Re: [Talk-ca] Internal CanVec conflicts

2012-11-15 Thread Tom Taylor
I've just performed my first edits, in our neighbourhood. One thing I noticed was that some of the buildings are duplicates. I assume this is part of what you are talking about when you mention internal CanVec conflicts. In the case of a local public school, I deleted one of the copies and

[Talk-ca] Primacy of GPS Traces (was Re: Internal CanVec conflicts)

2012-11-15 Thread Tom Taylor
As a geocacher, I'm unhappily aware that different brands of GPS give different results, with differences in the order of 10 meters for an individual point. I suppose a track should be better, since there is an internal consistency check, though not if the difference is due to systemic causes.

Re: [Talk-ca] Internal CanVec conflicts

2012-11-15 Thread Paul Norman
From: Tom Taylor [mailto:tom.taylor.s...@gmail.com] Subject: Re: [Talk-ca] Internal CanVec conflicts I've just performed my first edits, in our neighbourhood. One thing I noticed was that some of the buildings are duplicates. I assume this is part of what you are talking about when you

Re: [Talk-ca] Primacy of GPS Traces (was Re: Internal CanVec conflicts)

2012-11-15 Thread Connors, Bernie (SNB)
Tom, Differences in GPS results has less to do with the GPS brand and more to do with how the GPS is used, the type of antenna, the satellite geometry, WAAS reception, etc. If you placed your consumer grade GPS receiver in the exact same location on two different dates you will get

Re: [Talk-ca] Appropriate level of detail and map rendering

2012-11-15 Thread Pierre Béland
This history shows the area were you mapped : http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/changesets?bbox=-75.6989%2C45.372%2C-75.6065%2C45.4037 Your changeset comments are detailed and describe well what you do. This helps other mappers monitoring what is done in the area. A bad habit is having a

Re: [Talk-ca] Primacy of GPS Traces (was Re: Internal CanVec conflicts)

2012-11-15 Thread Pierre Béland
Tom I have a Garmin Etrex HCX.  I had the opportunity to compare my results while hiking with a  friend wich has a Garmin GPSMAP 62. The antennas seems to make the difference, especially when there is a coverage in forests.  Even with the same brand you may notice differences. When opening

Re: [Talk-ca] Internal CanVec conflicts

2012-11-15 Thread James Ewen
A really simple answer that gets lost is this: Did you make the edits to the best of your ability, and your edits add value to the OSM project? If so, then it was the right thing to do. We all bring different levels of ability, and may not do things perfectly according to the experts, but if

[Talk-ca] Bus maps for Ottawa

2012-11-15 Thread Tom Taylor
I was looking at Helsinki for solutions to a lane mapping problem (how to map left turn lanes), and noticed they have bus routes specified as relations on the road segments. This put me in mind of Ottawa. My first thought was to check on copyright issues. I learned that Ottawa has an open data

Re: [Talk-ca] Internal CanVec conflicts

2012-11-15 Thread Pierre Béland
North of Québec province, and probably elsewhere in Canada, I see a lot of objects identified with created by=Dshpak_landsat_lakes. These are apparently traced by  the Lakewalker JOSM Plugin that vectorize landsat imagery. See http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/JOSM/Plugins/Lakewalker There

Re: [Talk-ca] Bus maps for Ottawa

2012-11-15 Thread Pierre Béland
Tom this Ottawa license seems compatible with ODbl. Then, I think that the data can be imported. You can add to the relation the tag source=City of Ottawa. I have not done any yet, but it does not seem to complicate.  Wiki pages should give godd information. Also, looking at some Bus

Re: [Talk-ca] Bus maps for Ottawa

2012-11-15 Thread Mike Boos
Hi I was actually thinking of something similar for the Region of Waterloo, for both the routes and bus stop data, which is available under an Open Data License ( http://www.regionofwaterloo.ca/en/regionalGovernment/OpenDataLicence.asp) I am exploring the use of a tool called GO-sync for

Re: [Talk-ca] Bus maps for Ottawa

2012-11-15 Thread Pierre Béland
Mike, Waterloo license is based  UK Government's Open Government Licence and is considered as a true OpenData license. It is not the case for all canadian cities and governments. For my city, Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu, the data is available but the license is to restrictive. I will have to

Re: [Talk-ca] Primacy of GPS Traces (was Re: Internal CanVecconflicts)

2012-11-15 Thread Daniel Begin
Agreed about GPS behaviour, and do not take for grant your 3m accuracy. I got 3m accuracy measurement on my GPSmap 60CSX but a much larger differences looking at my traces, with the same device, the same track, same day, but under different meteorological condition. Multiple tracks are always

Re: [Talk-ca] Bus maps for Ottawa

2012-11-15 Thread Pierre Béland
Richard, Do we have a page somewhere that indicate the status of various municipalities and governements licences in Canada ?   Pierre De : Richard Weait rich...@weait.com À : Pierre Béland infosbelas-...@yahoo.fr Cc : Tom Taylor tom.taylor.s...@gmail.com;