Re: [Talk-GB] FIXME and incorrect tags

2011-01-19 Thread Andy Allan
On Wed, Jan 19, 2011 at 9:55 AM, James Davis jam...@jml.net wrote: I've come across a few combinations recently of ways being tagged 'foo=bar;fixme=foo is wrong, please check'. If you know that the foo tag is definitely incorrect; isn't it better to remove it completely? Not in every case.

Re: [Talk-GB] FIXME and incorrect tags

2011-01-19 Thread SomeoneElse
On 19/01/2011 09:55, James Davis wrote: - Tools using the data won't easily be able to parse a freeform fixme tag. 'highway=motorway;fixme=highway tag clearly wrong, please correct' being a good example. But it's humans and not machines that edit the map. The fixme is for humans to read.

Re: [Talk-GB] FIXME and incorrect tags

2011-01-19 Thread Richard Fairhurst
Someoneelse wrote: For example, the simple editor in P2 doesn't show either note or the way ID (it is supposed to be simple after all; the advanced editing view does show both). FWIW my ambition for P2 is to have a non-prescriptive, friendly quality inspector that will tell you about the