Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-17 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sat, 07 Apr 2012 09:27:53 -0700 JSL Internet wrote: > Thank you for the detailed post. It is clear that you have some > understanding of best practices regarding digital PCB layout. However, > you've made a number of assumptions and generalizations. Are you > certain that there are no

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-11 Thread Bjarke Istrup Pedersen
2012/4/11 Svenning Sørensen : > > > On 10-04-2012 15:12, Jan Ceuleers wrote: >> Svenning Sørensen wrote: >>> Two machines sending high rates of UDP packets to each other would make >>> the box hang rather fast, often within a few seconds under certain >>> loads. >>> I made a few fixes to the 3.2.13

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-11 Thread Svenning Sørensen
On 10-04-2012 15:12, Jan Ceuleers wrote: > Svenning Sørensen wrote: >> Two machines sending high rates of UDP packets to each other would make >> the box hang rather fast, often within a few seconds under certain >> loads. >> I made a few fixes to the 3.2.13 driver which seem to have solved the

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-10 Thread Jan Ceuleers
Svenning Sørensen wrote: > Two machines sending high rates of UDP packets to each other would make > the box hang rather fast, often within a few seconds under certain loads. > I made a few fixes to the 3.2.13 driver which seem to have solved the > hangs as well as another major problem (the one ad

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-10 Thread Svenning Sørensen
On 08-04-2012 22:54, Soren Kristensen wrote: And it is a fact that the Linux VT6105M driver had bugs, reported to be fixed in Linux 3.3. And that the atheros and/or wlan drivers had/have bugs, don't know if fixed. Opgrade to Linux>= 3.3 and we can continue talking. I have observed the via-rhi

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Nenhum_de_Nos
On Sun, April 8, 2012 07:59, Soren Kristensen wrote: > I still have the problem that nobody running FreeBSD and OpenBSD have > reported similar issues, somebody correct me if I'm wrong. I don't know if it counts, as I use PCI atheros card. But I have: FreeBSD cygnus.apartnet 8.1-RELEASE-p4 FreeB

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Alan
> Looking though the archieves I found two reported issues, both on Linux. > > 1) The thread in Sept/Oct 2010, concluding with Andrey Safonov reporting > the Linux VIA VT6105M driver to have bug, and how to fix it: > > http://lists.soekris.com/pipermail/soekris-tech/2010-October/016884.html > http:

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 08 Apr 2012 22:54:42 +0200 Soren Kristensen wrote: > A quick and easy way to check power supply issues is to lower the TX > power on the wlan card, have you tried that ? Yes. I went as far down with TX power until i hardly got a connection. My subjective impression was that it helps a

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Soren Kristensen
Hi Attila, Sometimes you postings are well thought out, like the one at 12:03 today, but then you do postings like this where it sounds like you have no idea what you're doing Attila Kinali wrote: .. > > Attached is a picture of an DDR SRAM chip mounted at the bottom of > the net5501. For

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Soren Kristensen
Hi Attila, Attila Kinali wrote: > > Could be. I think that's unlikely. I rather think that the wlan card > has a spiky power need, probably drawin ~300mA for very short periods. > The VIA6105M should have about the same spikyness, but with less power > consumption. As both share their power supply

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Bjarke Istrup Pedersen
2012/4/8 Soren Kristensen : > Hi Attila, > > Attila Kinali wrote: >> On Sun, 08 Apr 2012 01:34:58 +0200 >> Soren Kristensen  wrote: >> >>> Alvar Kusma wrote: > As I have stated before, afaik the net5501 do not have any design > issues, Attila's problem is most likely either software re

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Jan Ceuleers
On 08/04/12 13:22, Attila Kinali wrote: > Could be. I think that's unlikely. I rather think that the wlan card > has a spiky power need, probably drawin ~300mA for very short periods. > The VIA6105M should have about the same spikyness, but with less power > consumption. As both share their power s

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Aragon Gouveia
On 04/08/12 13:26, Alvar Kusma wrote: >> I still have the problem that nobody running FreeBSD and OpenBSD have >> reported similar issues, somebody correct me if I'm wrong. > > Just to point one: > > http://lists.soekris.com/pipermail/soekris-tech/2011-December/017988.html You can add another to t

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Attila Kinali
On Wed, 4 Apr 2012 11:01:51 +0900 Alan wrote: > On Sun, Apr 1, 2012 at 7:05 PM, Attila Kinali wrote: > > > I finaly got the time to work on this again and got my net5501 > > working without crashes even under heavy load and using wlan at full > > power. At least not within 24h. > > Great that

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Lev Serebryakov
Hello, Soren. You wrote 8 апреля 2012 г., 14:59:21: > I still have the problem that nobody running FreeBSD and OpenBSD have > reported similar issues, somebody correct me if I'm wrong. It seems, that I have some interference between eth0 and WiFi in MiniPCI slot, but I've always attributed it

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Lev Serebryakov
Hello, Attila. You wrote 8 апреля 2012 г., 14:10:22: > Do you use eth0? If yes, try not using it. The VT6105M of eth0 shares > its power supply pins and capacitors with the mini PCI interface. > If your crashes are so rare, it might be enough that not using that > interface is enough to get you in

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Alvar Kusma
> I still have the problem that nobody running FreeBSD and OpenBSD have > reported similar issues, somebody correct me if I'm wrong. Just to point one: http://lists.soekris.com/pipermail/soekris-tech/2011-December/017988.html -- == ___ Soekris-tech

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 08 Apr 2012 12:59:21 +0200 Soren Kristensen wrote: > Attila Kinali wrote: > > You repeat this argument over and over. But apearently, you are the only > > one who knows about these race conditions. I cannot find any reference > > to the race condition on the VT6105M at all. And for the at

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 8 Apr 2012 12:49:17 +0200 Flemming Jacobsen wrote: > Attila Kinali wrote: > > If i had a software problem, why does the behaviour change if > > i connect two 1000uF capacitors to the powersupply pins available > > at J5? And how come the whole issue disapears after soldering three > > doz

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Soren Kristensen
Hi Attila, Attila Kinali wrote: > On Sun, 08 Apr 2012 01:34:58 +0200 > Soren Kristensen wrote: > >> Alvar Kusma wrote: >>> As I have stated before, afaik the net5501 do not have any design issues, Attila's problem is most likely either software related, >>> >>> Please, can you explain,

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Alvar Kusma
> Do you use eth0? If yes, try not using it. The VT6105M of eth0 shares > its power supply pins and capacitors with the mini PCI interface. This is the reason i obtained net5501-s - need for more than 3 ethernet NIC-s on router, _real_ NIC-s, and not those vlan capable 5 port internal "smart swi

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Flemming Jacobsen
Attila Kinali wrote: > If i had a software problem, why does the behaviour change if > i connect two 1000uF capacitors to the powersupply pins available > at J5? And how come the whole issue disapears after soldering three > dozen of capacitors at various places? This screams "My PSU was sub par f

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sat, 07 Apr 2012 23:03:43 +0300 Alvar Kusma wrote: > > As I have stated before, afaik the net5501 do not have any design > > issues, Attila's problem is most likely either software related, > > Please, can you explain, why similar board from PCEngines (Alix 2D13) > with same software (Open

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 08 Apr 2012 01:34:58 +0200 Soren Kristensen wrote: > Alvar Kusma wrote: > > > >> As I have stated before, afaik the net5501 do not have any design > >> issues, Attila's problem is most likely either software related, > > > > Please, can you explain, why similar board from PCEngines (Alix

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Alvar Kusma
> The net5501 have 4 ethernet ports, 1 Mini-PCI slot and 2 PCI expansion > slots each with 4 interrupt lines. Therefore the 4 interrupt pins on the > Geode LX need to be shared along the possible devices. PCI Interrupt > sharing is part of the PCI specification and should in principle not be >

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sat, 07 Apr 2012 20:32:41 +0200 Soren Kristensen wrote: > Are not really interested in commenting on Attila, especially as you > seems to have received private emails off list (or the one with photo is > stuck in our spam filter). It is not private and it is not stuck in your spamfilter

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-08 Thread Alvar Kusma
> The Linux VT6105M driver has interrupt race problems, reported to have 2D13 has same ethernet chip. Just FYI - i have 10+ Alix boards, all without this sort of problems. Just used net5501 boards simply because i need 4 or 5 LAN interfaces, Alix is limited to 3 (i don't count usb NIC-s as real

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-07 Thread Alan
On Sun, Apr 8, 2012 at 8:34 AM, Soren Kristensen wrote: > Hi Alvar, > > Alvar Kusma wrote: >> >>> As I have stated before, afaik the net5501 do not have any design >>> issues, Attila's problem is most likely either software related, >> >> Please, can you explain, why similar board from PCEngines (

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-07 Thread Soren Kristensen
Hi Alvar, Alvar Kusma wrote: > >> As I have stated before, afaik the net5501 do not have any design >> issues, Attila's problem is most likely either software related, > > Please, can you explain, why similar board from PCEngines (Alix 2D13) > with same software (OpenWRT image) just works, but Soe

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-07 Thread Alvar Kusma
> As I have stated before, afaik the net5501 do not have any design > issues, Attila's problem is most likely either software related, Please, can you explain, why similar board from PCEngines (Alix 2D13) with same software (OpenWRT image) just works, but Soekris board shows some unstability?

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-07 Thread Soren Kristensen
Hi Jeff, JSL Internet wrote: > Attila, > >Thank you for the detailed post. It is clear that you have some > understanding of best practices regarding digital PCB layout. However, > you've made a number of assumptions and generalizations. Are you > certain that there are no power and ground

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-07 Thread JSL Internet
Attila, Thank you for the detailed post. It is clear that you have some understanding of best practices regarding digital PCB layout. However, you've made a number of assumptions and generalizations. Are you certain that there are no power and ground layers within the net5501 multi-layer

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-04 Thread Nix
On 4 Apr 2012, Alan told this: > On Sun, Apr 1, 2012 at 7:05 PM, Attila Kinali wrote: > >> I finaly got the time to work on this again and got my net5501 >> working without crashes even under heavy load and using wlan at full >> power. At least not within 24h. > > Great that someone is working on

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-03 Thread Alan
On Sun, Apr 1, 2012 at 7:05 PM, Attila Kinali wrote: > I finaly got the time to work on this again and got my net5501 > working without crashes even under heavy load and using wlan at full > power. At least not within 24h. Great that someone is working on this, but 24 hours is not much. If I re

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved (Attila Kinali)

2012-04-02 Thread Bob Gustafson
On Tue, 2012-04-03 at 01:27 +0200, Attila Kinali wrote: > On Mon, 02 Apr 2012 09:54:16 -0700 > JSL Internet wrote: > > > You claim to have solved a mystery but you did not provide any > > technical details of the problem or the solution. This is a support > > list but instead of being suppor

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved (Attila Kinali)

2012-04-02 Thread Attila Kinali
On Mon, 02 Apr 2012 09:54:16 -0700 JSL Internet wrote: > You claim to have solved a mystery but you did not provide any > technical details of the problem or the solution. This is a support > list but instead of being supportive or asking for support, you are > being critical of a product t

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved (Attila Kinali)

2012-04-02 Thread JSL Internet
Attila, You claim to have solved a mystery but you did not provide any technical details of the problem or the solution. This is a support list but instead of being supportive or asking for support, you are being critical of a product that most users do not have any trouble with. Without k

Re: [Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-02 Thread Jan Ceuleers
On 01/04/12 12:05, Attila Kinali wrote: > Can it be fixed? Not really. It's a design issue. The only way to > really fix it is to change the design and redo the boards. > If you already own a net5501, the only thing you can do is, to patch > it up until the crash probability reaches a level where y

[Soekris] net5501 inexplicable crashes under load and using wlan - mystery solved

2012-04-01 Thread Attila Kinali
Moin, Some might remember that i talked a few times about crashes of my net5501 under heavy load or when using wlan. Eg when i switched wlan on and did generate some traffic it didn't take more than 5 minutes to crash the net5501. I finaly got the time to work on this again and got my net5501 wor