wireshark does not show anything out of the ordinary. Roy On

beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-10 Thread roy . james
Hi guys, So i've been working on my company's own customer mailbox implementation of James on Version 3 originally started with beta 3. I recently upgraded our code to work with beta 4 but now I notice that when I enable compression on the IMAP server my iPad will break out of the Mail app to

Re: beta 4 imap with compress and iPad

2012-04-10 Thread roy . james
To follow up I tried beta 4 with default configuration with jpa specified under mailbox. No compression set at the moment. With only 2 mailboxes setup. For some reason after the first message is picked up under the inbox for the test account the ipad starts freaking out checking for more