Re: [OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-17 Thread joost schouppe
I'm enjoying working on the task myself. Here are a few of the cases that show what this project is all about: http://maproulette.org/map/2789/3111819? http://maproulette.org/map/2789/3119207? http://maproulette.org/map/2789/3111814? http://maproulette.org/map/2789/3117909?

Re: [OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-14 Thread joost schouppe
If you want to follow up on the task, here's some useful links: Maproulette reporting: http://maproulette.org/ui/metrics/2789 General overview of mapping work: https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-changesets?comment=roadcompletionprojec#8/50.750/4.180 All relevant changesets, in case you want to

Re: [OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-14 Thread joost schouppe
Unfortunately, you have to reload the task every time of you want to keep working on a local area. Though the team behind maproulette wants to improve that.for now, you can use your browser developer tools to identify the task number and paste that in an url. But not exactly user friendly. We

Re: [OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-14 Thread Marc Gemis
> You can go to the overview of the challenge (what you call 'task', the > collection of all wegenregister cases) by selecting the little 'cogs' on the > top right and then click 'view challenge', then you get all the little task > on one big map. This way you can select tasks in your area.

Re: [OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-14 Thread Ben Abelshausen
You know I probably agree with most of the 'mapping based on imagery' remarks! ;-) It's on our feature request list for maproulette to limit to area and yes joost has a map with all the differences so you can use that (it's in fact the background map in maproulette) but the big advantage of

Re: [OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-14 Thread Marc Gemis
It would be nice if I could find limit the "tasks" to an area I'm really familiar with or that I have surveyed. I know Joost has a map somewhere that shows the differences. But I might easily fix all the problems in my town without leaving the computer right now. I know this is not how MapRoulette

Re: [OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-14 Thread Ben Abelshausen
Marc, Thanks for the not-so-positive feedback. I'm a bit disappointed by the quality of wegenregister as a comparison basis (but I should have known better by now) but I'm still conviced about the general idea. In the beginning we had another subset of the data with only what we are relatively

Re: [OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-14 Thread Marc Gemis
I've tried a couple of "tasks". I found it pretty hard to fill in the proper road type without being familiar with the local situation. The fact that Wegenregister adds a name to each and every long drive way is not going to help with the OSM data quality. So I gave up and went back to processing

[OSM-talk-be] road completion project

2017-11-14 Thread joost schouppe
Hi, Ben and I have been working on "the road completion" project for quite some time now. The idea is to build a toolchain that harvests any open data source on road networks, and turn it into a list of "possibly missing roads in OSM". For a project overview, look here: