Re: [Talk-GB] Vanguard Way - Anyone from the Kent / Sussex border?

2013-10-30 Thread David Fisher
There appears to be a user named VanguardWay ( http://www.openstreetmap.org/user/VanguardWay/edits) who has been systematically adding Vanguard Way to all ways along the route, all in mid-September of this year. To their credit, I suppose, they've added it as an extra name with a forward slash

Re: [Talk-GB] Vanguard Way - Anyone from the Kent / Sussex border?

2013-10-30 Thread David Fisher
(P.S. and as a local, I can confirm that no ways are actually named Vanguard Way on the ground, at least not in the Croydon area) On Wed, Oct 30, 2013 at 7:27 AM, David Fisher djfishe...@gmail.com wrote: There appears to be a user named VanguardWay (

Re: [Talk-GB] Vanguard Way - Anyone from the Kent / Sussex border?

2013-10-30 Thread SomeoneElse
David Fisher wrote: (P.S. and as a local, I can confirm that no ways are actually named Vanguard Way on the ground, at least not in the Croydon area) Thanks for that. It's something that happens fairly regularly around my patch too - people add the name of the long distance route to the

Re: [Talk-GB] Editor backbground layers in iD

2013-10-30 Thread SomeoneElse
Andrew Hain wrote: Is there a useful distinction between the two 1:25000 layers? In the area that I was looking at (just south of Kirk Ireton in Derbyshire) they appear to be different original maps, and it appears that coverage of each layer is slightly different. On the subject of the

Re: [Talk-GB] Editor backbground layers in iD

2013-10-30 Thread SomeoneElse
Rob Nickerson wrote: 2). iD is a general purpose editor. It can be used for OpenHistoricalMap too. Indeed - perhaps I should have been clearer that I'm talking about the instance in use on the OSM site used to edit the OSM map, not any other instance which presumably could feature any

Re: [Talk-GB] Editor backbground layers in iD

2013-10-30 Thread Michael Collinson
On 28/10/2013 19:28, SomeoneElse wrote: series, Mapbox Satellite or Mapquest Open Aerial, and if anyone's using NPE, Bartholomew 1/2 inch or OS 1 inch as backgrounds they probably shouldn't be using iD to do it (if for no other reason due to alignment issues). Am I maligning these sources and

[Talk-GB] London LOOP

2013-10-30 Thread Derick Rethans
Hey! I've recently started walking the London LOOP[1]. It's a 24 section walking tour around London which seems mostly fully mapped (yay!). However, it is mapped as one route which is rather large (245km). I wonder whether it would be a good idea to actually split it up in each of the

[Talk-GB] Vanguard Way

2013-10-30 Thread UrbanRambler1
Hi David, It looks like the Vanguard Way website uses OS maps, and the ways that form part of it in OSM haven't all been surveyed for e.g. surface, gates and stiles, and that sort of thing. I can assure you that I walked every bit of it last year, so I'd be surprised if many gates or stiles

Re: [Talk-GB] Vanguard Way

2013-10-30 Thread SomeoneElse
UrbanRambler1 wrote: Hi David, (it was me that said this, actually) It looks like the Vanguard Way website uses OS maps, and the ways that form part of it in OSM haven't all been surveyed for e.g. surface, gates and stiles, and that sort of thing. I can assure you that I walked every bit of

Re: [Talk-GB] Geological Data

2013-10-30 Thread Michael Collinson
It is an area that interests me too, explicitly surface expression of geology, (outcrops and faults mostly) and geomorphology (interesting drumlins, meander loops, landslips, ...). My personal conclusion is that by all means do low-key experimentation but that any systematic mapping is better

Re: [Talk-GB] Editor backbground layers in iD

2013-10-30 Thread Rob Nickerson
Hi Andy, I get all of your points on this one, but just as we generally don't go and remove other peoples custom tags, I think it would be a shame if we remove available layers. Having historical background layers can attract people to other projects (Open Historical Map). I've even used historic

Re: [Talk-GB] Editor backbground layers in iD

2013-10-30 Thread Paul Norman
From: SomeoneElse [mailto:li...@mail.atownsend.org.uk] Subject: Re: [Talk-GB] Editor backbground layers in iD Rob Nickerson wrote: 2). iD is a general purpose editor. It can be used for OpenHistoricalMap too. Indeed - perhaps I should have been clearer that I'm talking about the

Re: [Talk-GB] Editor backbground layers in iD

2013-10-30 Thread Rob Nickerson
Dealing with it from a UI perspective is difficult, and I get the impression that's the main issue, not the coding once the UI is figured out. I'm not a UI designer, but I'll have a go at sketching a few ideas over the next 7 days. It would be a shame to drop background layers where they are