Re: [talk-au] Murray River relation deletion?

2023-05-23 Thread Little Maps
Hi Graeme, that’s a whopper isn’t it. It contains a hotch potch of adjacent waterbodies, but the m/polygon works well to define outer and inner boundaries (islands). Given it’s not all a ‘river’, the multipolygon tags would perhaps be more accurate if the tag water=river was removed, leaving jus

Re: [talk-au] Murray River relation deletion?

2023-05-22 Thread Graeme Fitzpatrick
Have spotted a bit of a similar issue here: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/6168517#map=13/-28.0105/153.4332, which has a natural river & a few "streams" running through lots of dredged out canals e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/593943553#map=13/-28.0018/153.3810. Does this really ne

Re: [talk-au] Murray River relation deletion?

2023-05-22 Thread Little Maps
Thanks Warin and Cleary, I’ll remove the lake from the relation and cut the relation back to the river banks. I agree, there’s no need to add name or other tags to the riverbank (natural=water) tags as these details are already on the waterway and the waterway relation. Warin, I’ve never seen a

Re: [talk-au] Murray River relation deletion?

2023-05-22 Thread cleary
I agree with your proposed action to separate the lake from the remainder of the river. Related to this is the question of whether riverbanks should be named. I would name a waterway and its relation but not a riverbank multipolygon. I would have thought that a search for "Murray River" would n

Re: [talk-au] Murray River relation deletion?

2023-05-22 Thread Warin
On 22/5/23 16:09, Little Maps wrote: Hi folks, just checking to make sure I'm not missing something here... There's a large relation called 'Murray River' which covers all of Lake Hume, plus an upstream section of the Murray. This is a natural=water 'riverbank' relation, not a waterway relat

[talk-au] Murray River relation deletion?

2023-05-21 Thread Little Maps
Hi folks, just checking to make sure I'm not missing something here... There's a large relation called 'Murray River' which covers all of Lake Hume, plus an upstream section of the Murray. This is a natural=water 'riverbank' relation, not a waterway relation. https://www.openstreetmap.org/relatio