Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-05-19 Thread Matthieu Stone
Kev, Did your accountant point out any small business concessions that may be effect by class of shares? Thanks for these Mick. rgds, - matt. On 21 March 2011 11:44, Kev wrote: > Mick, thanks for sharing, could be very useful. I will be having a > chat with an accountant re these docs and pr

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-20 Thread Kev
Mick, thanks for sharing, could be very useful. I will be having a chat with an accountant re these docs and provide any useful feedback - one thing my accountant did point out in an initial chat is that there apparently are small business concessions (tax I assume) that kick on on a sale of a sma

Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-19 Thread Ryszard
thanks for this mick, its pretty cool that you share it with us. On 17 March 2011 23:43, Mick Liubinskas (Pollenizer) wrote: > Hi everyone, sorry this is so late. Took a while to scrub it clean. It > may not be the simplest thing to work out but blame the govt for not > making options work. > > R

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-19 Thread Tristan
Thanks for sharing Mick, excellent work getting around that. If there is one thing politicians must understand, it's that innovation in the private sector can circumvent ('game') nearly any legislation. They need to start considering this truth. I think the cultural barrier is the bigger issue

Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-18 Thread Michael Fox
Mick, Thanks so much for sharing these docs, very generous of you and it looks like a very good solution. Would you be happy to share the details of your contact at http://www.mk.com.au/ who put these together for you? Would love to have a chat to them as we're going through exactly this at the mo

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-18 Thread Robert Yearsley
Hey Mick - Thanks so much for sharing these docs, handing over bundles of green to tax lawyers to find a way though this debacle of short sighted tax policy must have been somewhat maddening. Looking at the complexities involved in making share options work for startups, it seems the administrat

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-17 Thread Mick Liubinskas (Pollenizer)
Hi everyone, sorry this is so late. Took a while to scrub it clean. It may not be the simplest thing to work out but blame the govt for not making options work. Read the summary first. As a way of quick explanation, instead of options you issue a two classes of shares/units. B class shares which

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-10 Thread Humphrey
Thanks Mick. Perfect timing! :) On Mar 10, 9:46 pm, "Mick Liubinskas (Pollenizer)" wrote: > Hi all, sorry for the delay. We've removed all of the specific info > and are just getting the docs double checked. I'll get them out > shortly. > > On Mar 10, 6:10 am, Humphrey wrote: > > > > > Hi Mick,

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-10 Thread Mick Liubinskas (Pollenizer)
Hi all, sorry for the delay. We've removed all of the specific info and are just getting the docs double checked. I'll get them out shortly. On Mar 10, 6:10 am, Humphrey wrote: > Hi Mick, Any chance you could share the Dropbox link agian? Thanks > > On Feb 28, 11:13 am, "Mick Liubinskas (Polleniz

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-03-09 Thread Humphrey
Hi Mick, Any chance you could share the Dropbox link agian? Thanks On Feb 28, 11:13 am, "Mick Liubinskas (Pollenizer)" wrote: > I've had a few requests for this, let me make sure the documents are > clean and I'll post a Dropbox link. > > Mick "Admin is my co-pilot" Liubinskas > > On Feb 24, 10:0

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-27 Thread Mick Liubinskas (Pollenizer)
I've had a few requests for this, let me make sure the documents are clean and I'll post a Dropbox link. Mick "Admin is my co-pilot" Liubinskas On Feb 24, 10:04 pm, "Mick Liubinskas (Pollenizer)" wrote: > To get around Australian option laws tax issues we've used a multi > class system where sha

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-24 Thread Mick Liubinskas (Pollenizer)
To get around Australian option laws tax issues we've used a multi class system where shares change class after a certain milestone (time or goal based). Then you combine that with a non interest loan and you get a pretty good working system. We've got documentation for a system like this that I'm

Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-23 Thread Clifford Heath
On 24/02/2011, at 10:48 AM, Jeromy Evans wrote: - if you're a company with real value, it's a disincentive that your employee has to be pay income tax on that right before it's realized as a gain (or loss). ie. we're offering you what we estimate is $10k worth of shares/options today, that will

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-23 Thread Jeromy Evans
On Feb 24, 3:03 am, Andrew Bruno wrote: > Isn't the value of what an item is worth really what one is prepared to buy > it for? > That's right, but employee share ownership has a different purpose. It's to provide an incentive (motivation) to employees and can be an instrument to retain employee

Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-23 Thread Andrew Bruno
I am curious. Person A owns a company A Pty Ltd. They also work for an employer ABC pty ltd. ABC decides to sell part their company. What's wrong with person A buying part of company's ABC Pty Ltd via their investment company A pty ltd just like they may buy anything else? shares, property, cars

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-23 Thread Jeromy Evans
On Feb 23, 11:51 am, Clifford Heath wrote: ... > Anyhow, that was the situation before the last round of changes. In   > this context, > can someone clarify what the changes were, and when tax is payable? > Division 83A introduced the new rules for shares or rights acquired by employees after 1

Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-22 Thread Clifford Heath
* And by "Thoughts?", I mean, "does anyone have any relevant thoughts on the Australian Federal Government's taxation regime of options and its reform" I received options in a startup we did in the 90's, and the rules then depended on the vesting price. I.e. if your company's shares were curre

Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-22 Thread David Lyon
On Wed, Feb 23, 2011 at 11:27 AM, Geoff Langdale wrote: > > Frankly I don't want to subsidize either (or both?) of the major > parties after having our interests so comprehensively ignored. A lot > of us will just vote with our feet (see also the exodus to San > Fransisco) or find ways to work aro

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-22 Thread Geoff Langdale
David: yes, I'm subtle like that. Our messages crossed for some reason, so don't think my previous message in this thread is in response to yours. Thanks for the (on-topic) contribution. I think the fear of rorting is the major problem but this won't be the first or last part of the tax code that

Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-22 Thread David Lyon
Hi Geoff, I was actually going to leave this thread alone but I detected you were trying to secretly message me. In Canberra, I discussed this recently with some Government Officials. What they said went close to this "Well we did something like that for the film Industry and the whole thing got

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-22 Thread Geoff Langdale
It's a dumb move by the government. Not so much the issue of paying taxes but forcing startup employees to pay taxes up front on assets that might be worth 10x or 0x and are extremely hard to value. I don't think the key issue is wanting to dodge or minimize tax here, it's not to take a potential h

Re: [SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-20 Thread Elias Bizannes
The story behind this is that the Rudd government -- likely reacting to public anger with senior executives making money during times of massive layoffs -- decided that if you were given stock options, you were taxed at that point (even if you never exercised the right to purchase stock with your o

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-20 Thread Jeromy Evans
Hi, I receive cash salary + stock as part of my package in Australia. As a result, I pay personal income tax on the valuation of the stock at (approx) the time it is *issued* to me. That is, I pay tax now on a benefit that may not be realized. This is due to a recent Australian tax ruling (I forg

[SiliconBeach] Re: Stock options common in offer packages

2011-02-20 Thread Geoff Langdale
Is there any recent news on the incredible mess that the Australian government made of ESOP-type programs? Last thing I saw was from about 8 months ago in a post by David Jones, indicating that this is 'still in the too-hard basket'. If there are government types who care about this they are keepin