Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Andrew Hain
You might want to ask for Nominatim to return relations for queries of road names. -- Andrew From: Paul Berry Sent: 25 June 2018 15:59:36 To: David Woolley Cc: Talk GB Subject: Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads Someone's had a brave go at

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Andrew Hain
You could also check the way histories to see if the local road names have been mapped in the past. -- Andrew From: Adam Snape Sent: 25 June 2018 17:11:04 To: Stuart Reynolds Cc: Talk GB Subject: Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads And, to actually

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Adam Snape
And, to actually deal with your question, I'd do a ground survey to see where the name changes. Failing that, the OS Open Map Local roads vector layer will show where the OS thinks the road name changes. Kind regards, Adam On Mon, 25 Jun 2018, 17:01 Adam Snape, wrote: > Hi Stuart, > > Sorry,

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Adam Snape
Hi Stuart, Sorry, to clarify I meant the Great North Road relation. It is entirely right that the verifiable current names are mapped. Kind regards, Adam On Mon, 25 Jun 2018, 16:41 Stuart Reynolds, < stu...@travelinesoutheast.org.uk> wrote: > What do you mean by the “this” that is to be

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Stuart Reynolds
What do you mean by the “this” that is to be mapped? Do you mean “Great North Road” or High Road / London Road, etc. The latter are not historic - they are current (as you can verify on e.g. Postcode Finder looking for 11 High Road, Beeston, Sandy) Regards, Stuart

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Adam Snape
Hi, If this is to be mapped shouldn't it be as a historic feature rather than a (current) road route? By the way I tend to use loc_name for a colloquial name regardless of whether it is just used by local people. Kind regards, Adam On 25 June 2018 at 15:59, Paul Berry wrote: > Someone's

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Paul Berry
Someone's had a brave go at defining that very relation: http://osm.org/relation/2776562 Feel free to extend it, bearing in mind the Great North Road != A1 (M or otherwise). Regards, *Paul* On 25 June 2018 at 14:44, David Woolley wrote: > On 25/06/18 14:13, Stuart Reynolds wrote: > >> So how

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread David Woolley
On 25/06/18 14:13, Stuart Reynolds wrote: So how should I tag this? I want to have the correct name for the sections of A1, yet I don’t know how far these extend (my data lists the street names at points, not over lengths), and equally I don’t want to lose the Great North Road tag - just to

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread SK53
Discussed as long ago as 2011 on Sabre: https://www.sabre-roads.org.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?t=28139#p571505. This discussion on Sabre highlights the fact that the Great North Road and current A1, A1(M) route may not always be identical. I know I might refer to older dual carriageway sections of

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Stuart Reynolds
Thanks, but that seems the wrong way round. When I said that they were local names, what I meant is that local bits of the A1 have different official names. So name=* . It isn’t a “local” usage in the same way that e.g. Squinty Bridge from the Wiki is. And “Great North Road” isn’t a local

Re: [Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Dave F
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names#loc_name DaveF On 25/06/2018 14:13, Stuart Reynolds wrote: local road names ___ Talk-GB mailing list Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

[Talk-GB] Local names of bits of trunk roads

2018-06-25 Thread Stuart Reynolds
So here’s a question. As the A1 passes Sandy in Central Bedfordshire, and further south, the road has local road names. For example, it is London Road past Sandy, and High Road as it passes Beeston to the south of Sandy. These names are verifiable from other sources, and while I note that