Re: [Talk-us] National Forest boundaries

2020-06-24 Thread stevea
A refinement, perhaps Bradley and others agree with me, perhaps not. A USFS NF is a "virtual" multipolygon (not one in OSM, we can get to that later) of three kinds of things: 1) An "outer" (but not the biggest one) which is "the enclosing land which USFS manages, except for inholdings,

Re: [Talk-us] National Forest boundaries

2020-06-24 Thread stevea
On Jun 24, 2020, at 9:40 PM, Bradley White wrote: > NF congressionally designated boundary, minus private inholdings (more > specifically, non-USFS-owned land), gives you the boundary of land > that is actually managed and protected by the USFS. This boundary > should be tagged with

Re: [Talk-us] National Forest boundaries

2020-06-24 Thread Bradley White
> However, I'm not exactly sure how the outer polygons found in NFs differ from > either the "Congressional" boundary or the one Bradley says he would tag > "boundary=administrative" (and I don't think we should tag it that, > especially while excluding a specific value for admin_level), but

Re: [Talk-us] Is summit register something that is often found in USA mountains?

2020-06-24 Thread Tod Fitch
Summit registers are fairly common on the higher peaks in California. > On Jun 24, 2020, at 12:07 PM, Mike Thompson wrote: > > > > On Wed, Jun 24, 2020 at 1:03 PM Mateusz Konieczny via Talk-us > mailto:talk-us@openstreetmap.org>> wrote: > > > > Is summit register something that is often

Re: [Talk-us] relations on which thematic data can be connected? eg internet availabilty byt zipcode

2020-06-24 Thread Clifford Snow
Ray, As you learned from Spencer Alves, postal codes are not areas. As far as I know there are no zip code areas in OSM. I would recommend using QGIS and Postgis to construct your queries using OSM and TIGER zip code boundaries. Are you looking for any broadband connectivity, just cellular, DSL,

Re: [Talk-us] relations on which thematic data can be connected? eg internet availabilty byt zipcode

2020-06-24 Thread Spencer Alves
Zip Codes are Not Areas http://www.georeference.org/doc/zip_codes_are_not_areas.htm Specifically for Zip codes, the best you could do is query for addr:postcode. > On Jun 24, 2020, at 2:33 PM, Ray Kiddy wrote: > > Hello - > > I am interested in where people in the US lack internet connectivity

Re: [Talk-us] relations on which thematic data can be connected? eg internet availabilty byt zipcode

2020-06-24 Thread Ray Kiddy
Wow. Bizarre, but good to know. Yes, I _always_ have thought that zipcodes partition land areas. Now I have to wonder if ZCTAs are still around and if they are mapped. I expect not. much thanx - ray On 6/24/20 2:39 PM, Spencer Alves wrote: Zip Codes are Not Areas

[Talk-us] relations on which thematic data can be connected? eg internet availabilty byt zipcode

2020-06-24 Thread Ray Kiddy
Hello - I am interested in where people in the US lack internet connectivity and I keep thinking that I should be able to use OSM for some part of this. I am recalling (perhaps not accurately) that connectivity information is published by the FCC and I think that at least some of the

Re: [Talk-us] National Forest boundaries

2020-06-24 Thread stevea
I (momentarily?) recede from my "watching mode" in this thread to offer my agreement with Mike and to reiterate a slight disagreement with Bradley (or maybe to ask Bradley and especially the wider list here for clarification), as while it seems we get closer to a "more definitive" way to tag NF

Re: [Talk-us] Is summit register something that is often found in USA mountains?

2020-06-24 Thread Mike Thompson
Another feature that is often found at summits around here is a roughly constructed shelter, such as: https://images.app.goo.gl/KogTgXChrGx93Ab96 These have been made over the years by various hikers stacking rocks in a semicircle. One can sit down inside them and obtain some shelter from the

Re: [Talk-us] Is summit register something that is often found in USA mountains?

2020-06-24 Thread Mike Thompson
On Wed, Jun 24, 2020 at 1:03 PM Mateusz Konieczny via Talk-us < talk-us@openstreetmap.org> wrote: > > Is summit register something that is often found in USA mountains? At least in Colorado they are. Nowadays they are often pieces of pvc pipe. Mike ___

[Talk-us] Is summit register something that is often found in USA mountains?

2020-06-24 Thread Mateusz Konieczny via Talk-us
Is summit register something that is often found in USA mountains? ("A summit book or summit register is a record of visitors to the summit of a mountain. It is usually enclosed in a weatherproof, animalproof metal canister.") I am asking as I plan to implement summit register part of

Re: [Talk-us] National Forest boundaries

2020-06-24 Thread Brian M Hamlin
seconded stevea -- very interesting and cogent, definitely reading these National Forest expositions best regards from Berkeley, California   --Brian M Hamlin MAPLABS ___ Talk-us mailing list Talk-us@openstreetmap.org

Re: [Talk-us] National Forest boundaries

2020-06-24 Thread Mike Thompson
On Tue, Jun 23, 2020 at 7:35 PM brad wrote: > > There are a few cases where property owners have put up illegal, or very misleading signs. I have come across this too. The signs are on private property, but face you as you are traveling on a legal FS road and looking straight ahead. It makes