Re: [OSM-talk] Overhaul of voting process (was: Road crossings proposal - status?)

2008-05-08 Thread Celso González
On Thu, May 08, 2008 at 08:42:55AM +1200, Robin Paulson wrote: 2008/5/8 Christoph Eckert [EMAIL PROTECTED]: For those who think the RFC/vote process represents the consensus on how things should be done, what needs to happen to change that process? IMO map features should be

[OSM-talk] Overhaul of voting process (was: Road crossings proposal - status?)

2008-05-07 Thread Stephen Gower
On Tue, May 06, 2008 at 11:01:33AM +0200, Frederik Ramm wrote: Hi, * Some people started tagging *and rendering* crossings, using a particular tagging scheme. * Some other people, who weren't actually out doing the work, started complaining about what was going on [1] May I take this

Re: [OSM-talk] Overhaul of voting process (was: Road crossings proposal - status?)

2008-05-07 Thread Christoph Eckert
Hi, For those who think the RFC/vote process represents the   consensus on how things should be done, what needs to happen to   change that process? IMO map features should be built on top of tagwatch. This way tagging recommendations would be built on top what's actually used. Much more

Re: [OSM-talk] Overhaul of voting process (was: Road crossings proposal - status?)

2008-05-07 Thread Robin Paulson
2008/5/8 Christoph Eckert [EMAIL PROTECTED]: For those who think the RFC/vote process represents the consensus on how things should be done, what needs to happen to change that process? IMO map features should be built on top of tagwatch. This way tagging recommendations would be

Re: [OSM-talk] Overhaul of voting process (was: Road crossings proposal - status?)

2008-05-07 Thread DavidD
2008/5/7 Robin Paulson [EMAIL PROTECTED]: using tagwatch is a good idea as a basis for proposals, but problems arise when we have two ways of tagging the same type of item. how does anyone decide which should be used? one must be more optimal than the other. having two methods running

Re: [OSM-talk] Overhaul of voting process (was: Road crossings proposal - status?)

2008-05-07 Thread Robin Paulson
2008/5/8 DavidD [EMAIL PROTECTED]: 2008/5/7 Robin Paulson [EMAIL PROTECTED]: using tagwatch is a good idea as a basis for proposals, but problems arise when we have two ways of tagging the same type of item. how does anyone decide which should be used? one must be more optimal than